They have been given a gift of the taste of freedom and 20 years of education. Now, they need to use what they have been give and stand up for themselves. I bet they can do it... if they want to do it.
@NangiUniverse I would not go that far. Communists and socialists have no use for reactionary extremists but don't hate Muslims per se. Hell many Muslim majority countries have well established communist parties like Iraq. Many are also religious and see no contradiction. Just like you have Catholic communists in Latin America. In the holy city of Nejaf in Iraq they elected a communist woman to run the city because all sides trust them to not play favorites and take sides in sectarian nonsense.
In China the situation is a bit different since like in Chechnya it is a hotbed for extremism and terrorism. Many of the "poor uighurs" everyone in western media is lementing about are in allegiance with ISIS and Al Qaeda. Muslims were not popular in Russia for awhile when terrorists bombed the Moscow metro too.
most secular and moderate seem to count on communism as their last straw of hope for personal freedom.
I agree with the last bit.
SW-User
@NangiUniverse If I understand secularism properly, the want is not making religion into a straw issue and understand it's place. You seem to have a different view, but okay. Ie, if Israel does something I don't support in idea, I don't blame Jewish people, yet ..... you seem to be associating faith with wrongdoing? Correct me if my reading is wrong.
@Entwistle You haven't been called nor has it been revealed to you. You have no choice in the matter. Much like the time your parents conceived you and gave you birth. You were just along for the ride. Don't pride yourself on what you don't know or don't understand. Ignorance is never a point of pride.
On the contrary, they are guaranteed all the freedoms, rights, and aspirations of the religion they espouse, support, and practice... so how can they have a problem with that?
@OogieBoogie Im not berating and chastising Afghani women. On the contrary, I've been saying that they will now be able to exhibit the piety and devout practices required by their chosen religion. In fact, they’ll be actively encouraged to do so. Accordingly, I see no reason to spend time wailing about what I might perceive as their dire situation.
Yep .... I just peeked at the Afghanistan casualty counts and it shows about a dozen US casualties for all of 2020. Chicago matches that practically every Saturday night. And the mess in Chicago goes back a lot more than 20 years.
Military involvement in Afghanistan had drawn down significantly over the past few years and mostly it's been about air support and cheering the Afghan military on.
It was like Biden just yanked the rug out from under everything, suddenly surrendered unconditionally and and armed the Taliban to the hilt with US weapons.
There's something else going on here. And it smells.
@Heartlander Yes it does smell. Because all they care about is denying science when it comes to mother nature (climate change) and punishing the Political Right here in the USA today.
@DeWayfarer On this we mostly agree. I just think the American tendency to not even think about the consequences of disrespecting their allies played a bigger role here. They do it with "top tier" allies too. Even Canada is treated like a colony most of the time and it doesn't even seem to occur to the US government that could ever have consequences.
@OogieBoogie That's really not just a small detail. Characterizing oppression as a type of war gives undue legitimacy to the actions of oppressive governments by implying that the action in question is reciprocal. Also important is the fact that in a war, the monopoly on the use of force breaks down, leading to chaos and random violence. I've got a million criticisms of every repressive government under the Sun, but there's a clear difference between killing everyone who insults the god emperor and bombs being dropped indiscriminantly into a city.
Malala Yousafzai says: In the last two decades, millions of Afghan women and girls received an education. Now the future they were promised is dangerously close to slipping away. The Taliban — who until losing power 20 years ago barred nearly all girls and women from attending school and doled out harsh punishment to those who defied them - are back in control. Like many women, I fear for my Afghan sisters.
Yeah I saw that, it's terrible. I don't get how insecure of a male you must be to actually be angry at women for being in school. How weak must you be to feel like you can't compete if women were allowed to be scientists for instance. That's really sad.
I just read a piece in the Guardian where a student left the university hurriedly yesterday and is hiding her certificates.
There was the minister for education on the tv yesterday "I'm about to pay a high price for trying to improve the world". Very brave woman she wasn't fleeing the country even though she expects the death penalty.
@OldBrit Speaking of price, looks like the price of burqas just went up.
"Ahead of the Taliban's arrival in Kabul on Sunday, women also rushed to stores to panic buy burqas, The Guardian reported. The last time the Taliban were in power, in the 1990s, the wearing of burqas was policed strictly. Kabul's vendors were also said to be hiking their prices for burqas in light of the Taliban takeover. Last year these burqas cost AFS 200 ($2.50). Now they're trying to sell them to us for AFS 2,000 to 3,000 ($25 to $37)," a woman identified as Aaila told The Guardian.
don't live in a religiously conservative/fundamentalist society
The American Christian Taliban will change that if given the chance.
The Taliban are merely pious and devout muslims who strictly observe Islamic rules and teachings. Afghani muslims should be delighted that they will now be allowed to follow their religion without interference from others.
@newjaninev2 yeah, some would be delighted to be able to follow their religion, to whatever extreme degrees they want to. And a lot of people caught in the midst of their religious pursuits will feel the restriction of rights, etc. Same with the analogous Christian societies.
@Heartlander a large percentage of Germans in 1930’s supported NaZism A large percentage of Muslims in 2021 support Sharia It’s an over generalization, but tell me . Am I wrong ?
@Heartlander Hitler only maintained the facade of Catholicism as a ruse. Truth be known, he saw Christianity as a weak religion and admired Islam for its brutality.
@QuixoticSoul Jews never murdered on behalf of Hashem bc their religious leaders never told them to It’s been almost a millennium since a Christian murdered on behalf of Yahweh bc their religious leader told them to You know what I’m getting at The 3rd Abrahamic religion is in bad need of a reformation
@NangiUniverse It has since come out the power struggle within the Afghan communist party was manufactured from outside during the Carter administration too.
