Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

controversial but genuine question

can you name even one truly unselfish reason for having a child? to wit:

- by the very nature of the beast, there is no childish input in the decision
- even at the highest levels of living, there will be major hard scrabble and worrisome moments as the child grows and dies
- many have children as accessories, caregivers, easers of loneliness, entertainment, or cleaners of the home
- the only even-close reason I can think of as roundabout unselfishness is to build a religious army of sorts, but that is mightyyy presumptuous
- how dare parents then say, "I BROUGHT YOU INTO THIS WORLD AND I CAN TAKE YOU OUT" or, "do you know how long i labored to have you"....
Top | New | Old
Luckylu · 61-69, F
I did not want to bring a child into this world either but became pregnant at 42 while on birth control. I would never abort a child so I had her. I have devoted my life to her since she was born. There is so much to this story you will never know because it is too long to write here. But she is why I am still here. The only thing I do for myself is write the rest I do for her which benefits us both. If I had been selfish I would have aborted her but once life is given I cannot take it away. I had to choose between a life being lived where I caused a death or a life being lived of bringing another life into this God forsaken world. No matter the choice there was no selfish decision that could possibly make it better. I may love her with all that I am but I see her suffering every day. And then I see moments of joy which eases the pain of that decision.
foldedunfolding · 41-45, F
@Luckylu i love this answer. i am actually pro life writing this post! i believe in life lived abundantly! i even love children and loving parents! just pointing out that i think folks need to give this more thought than, "yeah i think i can handle two". i applaud your selflessness in this act, and grieve with you for any traumas surrounding it. you are a hero!
Luckylu · 61-69, F
@foldedunfolding thank you for your comments. By definition a hero is: noun
1. a person who is admired or idealized for courage, outstanding achievements, or noble qualities. I am none of these. If you knew the whole story you would not call me a hero. I brought a child into the world with a man who already had 2 children he didn’t support. I was so terrified I would have another child while with him, I had a tubal ligation performed so I couldn’t have any more children, as soon as possible after her birth. After we split, he went on to have 2 more children again which he does not support, with a woman who was told she couldn’t have children. But that isn’t my story, other than I warned her when we met. He was abusive emotionally/mentally to me, and physically to others. I knew what kind of man he was and yet I was with him, bore a child with him, and still tried to make the relationship work. I have no idea if the problems she has today are due to him. I should have split from him when I found out I was pregnant, that would have been the courageous thing to do. Instead I stayed, moved across country and moved into another country, away from family and friends to be with him. And then spent 18 years raising her alone because I was too afraid to become involved again with another man. I didn’t trust my judgement of who would be good for us and who wouldn’t be. I couldn’t put my heart out there again. I’m not sure I’ll ever be able to.
foldedunfolding · 41-45, F
@Luckylu im failing to see why i shouldnt see you as a hero here..you did all you could to not give birth to another of his babies..you escaped an evil man..you warned the future woman of your troubles..and you raised a full woman for 18 years alone, all the while protecting her and neglecting yourself.....
WaryWitchWandering · 36-40, F
I’m sure it’s not selfless to decide to have children (it’s something I wanted, a family of my own)

I give my children all my love and I guide them. Their feelings and thoughts are very important to me. We play, explore, and learn together.

I don’t think it’s selfless, but I don’t think it’s selfish either. Humans are meant to reproduce, and although I don’t think ALL should be allowed to, I do my very best to be sure my children feel loved and supported , while allowing them to figure out who they are in this world.

I understand I can’t control what goes on outside of my home, but I can help give them the confidence in themselves to make best decisions for themselves and to cope. I also understand they didn’t have a choice in being born, but they also didn’t choose not to… it just is.
calicuz · 56-60, M
The unselfishness is sacrificing to give them a better life than you had.
calicuz · 56-60, M
@foldedunfolding

I understand no rudeness was meant, but giving my son a better life and teaching him better ways, is for him, not for me, or to "rub in anyone's face."
foldedunfolding · 41-45, F
@calicuz i definitely agree..there is selflessness in that, now that he is here. but i beseech amnesty when i ask: when you planned him, if you did, did you do it for his sake or your own? if you had to dig deep to answer.
calicuz · 56-60, M
@foldedunfolding

Wow, not ready to answer that one yet.
Northwest · M
The continuation of our species.

"This is what my parents inflicted on me, and I did not inflict on anyone".

Engraved on the tombstone of an 11 century Syrian poet (ISIS blew it up).
foldedunfolding · 41-45, F
@Northwest but perpetuating such a horrid species is uncool in the extreme lol. and even if half the population didnt procreate, the world would at least be able to handle the few occupants it did have
Northwest · M
@foldedunfolding Who decides who gets to procreate? The elite? We're not all that bad, and perhaps, one of these days, our species can live at peace, perhaps on Mars, where Musk will be revered as a God.
foldedunfolding · 41-45, F
@Northwest oh now im just gonna off myself at THAT prospect ew
Queendragonfly · 31-35, F
I can't, there's none. Everyone who claims it's selfless are not completely honest with themselves.

