Sad
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Palestinian death toll rises to 1500.

This in a few days of bombs and missiles into civilian areas. This is before the ground offensive starts and before or the health system collapses. Two things that are about to happen.

This is likely to result in tens of thousands of deaths and many more due to starvation and disease. This is before we get to life changing injuries, which will be tens of thousands again.

I'm not shedding a tear for the Hama's fighters who targeted civilians but I am for everyone else. If a whole population must be made collectively responsible for the actions of their government then, well I deserve to die. By logical extension, I must be responsible for the Iraq war, Brexit and all the poverty caused by Tory austerity policies.

Do we value all lives equally? If we do, then we should be all be condemning the actions of the Israeli state.
newjaninev2 · 56-60, F
hamas is a terrorist organisation that has been sheltered, housed, fed, encouraged, lauded, and supported by the residents of Gaza.
While hamas terrorists were murdering Israeli families, while hamas terrorists were shooting Israeli babies or burning them alive, while hamas terrorists were firing missies at a music festival, while hamas terrorists were kidnapping Israeli citizens from their homes... the residents of Gaza were dancing in the streets, celebrating, and shouting their approval.

The dildo of consequences seldom arrives lubed.
BRUUH ·
@newjaninev2 Jane, I somewhat agree with you and somewhat disagree.

It's always wrong to kill civillians. However, it's hard for me to condemn military action which doesn't directly target civillians, but knows civillians will die yet is carried out anyways. I doubt world war two could have been won had we used the same morals of war that we have now. If we never did anything that resulted in civillian death, could we have defeated the third reich, Itally, and Japan? Probably not, hoenstly. So, what do we do???
Kwek00 · 41-45, M
@newjaninev2 I'm on to how these people think... because it's part of the phenomena in human society that I have a disgust for. Not only is it emotial and irrational, it's also extremely destructive. It's the same thinking you find with every genocide. But if you want to subscribe to it... go ahead, good luck... but keep it out of my backyard.
Burnley123 · 41-45, M
@newjaninev2 [quote]https://theintercept.com/2023/10/11/israel-hamas-disinformation/[/quote]
Tell Hamas not to behead little babies and then they maybe won't get attacked. As you know, civilian casualties are inevitable in any war, especially when the terrorists are hiding in schools and hospitals, but at least the Israelis make an effort not to target innocent civilians.
Guitarman123 · 31-35, M
@CactusJackManson when it destroys 400 Palestinian villages and forcibly removes Palestinian citizens from their homes. Israel put the target on its back
JSul3 · 70-79
@CactusJackManson I do not support the radical Sunni terrorist group Hamas.....nor do I support the butchery and land grabbing Netanyahu.
I do fully support the innocent people of Israel and the innocent Palestine people.

The Palestine people want a free state...the same thing Israel has.

Hamas is just like ISIS, al Queda, Hezbollah, and other radical Sunni. They need to be killed....but taking the lives of innocent civilians, is not acceptable!

Now Bibi demands that about 1 million people have 24 hours to evacuate to the south of a river....and one Israel official calls for them to be nuked?

There are no 'good guys' here....only innocent people on both sides being killed over religious beliefs.
Diotrephes · 70-79, M
@JSul3 [quote]Now Bibi demands that about 1 million people have 24 hours to evacuate to the south of a river....and one Israel official calls for them to be nuked?[/quote]

The Israelis are eager to commit another one of their many genocides. Committing genocides and ethnic cleansing is their favorite hobby.
JSul3 · 70-79
JERUSALEM (AP) — In Israel’s call for the evacuation of half of Gaza’s population, many Palestinians fear a repeat of the most traumatic event in their tortured history, their mass exodus from what is now Israel during the 1948 war surrounding its creation.

Palestinians refer to it as the Nakba, or “catastrophe.” An estimated 700,000 Palestinians, a majority of the prewar population, fled or were expelled from what is now Israel in the months before and during the war, in which Jewish fighters fended off an attack by several Arab states.

The Palestinians packed their belongings, piling into cars, trucks and donkey carts. Many locked their doors and took their keys with them, expecting to return when the war ended.

Seventy-five years later, they have not been allowed back. Emptied towns were renamed, villages were demolished, homes reclaimed by forests in Israeli nature reserves.