The Taliban also offered to hand over Bin Laden in 2001 too but Bush wanted a war.
It's sad to me that there seems to be no significant counteractive force in Afghanistan. Why are the Taliban so powerful and so influential? Why did the cities capitulate so readily? Unfortunately religious fanaticism is an extremely potent motivator, and a lukewarm U.S.-supported army and government isn't enough to counteract the zeal of Taliban fighters who have been laying in waiting for two decades for their return. Though I refuse to believe that the Taliban is the be-all end-all for Afghanistan. Some day there may come a homegrown, secular-ish, modernizing force that can oust them once and for all.
Hell most countries are trying to do that to EVERYone in the name of covid and vaccines. "having their freedoms, aspirations and hopes taken away overnight". Sounds like the rest of the planet.
@IronHamster Brutality is the language of the human race. No matter the geography, the ethnicity, the time period, the religion, or the culture, people are violent.
@BlueMetalChick To a varying degree. We have liberals in schools that work to eliminate that, and as a result they don't understand cultures where brutality is the order of the day. Hell, here in the US there are folks that actually believe women and black people are oppressed, and, LOL, every institution they claim is racist or sexist is run by liberals. The Antifa group in Seattle screams about police brutality and racism, but leave them in charge of a few city blocks and in less than three weeks they start murdering black people themselves. I have more examples of the total lack of self awareness liberals have regarding brutality. It's too bad we can't universally recognize brutality for what it is.
Something missed in alot of the narrative of why Afghanistan fell so quickly is the fact that even after 20 years the US puppet government controlled relatively little of the country and was mostly patches scattered all over the country like city states. When you are in a small little pocket surrounded by hostile or "neutral" forces and cut off from any reinforcements you don't last very long.
It's sad. But can the world community really do anything about it except express anguish on social media? This is just trying to get over the guilt that we are doing nothing.
@Northwest yes that’s true but Afghanistan a in imminent danger and people are literally running away from cities taken over by the Taliban on foot with their children
@Jenny1234 People are scared, but there's nothing we can do about it. It is up to the people of Afghanistan to resist the extreme Islamist agenda, if the Taliban attempt to change the terms of the agreement they committed to, which is to develop a power sharing agreement with the current government.
The Afghanistan president fled the country, so the former President is now the front person, meeting with the Taliban to transition, whatever that ends up meaning.
If the people did support the Taliban, the government would not have fallen in a matter of days, mostly without any fighting, especially in Kabul.
@beckyromero Well, it certainly worked for the Kurds. It is a strong belief in Salafist Islam that it is dishonorable for a man to be killed by a woman, and if he is, he will go straight to hell with no chance for redemption in the eyes of Allah. The fear of being shot and killed by a female soldier and subsequently condemned to an afterlife of eternal suffering was so overwhelming that a significant number of Salafist insurgents flat out refused to fight against all-female Kurdish brigades. Which is pretty fucking based if you ask me.
@WSEIII Wrong. Look, Biden was right that we needed to leave. You might be right that you need your appendix removed, but you can Trump that by hiring a skilled surgeon or Biden it by hiring a drunk with a pocket knife.
I am sure a few do. I am also sure a goodly number welcome the Taliban's return. Sad comment on humanity but we see evidence of the same in the west so.....
@iamelijah Not really but that kind of mentality is how western governments justify endless wars leaving out the part that they are largely responsible for these extremists in the first place.
@yeronlyman ummm... I dunno. No... I think ethics is.
Like, I'll shoot myself in the foot and tell someone I've done something wrong. One of my kids got so distracted with school activities one year, they freaked out when a few final assignments were due all at once. They complained to me, asking for a note to explain why.... And I had explain why I had to say no.
They took it hard... But it was realistic and fair by my ethics. I wasn't going to teach my child that duties could be weedled out of.
There are times I hate my ethics... They hurt me more than if I didn't have them. 🤷♀️
@YukikoAmagi This is a post about the Taliban. Most Muslims ALSO hate the Taliban. Just like most Muslims hate Wahhabis because Wahhabis are insane murderous barbarians. Don't forget, they primarily target and kill non-Wahhabi Muslims.
One of the worst sufferers of modern world are Muslim women ,I can't help but feel the horror they have in their eyes with the Taliban taking in control . Rapes ,gangrapes ,stone pelting ,beheading..!Such raw insensitivity towards them is just so objectionable . God bless them .
@MartinTheFirst when i mean sources i mean not only western media, but indian media, pakistani media, chinese media, russian media and hell even discussion on reddit or 1st-hand information on twitter as well. when u read a source it is true that u only get 2 know what the author wants 2 reveal 2 u (plus his/her own bias and interpretation) but by reading all the sources and examining conflicting information we can filter out propaganda/misinformation/bias via critical thinking and reassemble the truth of such an event, how people perceive such an event and how people react 2 such an event.
@PatKirby nah this is 2 reductionist... 2 rly know what's going on I suggest reading the entire wikipedia regarding afghanistan, the taliban and the war in afghanistan.
I knew this would happen once we withdrew from Afghanistan, and actually, I blame the Reagan administration, and the Bush administration that followed immediately. We basically blew the hell out of that country. We sent it back to the stone age. But when it came time to rebuild the country and educate the young people, the American government was like, "Nah, we're good." And that's how the Taliban was born in the first place.
@LordShadowfire I blame the Reagan administration for a lot of things lol, they made horrible decisions. A lot of the groups fighting communism were Islamic militants who mostly murdered nuns.
Its horrific. Women can't learn,have their freedoms abolished. Why do people follow the words of a man who married a 6 year old and raped her when she was 9? How can any decent person follow teachings of a beast like that? Why would an omniscient Allah make a monster like Mohammed his mouthpiece?