No child gets the question "Do you want to be born? And no child gets to pick their family.

The decision to have a child is made by a selfish act to fulfill / be happy / be completed in life. And what's worse is all too often, parents ignore that their child is their own person, their own individual, and only treat their child as a reflection of how the parents themselves want to be recieved.

That's not selfless. The most selfless thing for a parent is to support who the child is even if they're not as their parents.
foldedunfolding · 41-45, F
@Queendragonfly yep!! said better than i could myself! i think an act necessarily lacks selflessness if the person they are being "selfless" TOWARDS doesnt exist 🤣

well..i guess you can be selfless towards future folks by creating generational wealth, etc 🤔
caPnAhab · 26-30, M
If you give everything you have to this kid, then is that not selflessness?
caPnAhab · 26-30, M
@Queendragonfly Well, I'm starting to rethink. Right.. I guess there is no true selfless reason. I don't think it cancels out the reasons I said above.


I thought this question though:

Are we better off or worse off than our previous societies? Imagine living in medieval times where medical practices would make you raise an eyebrow. Maybe this world will always be terrible... but it might also be an improvement?

... debatable, I know
Queendragonfly · 31-35, F
@caPnAhab I think it's improving but environmental wise, we are neglecting our planet.
caPnAhab · 26-30, M
@Queendragonfly yeah agreed. That much is easy to see
With the way the world is developing, it doesn't matter how good a parent you'll be. Others will make your child's life hell and no support you offer can compensate for that. I would not put a child into the current world, let alone what it will be like in 80 or 120 years at this rate.
foldedunfolding · 41-45, F
@NerdyPotato yeah exactly. like honestly i should sue my parents for emotional distress ha
kodiac · 22-25, M
Wouldn't to propagate the species be a form of unselfish act ? Without children the species would become extinct.
kodiac · 22-25, M
@foldedunfolding Hanging out here can cause that lol
foldedunfolding · 41-45, F
@kodiac ha nah this site actually gets me through some rough patches
kodiac · 22-25, M
@foldedunfolding Yup me to ,but there are times i just have to say wth!😅
WillaKissing · 56-60, M
I had my children because it was the only legacy that I wanted to leave behind in this world when I left it. To raise love, and to leave this world with love shared with my children.
originnone · 61-69, M
caregivers....that strikes a nerve. My kids wouldn't toss me a scrap of bread like Pietta did for Katniss.
foldedunfolding · 41-45, F
@originnone that's the thing tho..it is so presumptuous that you can bring a little pet into the world, forge them in your own image, then be upset if they dont want to caregive later..idk
originnone · 61-69, M
@foldedunfolding Yeah....I do get it....
foldedunfolding · 41-45, F
@originnone that being said..i wish they would give you care for whatever it is you are going through..you are one of the good ones 😪
Deceased · M
The act of having a child is inherently a selfish and narcissistic act.
Deceased · M
@foldedunfolding its a quality I admire and look for in people.
And I would certainly hope not 🙂
foldedunfolding · 41-45, F
@Deceased also if i were calling something a galling practice, it most [b]certainly[b] would not be that which i have most perfected
Deceased · M
@foldedunfolding oh my! Love that confidence. 💜🌹
Yes my husband wanted a child. I did it for him. But I wanted one.
SW-User
Surrogacy?
foldedunfolding · 41-45, F
@SW-User surrogacy is still bringing a life into the world, which i find near unforgivable, lol..but i can see how you could say it is unselfish towards the would-be parents
plungesponge · 41-45, M
I had a comically narcissistic father and he actually said "Whatever issues you think you have with me, none of them matter. I'm sorry you got the impression I lied to you, I don't lie.
I have never lied since I was 17. The only thing that matters is I'm your father and you're my son and it's as simple as that". Talk about lifetime enslavement lol. He had no friends his whole life, nobody could put up with his stream of self serving lies, so he thought he could use that BS to lock me in as the only person who had to put up with him. fvck that, I went no contact on him.
Montanaman · M
Love ❤️
fun4us2b · M
It's an instinct

Why are we all so horny?

So we can procreate

If we thought about it there would be far fewer people

I have one - I was also an only

Such a cool guy - I think he's better than me
foldedunfolding · 41-45, F
@fun4us2b it's so strange that the Bible always tells us to rise against our base instincts, but not on this one 🤔
fun4us2b · M
@foldedunfolding Does the Bible actually say that - or is that how some interpret the Bible? All I ever see are stories, but maybe because that is what I look for.

Makes no sense for the Bible tell us to fight our nature.
foldedunfolding · 41-45, F
@fun4us2b it tells us to lean not on our own understand, and to be above sin
PhilDeep · 51-55, M
I decided years ago that not having children was the better decision, looking at how fucked-up the world is already with no signs of improvement. I think it's only compassionate to choose not to bring anyone else into it.
HumanEarth · F
To have the human race to live on. But robots and AI will wipe out humans in the next few years.

So we are better off fucking just for the fun it before we are all dead

 
Post Comment