Israel refused to allow the Palestinians to return, because it would threaten the Jewish majority within the country’s borders. So the refugees and their descendants, who now number nearly 6 million, settled in camps in the West Bank, Lebanon, Syria and Jordan. Those camps eventually grew into built-up neighborhoods.

In Gaza, the vast majority of the population are Palestinian refugees, many of whose relatives fled from the same areas that Hamas attacked last weekend.

The Palestinians insist they have the right to return, something Israel still adamantly rejects. Their fate was among the thorniest issues in the peace process, which ground to a halt more than a decade ago.

Now, Palestinians fear the most painful moment from their history is repeating itself.

××××××××
I do not support the radical Sunni terrorist group Hamas. I do not support Netanyahu and his terrible policies and land grabbing corruption.

I do stand with the Palestinian people in their desire to have their own free state, just as Israel does. I stand with the innocent people on both sides, who are the victims of terror and war from Hamas and Netanyahu.

Who is going to step forward and demand a cease fire and stop this carnage?

I truly believe that the vast majority of Palestinians and Israelis want to live in peace and simply live their lives.
Diotrephes · 70-79, M
@JSul3 [quote]The Palestinians insist they have the right to return, something Israel still adamantly rejects. Their fate was among the thorniest issues in the peace process, which ground to a halt more than a decade ago.[/quote]

The Jewish Israeli doctrine is to never, ever, give up any land that they grab.
JSul3 · 70-79
@Diotrephes After Bibi levels Gaza, he will likely take it.....sounds like Putin.
Diotrephes · 70-79, M
@JSul3 That is netandyahoo's objective and then he will purge the West Bank, Lebanon, Syria, and possibly Jordan. And unless America gets its collective head out of its ass, it will aid and abet the ethnic cleansing and genocides like it is now doing to the people in Gaza.
the most important thing people should remember is that Israel and Ukraine are not America's problem
RedBaron · M
@orioninthenight OK, so if you don’t think personal attacks mean an automatic loss, what rule do you suggest instead? Why would that rule be better?

If you can supply a better rule, we’ll use that. Otherwise, we’ll stick with what we have.
@RedBaron hey wait I thought you said you were taking your win? lol

why are you still here?....the ego is strong in you....you probably spend your whole day protecting it from total strangers
RedBaron · M
@orioninthenight Not my ego so much as your hostility.
calicuz · 51-55, M
Those who condone the attack on civilian targets know nothing of the history of war.
To my knowledge, Germany was the first to target civilians and civilian instalation in WWl and it hasn't stopped since.
Men who truly know how to fight wars understand that a battle ground is to be chosen, away from civilians and the 2 sides do battle until one side is victorious.
There are no more men with honor in war, just ravishing murderers who love death, no matter who's death it is.
Diotrephes · 70-79, M
@HootyTheNightOwl [quote]Yeah, America should've just looked the other way and let the Japanese carry on mounting their base in Hawaii... Then Japan would have used that to attack the mainland.[/quote]

The Japanese never did make an attempt to land a military force in Hawaii.

[c=BF0000][b][i]Why Didn’t Japan Invade Hawai’i After Pearl Harbor?[/i][/b][/c]
"But a Japanese invasion never came. It was never a part of the plan to invade Hawaii after the attack on Pearl Harbor. The Japanese also passed up juicy targets in Australia and Ceylon where defenses were light and victory could have been easily secured if they had planned properly."
https://grantpiperwriting.medium.com/why-didnt-japan-invade-hawai-i-after-pearl-harbor-f1e11c5d72a9#:~:text=But%20a%20Japanese%20invasion%20never,if%20they%20had%20planned%20properly.
@calicuz

[quote]the dropping of the bombs was nothing more than a live human experiment[/quote]

That makes sense. America had been sitting stroking their new bombs for quite a while at that point.

Alternatively, though... Japan did catch America sleeping with Pearl Harbor. Had they known that the attack was imminent, there's no way they'd have left so much of their fleet there - so it's possible that the bombings were more to demonstrate to others at the time why it was a bad idea to try and spring surprise attacks like that.
calicuz · 51-55, M
@HootyTheNightOwl

If that's the true scenario, then I would have to agree.
JSul3 · 70-79
Yes, You Can Be Pro-Palestine and Anti-Hamas
This is one trap you really don’t have to fall into when you talk about war in Israel and Gaza.
BY DAVID FARIS
OCT 13, 202311:04 AM

From SLATE....a portion worth reading and considering, IMO:

More than any other single entity, Hamas (an Arabic-language acronym for the Islamic Resistance Movement) helped destroy the Israeli left and, with it, any meaningful prospect of a two-state solution to the conflict.

