Top | Newest First | Oldest First
The police in Britain don't help themselves it has to be said. The violent way they "handled"the vigil following the murder of Sarah Everard (murdered, incidentally, by a serving police officer who already had more than a dodgy past), coupled with handling demonstrations by far right wing agitators , with a softly softly approach, then turning a blind eye to corruption within its own heirarchy, not to mention the excessive cosiness with the senior members of the tory party are just a few reasons why people in this country are losing fasith in the police.
View 16 more replies »
@Lynda70 I have never said there wasn't. Maybe the victims of misandry need to speak out more. But it certainly doesn't paint the force in a very good light. There looks like it's fragmented and morale bad. A fragmented force wth bad morale leads to the sorts of problems the Home Secretary has highlighted.
@jackieash27 Thanks for the thumbs up. :) I've really enjoyed this conversation; it's a change to have a frank exchange of views while being civil to each other :)
Lynda70 · F
@jackieash27 I did too. We've proven it's possible to remain civil while disagreeing although it seems we're not as far apart as I first thought.
PicturesOfABetterTomorrow · 41-45, M
Sorry but pretending the issue is just a "few bad apples" is making excuses for a systemic problem. And if other officers turn the other way and pull the "blue wall" nonsense they are all bad apples. Colluding and covering for bad actors is effectively an endorsement of the behavior. In the US in particular the "good ones" are the exception to the rule.
cyberdude28 · 31-35, M
@PicturesOfABetterTomorrow I'm not saying these things are correct but let me ask you this; are you morally perfect?
PicturesOfABetterTomorrow · 41-45, M
@cyberdude28 Whether I am or not is totally irrelevant. Responding with a logical fallacy is not a great starting point.
SW-User
People who denounce the police are talking about the whole system, though. They don't mean that all police officers are bad people (even if that is how they talk sometimes!) They believe the whole institution of policing is bad.
cyberdude28 · 31-35, M
@SW-User but the police are necessary and serve a function no?
SW-User
@cyberdude28 That's kind of the question. Do we need a police force or could the functions we want them to serve be done better in other ways?
cyberdude28 · 31-35, M
@SW-User yeah I mean those are important questions.
TinyViolins · 31-35, M
The availability heuristic. Most people don't have any interactions at all with police in their daily lives, so they base their perception of them by what they see online or in the news, and since those platforms have an incentive to get people angry and keep them engaged, they mostly show the negative.
So people go on to have negative views about the police given what they see and with little to no exposure to anything else, the balance is easily tipped towards what you're describing
So people go on to have negative views about the police given what they see and with little to no exposure to anything else, the balance is easily tipped towards what you're describing
SW-User
Not all cops are bad people but good intentions do not matter in a fucked up system.
Anyone who truly wants to help people should rather go and be a social worker.
Anyone who truly wants to help people should rather go and be a social worker.
@SW-User Here in Britain, the only time social workers are mentioned is when something goes tragically, like a parent killing their child either with violence or neglect. The cry goes out "Where were the social workers? What do we pay our taxes for?" They are one of those groups of people who when things go right, no one notices, because a case successfully sorted by social workers is not news.
NortiusMaximus · M
@SW-User
Is that due to lack of funding or other reasons?
Here in Britain they seem to relish a sense of power. They go for easy targets like single fathers but turn a blind eye and ignore reports of children in danger from their mothers.
ViciDraco · 36-40, M
@SW-User there are places in the US where people become social workers to break the system from the inside and they purposefully try to find reasons to get people they don't like kicked off of any benefits. But that is hopefully a minority
ElRengo · 70-79, M
"All generalizations are wrong" (popular "wisedom")
"And the above one is the worst of them all") (B. Russell)
"And the above one is the worst of them all") (B. Russell)
cyberdude28 · 31-35, M
@ElRengo my brain is going to explode
ElRengo · 70-79, M
@cyberdude28 Dont worry. Mine already did long ago and here I am😄
GeniUs · 56-60, M
Don't know about other countries but the UK suffers from a broken legal system and instead of people who are qualified and smart enough to fix it they exploit it. How long can you fastidiously do your job for, seeing your efforts wasted when it gets to court before you become blasé about it?
Yes there are people who will always be dedicated and some were always bad but the ones between the 2 extremes who are affected by doing a job for no effect are the ones that can be changed.
Yes there are people who will always be dedicated and some were always bad but the ones between the 2 extremes who are affected by doing a job for no effect are the ones that can be changed.
assemblingaknob · 26-30, F
There are people bad at their jobs o
in every field.
in every field.
bijouxbroussard · F
@assemblingaknob True. But not in all jobs do they have the power of life and death over everyone they encounter.
assemblingaknob · 26-30, F
@bijouxbroussard you make a good point.
bijouxbroussard · F
Unfortunately, there’s something about the culture in many departments that encourages police officers to profile. My brother, who was a police officer for several years (retired recently) and entered the academy with a certain amount of idealism, told me a few things he observed over the years.
cyberdude28 · 31-35, M
@bijouxbroussard Yeah like I said it's not so simple unfortunately
gol979 · 41-45, M
Its the system. Not all police are "bad" but they represent a corrupt system and most times are the legitimised violent arm of this putrid system
basilfawlty89 · 31-35, M
Not every individual cop is a bad person, but the system is inherently oppressive, because it exists to punish, not deter, and to protect the property of the wealthy. It's also a top down hierarchy with a monopoly on the use of violence.
PicturesOfABetterTomorrow · 41-45, M
@basilfawlty89 The security industry also would arguably fall into that. Having worked in that industry you get told your job is to protect property, information, and people and largely in that order.
SW-User
Anyone who actually likes or embraces the police is a cuck lol
Roundandroundwego · 61-69
The sickness is in the system. Policing itself is problematic.
Mysterion619 · 26-30, M
Most of them are bad though
ViciDraco · 36-40, M
Not all cops are bad, but very few cops are good. They might be good people outside of uniform but they are bad cops.
This is because good cops are very quickly pushed out of the system. You see, a good cop challenges the behavior of bad cops and holds them accountable. But the moment a good cop brings charges upon a bad cop, they lose all support within their department. They are ostracized, slow to receive backup, and generally bullied until they become ineffectual, toe the line, or quit.
In this case, a few bad apples is absolutely true because the other apples are capable of identifying and throwing the bad ones out of the bunch. The fact that they don't makes them also bad.
This is because good cops are very quickly pushed out of the system. You see, a good cop challenges the behavior of bad cops and holds them accountable. But the moment a good cop brings charges upon a bad cop, they lose all support within their department. They are ostracized, slow to receive backup, and generally bullied until they become ineffectual, toe the line, or quit.
In this case, a few bad apples is absolutely true because the other apples are capable of identifying and throwing the bad ones out of the bunch. The fact that they don't makes them also bad.
DDonde · 31-35, M
People need to have some ownership in the whole thing
cyberdude28 · 31-35, M
@DDonde Maybe we should robot police eventually and take away the humans policing each other?
This comment is hidden.
Show Comment