Poll - Total Votes: 19 See Poll Options
PassingThrough · 46-50, M
Tennant is still my favorite. My buddy asked me once if the TARDIS materialized in front of me and he stepped out holding out his hand would I squeal like a little girl. I said ABSOLUTELY YES!
JJones · 18-21, M
@PassingThrough Wholesome lol
PassingThrough · 46-50, M
@JJones I’d be geeking out to no end. But I’d bet money on the fact he’d think I’m an idiot. And that’s ok
I like both the old and new show.
Tom Baker is 'my doctor' in that I grew up with a huge shelf of VHS tapes of all of his sesaons and so I'll always say the 4th doctor.
Of new doctor who, I'll go with Peter Capaldi.
Tom Baker is 'my doctor' in that I grew up with a huge shelf of VHS tapes of all of his sesaons and so I'll always say the 4th doctor.
Of new doctor who, I'll go with Peter Capaldi.
View 7 more replies »
CountScrofula · 41-45, M
@JJones https://open.spotify.com/album/7idJpl3Xvma03BAyURhehj
Chimes of Midnight is goddamn amazing. Proper scary bedtime story sorta stuff with the 8th doctor.
Chimes of Midnight is goddamn amazing. Proper scary bedtime story sorta stuff with the 8th doctor.
JJones · 18-21, M
@CountScrofula Cool! Never heard of it before
robingoodfellow · M
@CountScrofula i really love the Paul McGann Big Finish stuff and Sheridan Smith's Lucy Miller is a treasure.
DearAmbellina2113 · 41-45, F
11 is my absolute favorite. His imaginary friend energy and his physical comedy won me. I also think his seasons had the best storylines, I love that he was so geared toward children and also adults who'd lost their childhoods.
JJones · 18-21, M
@DearAmbellina2113 I completely agree with you! He was brilliant 😁
DunningKruger · 61-69, M
I like all of the new doctors pretty much equally, although leaning toward 10. I've only watched a handful of the old doctors' episodes.
Straylight · 31-35, F
@DunningKruger I think Jody Witika is a good actress, but the writing kept falling flat to me during her run.
JJones · 18-21, M
@Straylight Agreed
AbbySvenz · F
She’s a great actor but the writers didn’t really give her much to go on 😐
Matt85 · 36-40, M
Something like "How all knowing are you?"
-"You can't have degrees of all"
-"You can't have degrees of all"
OldBrit · 61-69, M
In descending order...
Jon Pertwee, Tom Baker, David Tennant
Jon Pertwee, Tom Baker, David Tennant
robingoodfellow · M
No matter what it's always going to be Tom Baker. But Matt Smith comes close.
CountScrofula · 41-45, M
@robingoodfellow What a wonderful butler, he's so violent!
JJones · 18-21, M
@robingoodfellow Great picks 😌
fun4us2b · M
10th then 11th..was a really strong run
reubles · 41-45, M
Colin Baker, BAYBEE!!!
AbbySvenz · F
Ten
Don’t blink
Don’t blink
bijouxbroussard · F
Mine from the original doctors was #2, Patrick Troughton.
[media=https://youtu.be/FFpuIqDKErk]
[media=https://youtu.be/FFpuIqDKErk]
Straylight · 31-35, F
@bijouxbroussard That’s my favorite classic Doctor too.
JJones · 18-21, M
@bijouxbroussard Nice pick 👍
AdaXI · T
Where's Peter Cushing?!👀 LOLZ!😅
The 7th is my favourite.
乂º◡º乂
The 7th is my favourite.
乂º◡º乂
JJones · 18-21, M
@AdaXI Oh her, that plot mess, I remember that 😅
However you look at it, it just doesn't make sense, for example if the Doctor had countless regenerations, why did they a need a new regeneration cycle after the 11th. The fugitive Doctor is the biggest plot hole in Doctor Who and I'd really like that whole thing to be retconned. It doesn't respect the story, it changes things way too much. You can't just change 60 years of built up story like that. We know who the Doctor is, they really need to stop changing things just for the sake of change. If it's not broken don't fix it
However you look at it, it just doesn't make sense, for example if the Doctor had countless regenerations, why did they a need a new regeneration cycle after the 11th. The fugitive Doctor is the biggest plot hole in Doctor Who and I'd really like that whole thing to be retconned. It doesn't respect the story, it changes things way too much. You can't just change 60 years of built up story like that. We know who the Doctor is, they really need to stop changing things just for the sake of change. If it's not broken don't fix it
CBarson · 51-55
@JJones I love the fugitive Doctor's personality and wish they'd give her her own season!
That said, I'm kind of disappointed at how regenerating has become such the main part of the plot line of late, when it was originally just an "in universe" way to explain a new actor taking the role (I guess I'm glad they didn't do that with James Bond or Batman)
That said, I'm kind of disappointed at how regenerating has become such the main part of the plot line of late, when it was originally just an "in universe" way to explain a new actor taking the role (I guess I'm glad they didn't do that with James Bond or Batman)
pride49 · 31-35, M
Peter Capaldi
Nanoose · 61-69, M
Not sure what the number is but his name was The Doctor and he always wore a long scarf. Cheers!
pride49 · 31-35, M
11th Matt Smith. I liked Peter Capaldi too
JimboSaturn · 56-60, M
14th.
JimboSaturn · 56-60, M
@fun4us2b ah ok

SW-User
I've forgotten who is who!

SW-User
@JJones hehe.
Tbf I thought Christopher Ecclestone had some mileage in him but he only lasted a season. David Tennant was superb, and I also had a soft spot for Sylvester McCoy for some reason. Matt Smith was fine, but then I lost interest.
Tbf I thought Christopher Ecclestone had some mileage in him but he only lasted a season. David Tennant was superb, and I also had a soft spot for Sylvester McCoy for some reason. Matt Smith was fine, but then I lost interest.
JJones · 18-21, M
@SW-User Excellent choices 😁
Straylight · 31-35, F
@SW-User I liked Sylvester McCoy. I wish he could have gotten another season as they were just moving away from the censorship being imposed on them that made Colin Bakers run so troublesome for them.
Belladonna · 41-45, F
Gotta go with 11, closely followed by 10.
JJones · 18-21, M
@Belladonna Agreed 😎
TheSirfurryanimalWales · 61-69, M
Tom Baker...whatever number he was.
JJones · 18-21, M
David Tenant was my favorite
JJones · 18-21, M
@Onestarlitnight Nice 👍
Straylight · 31-35, F
Got to go with Matt Smith. But I have a soft spot for Patrick Troughton too.
caesar7 · 61-69, M
Tom Baker was the best of the rest in my book!👍 Have a Jelly baby.....