The group had plenty of help, of course, from Jewish extremists in Israel and maximalist right-wing politicians like Netanyahu himself. Not long after the famous 1993 handshake between Palestinian Liberation Organization leader Yasser Arafat and Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin on the White House lawn that kicked off the doomed Oslo peace process, an Israeli extremist gunned down dozens of Palestinians in a mosque, Rabin was dead from a Jewish assassin’s bullet, the settlements in territories that would need to be handed back to the Palestinians continued to inexplicably expand, and then, in 1996, Netanyahu was elected.

"Let all endeavors be channeled towards building a huge edifice for peace, instead of strongholds and hideouts defended by destructive rockets,” Egyptian President Anwar El-Sadat told the Israeli Knesset in a 1977 address that remains underappreciated for its timeless eloquence. “Be the heralds to your sons. Tell them that past wars were the last of wars and the end of sorrows.”

Sadat was maligned at the time for selling out the Palestinians and was himself assassinated by Salafi extremists very similar in outlook and principles to today’s Hamas madmen. But he was right: The Palestinians will not be made whole by inflicting sorrow on Israelis, by creating more grief-stricken parents and children, by inviting the inevitable and terrible retaliation that has already begun. Increasing the supply of grief only boosts the aggregate demand for savagery.

There are words in Sadat’s speech to heed for Israel as well. “No one can build his happiness at the expense of the misery of others,” he told a roomful of people whose army at the time was occupying and colonizing Egypt’s Sinai Peninsula. Here, again, Sadat was right. Israel will never, can never, be truly secure until the Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank are free and the still-in-limbo refugees find justice. The nation’s fearsome military, its stockpile of nuclear weapons, its separate peace treaties with other Arab states, its separation wall—all were unable to protect thousands from the weekend’s horrors. What Israelis do now with the stinging realization that the status quo of just a few days ago was an unsustainable delusion will determine the shape of the near-term future. Pure vengeance will get them nowhere. There is not, ultimately, enough room to dig the two graves in which both Israelis and Palestinians will be buried if revenge is enshrined as a principle worth defending.

++++++++++
Who will step forward and demand an end to the killings by both sides and begin the road to peace? We are all human beings and must live together. End this hatred and division NOW.
Diotrephes · 70-79, M
@JSul3 It will never end because the Israeli cabal thinks that the whole Levant area belongs to it. Therefore, the cabal will continue the process of ethnic cleansing until it is destroyed.
PhilDeep · 51-55, M
Yes, it's very sad that many can't seem to distinguish between supporting ordinary civilians while opposing those who by exerting power with weapons, are a threat to them, on both sides.
Bumbles · 51-55, M
War is a horrible thing, but Israel has a right to destroy Hamas. These deaths are tragic, but Hamas must never be permitted sanctuary again.
Burnley123 · 41-45, M
@Bumbles Minus Dresden is a big caveat. If we are talking about the bombing of cities then I'm against it. For one thing, the war was already won. The Brits especially wanted revenge for the blitz. Military targets are different
Bumbles · 51-55, M
@Burnley123 If your position is never to bomb/shell cities where civilians are, so be it. Military targets are not always so separate, of course, as is the case in Gaza.
Burnley123 · 41-45, M
@Bumbles I'm generally a dove anyway. I never said never bomb cities. I've given an answe on the current situation and your hand picked historical one. This is getting pretty abstract.
smiler2012 · 56-60
@Burnley123 why are countries of the world condemming what is going on in the middle east but not lifting a finger to stop the fighting and the killing of innocent people . not trying to get hamas and israel to the table too tallk peace or at least a cease fire whilst the talks go on
RileyLandS · 41-45, M
@smiler2012 bullshit. 56% of palestinians voted for hamas. they have themselves to blame.

