Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

On tv shows or movies when someone is drowning and they are revived with CPR and start coughing up water why do they never turn them on their side?

Im not a nurse but wouldn't it be easier to cough out water when laying onto your side?
Top | New | Old
BamPow · 51-55, M
My wife works in nursing and has said as much. She’s also pointed out how many times CPR chest compressions are portrayed as love taps when in reality it’s a pretty violent endeavor causing cracked ribs.
FreddieUK · 70-79, M
@BamPow The actors' union had something to say about that. 😂
TexChik · F
IRL you would if you can physically move the patient after assessing them for a neck injury. Some folks weigh a ton!
BamPow · 51-55, M
@TexChik I watched CHiP’s recently, and they were responding to an accident. They run up to a guy laying on the ground complaining about his neck and back hurting. Ponch immediately grabs him under the shoulders and drags him 20 feet. I had to pause until I finished laughing.
oldguy73 · 70-79, M
because in the movies, directors want to show the persons face, while getting CPR, you see the person trying to breathe, etc. it's all for the movie trying tp thrill the audiance
FreddieUK · 70-79, M
It's like a lot of things in drama: the action is symbolic of an event rather than a faithful realist enactment of fact. Similarly, heart attacks don't always happen as portrayed and sex is very stylised. Most heroes would be dead after their first beating if what you see on the screen was to be taken at face value.
NeuroticByNature · 41-45, F
@FreddieUK true but if theyre detailed enough to fill an actors mouth with water and force them to lay on their back and cpugh they could as easily have them rolled over. It just gives me anxiety.
Wayne91 · 31-35, M
To face the camera
Monalisasmith86 · 41-45, F
They are supposed to do that lay them on the side it’s in cpr training
NeuroticByNature · 41-45, F
@Monalisasmith86 it gives me serious anxiety watching it lol
Wallflow3r · 31-35, F
You cant really do cpr on someone that is laying on there side
NeuroticByNature · 41-45, F
@Wallflow3r if they started coughing up water they wouldnt need CPR anymore.
Wallflow3r · 31-35, F
@NeuroticByNature I would 😌
NeuroticByNature · 41-45, F
@Wallflow3r maybe me too depending on who was giving it.
Thevy29 · 41-45, M
They rarely check the airway first before commencing CPR. Or in modern movies they do the old standard CPR and not the new one.
NeuroticByNature · 41-45, F
@Northwest maybe
Infamous607 · 51-55, M
Because they are not truly drowning. It's all make believe.

 
Post Comment