hamas isn't a political party. they're terrorists
smiler2012 · 56-60
@RileyLandS i agree they are terrorists and no one is dispute that fact . but what about those forty four percent that never voted for hamas do they deserve to die over a power they never chose
RileyLandS · 41-45, M
@smiler2012 they don't 'deserve' to die, no. but they have to assume the risk. if they live in an area ruled by a terrorist organization, then bad things are bound to happen. i understand they may not be able to move/flee. that's sad but we as humans take risks all the time. here, unfortunately, they're risking their lives
Diotrephes · 70-79, M
@Burnley123 The goal is to not have peace but to have destruction so that the
Palestinians will be forced to leave the Levant. After all, the biblical claim is that all of the land from the Nile River to the Euphrates belongs to the Jews. The people in Gaza could soon be exterminated if they don't get water and food. And there's no obvious way to rebuild their infrastructure.
@Diotrephes Israel attacked the Liberty because it was broadcasting Israeli troop movements to the Egyptians. Interestingly, President Johnson called back two air support groups that attempted to assist the Liberty. It's possible that Johnson wanted the Israelis to sink it, so he could blame it on the Egyptians and give the US a reason to enter the war. Israel didn't need US help at that point as they had captured the Sinai the same day.

The only trap will be Hamas using the hostages to lure Israeli soldiers into positions where they can ambush them. I assume the Israelis are aware of this. If the Iranians are foolish enough to attack our carrier group, we will be at war with them, not Hamas. However, I'm sure Iran is more than happy to have Hamas do its dirty work.
Diotrephes · 70-79, M
@LeopoldBloom We shall soon see.
@Diotrephes We already saw.
JSul3 · 70-79
Question: How many deaths are Hamas terrorists and how many are innocent Palestinians?
specman · 51-55, M
@JSul3 No Israel is not targeting civilians. They are collateral damage.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
JSul3 · 70-79
@specman I got it. I doubt a 'select few' idiots speak for 2 million Palestinians.
HannahSky · F
Not getting into condemning Israel. Most people are concerned about civilians. If you're not, something is wrong with your thinking.
Burnley123 · 41-45, M
@HannahSky A number of the people on this page express support for killing Palestinian civilians.
HannahSky · F
@Burnley123 @Elessar like I said, something is wrong with your thinking if you're not concerned about civilians. Not to mention that military service is mandatory in Israel. It's not a volunteer military.
HannahSky · F
@Elessar I have to agree, it's not a sport to pick sides on. Most people don't seem to be able to fathom what war is.
Convivial · 26-30, F
Correct me if I'm wrong, but Hamas were in control because they were voted in by those people i believe?
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
Convivial · 26-30, F
@SatanBurger just to be clear... There is wrong on both sides... Israel is taking land that doesn't belong to them, and making the next generation of terrorist in the process.... Hamas was wrong with their attack.
Most people on both sides, just want to live in peace and enjoy life.
This tit for tat approach serves only to prolong the agony on both sides
Deceased · M
@Convivial Israel started it. It turns out people get touchy when you force them from whats been their ancestral home for generations. I'm Cherokee, so I take that shit, plus the slow systematic murder of the displaced people very seriously.
Hamas knew that Israel would retaliate and that it would be big. The Yom Kippur war resulted in 18000 it is a surprise to no-one that Israel will retaliate. Innocent people will die - war will rage on and the conflict that started so many years ago will never die.

It is so sad
spjennifer · 56-60, T
If someone is not cognizant that there are innocent civilians on both sides of this dispute, they shouldn't be discussing it. And I don't mean [b]you[/b] specifically. Sadly, innocent civilians, women and children alike are often the ones who pay for the follies of Man. Hamas are animals and deserve to be eradicated as they have caused more harm to their own people than Israel has. Israel is allowed to defend itself from the Hamas terrorists but there is going to be a cost for this for them too. I have served in multiple war zones since GW1 but thankfully never killed civilians, only enemy combatants, just like they killed lots of ours. Wars have existed almost as long as Man has and there is never justification for killing innocents...
spjennifer · 56-60, T
@Diotrephes And what of the atrocities committed by Hamas? I may not agree with how Israel is going about this but I do agree with them having the right to protect their citizens from terrorists. Because you think that Hamas aren't racist and bigots too? Seriously?
Diotrephes · 70-79, M
@spjennifer All of the leaders on both sides are true bastards and the world would be better off if they were to all drop dead this very second. It is the normal people who end up doing all of the suffering because the put evil people in charge of their affairs.

Read this =

[b][i][c=BF0000]WATCH: Israel is only the first target, warns Hamas commander
Mahmoud al-Zahar: "The entire planet will be under our law, there will be no more Jews or Christian traitors."[/c][/i][/b]
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12613241/hamas-commander-israel-just-beginning-gaza-strikes.html

The[b][i] Jerusalem Post [/i][/b]has a better article but it's archived. The basic content is the same.

edit typo
spjennifer · 56-60, T
@Diotrephes Agreed and in this case, part of it is a holy war in that Hamas and Hezbollah both receive significant financial support and arms from Iran who wants to kill all the Jews in Israel and create another Muslim State so there are other actors in this situation that deserve attention too...
Tastyfrzz · 61-69, M
Good question. I don’t think that rational thought is going to be happening for a while. How do they sort out the terrorists from the normal people? It's like sodom and Gomorrah.
@Tastyfrzz There are no normal people in palestine.
Tastyfrzz · 61-69, M
@NativePortlander1970 then i guess they'll all be turned to salt.
HoraceGreenley · 56-60, M
Hamas was duly elected and carried out the attack.

Israel is protecting itself.

Goodbye Hamas
Guitarman123 · 31-35, M
@HoraceGreenley both sides killing innocent people will never achieve anything
hippyjoe1955 · 61-69, M
@HoraceGreenley Yeah I wish things were that black and white. Sadly the more I look at it the more I doubt the narrative. Israel was arming Hamas and giving it money. The US was paying Hamas. Hamas operates in a large concentration camp with guards all around it. Egypt and Israel by land and Israel by sea keep a tight lid on the people in the area. How did it get the arms unless someone let them in? How did the practicing of the Hamas raid go unnoticed? Why were the guards asleep at the switch? Why was the much vaunted Iron Dome turned off? This has Israeli malfeasance written all over it. Then Israel engages in war crimes in revenge for what it allowed to happen. Hmmmmm
Diotrephes · 70-79, M
@hippyjoe1955 That's a very astute analysis of the situtation. I agree with your opinion on this matter as you have expressed it in your recent comment.
RedBaron · M
In response to the most murderous attack on Jews since the Holocaust.

Your silence on that is deafening.
RedBaron · M
@Burnley123 Once again, your silence is deafening.
Burnley123 · 41-45, M
@RedBaron I have stated my position clearly. I do not think that invading and killing that many people is a justified action, even if that does fully destroy Hamas, which it probably won't/.
RedBaron · M
@Burnley123 That’s nice.
Katie01 · F
They deserve it so we shouldn't really care
Thay been fighting 2000 years ...time to finish it.. one way or another,,
@Diotrephes be sad if that every takes place, not just for them .but the world,
Diotrephes · 70-79, M
@jackrabbit10 The loss of life would certainly be a very bad thing but the overall result might be a good thing because it could show all of the nuclear powers how really destructive nukes are to humanity and the world. It might even get them to destroy all of the thousands they have and convince even the nutcases to live in peace and harmony, thereby saving billions of lives and even the planet.

Iran has no real interest in attacking Israel; it is actually Israel that is the warmonger and has been threatenting to attack Iran for decades. Israel keeps pushing for America to do its dirty work but it is no secret that Israel has engaged in assassinating Iranians.
@Diotrephes lots to think about isn't it,,
Not told in your other words, but I understand they were expressed in intellectual understanding, which has a way of trying to pronounce, why am I here, instead of asking how to feel with empathy.
cerealguy · 26-30, M
[quote]If we do, then we should be all be condemning the actions of the Israeli state.[/quote]

Condemn. That word is in our handbook!!

Who did our masters tell us to only associate that with again? 🤔
Me lost my handbook
Steve42 · 56-60, M
Stupid tricks get stupid prizes.
lumberjackslam · 41-45, M
same reason Obama said no boots on the ground. they don't want to spill any of their own blood. what country would?! IDF were forced into it. Hamas leadership said they don't care about their own people, hence, they use them as human shields. what is driving your constant anti Israel bias? even after Palestinians acted like 12th century barbarians you still defended them. makes no sense.
specman · 51-55, M
Allelse · 36-40, M
Exactly
Renaci · 36-40
The fact that 10,000 years later people are still thinking one side over the other are the good guys is pathetic.
Good riddance to those terrorist vermin.
smiler2012 · 56-60
@Burnley123 you will of heard of the saying the casualties of war well the civilians of both israel and palestine are this alright 😞
@smiler2012 There are no innocent men or women in palestine by how they allow their children to become indoctrinated and as shields.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment

 
Post Comment