Top | Newest First | Oldest First
JoePourMan · 61-69, M
Saying "Black Lives Matter" doesn't take anything away from me.
It's an illogical leap to say this implies other lives do not matter.
If you truly believe all lives matter, then you should have no problem agreeing that
Black Lives Matter
It's an illogical leap to say this implies other lives do not matter.
If you truly believe all lives matter, then you should have no problem agreeing that
Black Lives Matter
View 3 more replies »
CHARMAINE · 61-69, F
@JoePourMan oh im not agaist black life matter
But why is it more attention on them if the shoe was on the other foot you wouldnt hear so much fuss.
Understand
But why is it more attention on them if the shoe was on the other foot you wouldnt hear so much fuss.
Understand
This message was deleted by its author.
JoePourMan · 61-69, M
@CHARMAINE do you honestly think you would have the right to vote if not for the Women's Rights movement. I don't think you should feel obligated to work for change, but at least try not to get in the way
The slogan Black Lives Matter is meant to bring your attention to the fact that since the first Blacks were brought to the United States in slaves ships, Black have been systematically discriminated against in this country. That this discrimination isn't just the opinion of some individuals but has been written into law and allowed to continue as public policy whether official or not.
If whites were routinely stopped by police, denied promotions, murdered without consequences there would be rioting in the streets.
The past is not the past when it dictates the attitudes of the present.
No one is implying that all lives don't matter, just pleading with you to recognize that black lives matter
If whites were routinely stopped by police, denied promotions, murdered without consequences there would be rioting in the streets.
The past is not the past when it dictates the attitudes of the present.
No one is implying that all lives don't matter, just pleading with you to recognize that black lives matter
Mamapolo2016 · F
The slogan of a cause is not a dissertation, not a detailed examination of a society.
It's a rallying cry, simple and short.
"Black lives matter, too," does not have the same punch.
To dismiss the substance by quibbling with the motto is intellectually dishonest. I know, because I was dishonest.
A better statement would be "If black lives don't matter, then no life matters," but it's not catchy enough
It's a rallying cry, simple and short.
"Black lives matter, too," does not have the same punch.
To dismiss the substance by quibbling with the motto is intellectually dishonest. I know, because I was dishonest.
A better statement would be "If black lives don't matter, then no life matters," but it's not catchy enough
CHARMAINE · 61-69, F
@Mamapolo2016 why not all life matters skip of the racial ( black life)
Mamapolo2016 · F
@CHARMAINE Because protests are for the purpose of making people think, calling attention to something. Slogans are meant to jar us, make us think. "All life matters" would not do that. We'd just smile and go on our merry way.
I think the notion behind it is discrimination/exclusion in negative ways creates all these problems for groups of people. so they're trying to use discrimination/exclusion in a positive way. which kinda seems like backward thinking to me, but sometimes backwards is needed for a while, I suppose.
OogieBoogie · F
@CHARMAINE you're mixing metaphors that don't make sense 🤷♀️
Roses have thorns - rose thorns don't have caustion - they have bloody sharp edges - for good reason. They are both beauty and danger in one.
If you want a rose garden - you garden with respect to those thorns.
And this is what that phrase is about: RESPECT🤘😊.
Roses have thorns - rose thorns don't have caustion - they have bloody sharp edges - for good reason. They are both beauty and danger in one.
If you want a rose garden - you garden with respect to those thorns.
And this is what that phrase is about: RESPECT🤘😊.
MrAverage1965 · 61-69, M
You are right there are many people of many races treated unfairly and as second class human beings.
I guess #blacklifesmatter relates to one particular situation at this moment in time.
I guess #blacklifesmatter relates to one particular situation at this moment in time.
CHARMAINE · 61-69, F
@MrAverage1965 its just so sad
Hoosierxdaddy62 · 61-69, M
Imagine you're a parent of 2 kids. One of them falls of their bike and breaks an arm. You take the kid to the doctor because at thi moment, although you love your kids equally, the one with the injury needs a little more attention. Doesn't mean you stop loving the othe kid, just you put some extra attention to the one that needs it at the moment.
If you're a Christian, think of the parable of the lost sheep. The shepherd leaves the 99 to find the lost one. It doesn't mean he stops caring for the 99, they are important, but they aren't in trouble. He goes and finds the lost one and returns it to the flock.
If you're a Christian, think of the parable of the lost sheep. The shepherd leaves the 99 to find the lost one. It doesn't mean he stops caring for the 99, they are important, but they aren't in trouble. He goes and finds the lost one and returns it to the flock.
SW-User
The knee-jerk reactions of the masses. The foolish tend to like bandwagons. The next one will be along shortly and they'll jump like fleas to that one as well.
Magenta · F
@SW-User This!
ThePerfectUsername · 70-79, M
Simple really. Until you can say Black Live Matter and mean it - your "All Lives Matter" response is a lie.
@ThePerfectUsername BOOM!
CHARMAINE · 61-69, F
@ThePerfectUsername no
I have lots of black friens, and all nationalities and colors.
So if it was a black cop who kill a white you would say white life matters. All life matters. No matter what color I do agree on the cop being punished though. He pushed his limits
I have lots of black friens, and all nationalities and colors.
So if it was a black cop who kill a white you would say white life matters. All life matters. No matter what color I do agree on the cop being punished though. He pushed his limits
ThePerfectUsername · 70-79, M
@CHARMAINE If a black cop killed a white guy I'd say it was a crime. If 100 black cops killed 100 white guy's I'd say the system needed looking at. If black cops had been killing white guys with impunity for hundreds of years plus denying the equal opportunities wages and justice I'd be joining White Lives Matters. Till then, stop making up excuses to deny that Black Lives Matter.
CHARMAINE · 61-69, F
We are not living in past.
Why should we keep paying back on what our ancienseries did.
Let go and live on to better ourself. We our humans not animals
Why should we keep paying back on what our ancienseries did.
Let go and live on to better ourself. We our humans not animals
Poppies · 61-69, F
What Black Lives Matter really is trying to get across is, Black Lives Matter, TOO. Think of it that way to realize it isn't cutting other people out. Historically black lives have not been valued by the society at large as if they matter. When people respond to Black Lives Matter with All Lives Matter and Blue Lives Matter, it's as if they're denying that a change has to be made to make the treatment of black lives even with others.
Zaphod42 · 51-55, M
If you really believe that all lives matter, then saying Black Lives Matter shouldn’t register as anything different on your radar. Black lives are a part of all lives, yes? So by acknowledging that black lives matter you’re really acknowledging that all lives, regardless of skin color, should receive equal treatment and equal protection by the law.
Bobdale · 56-60, M
So agree with u .!
Nika2002 · 22-25, F
It's an American thing. Blacks get a raw deal there because politicians and big business are so morally bankrupt.
ThePerfectUsername · 70-79, M
@Nika2002 It's not an american thing. Who do you think sold them all those slaves in the first place? It's something that most major white european countries I'm aware of played a part in and it needs addressing there too.
it's specific movement, and all lives matters is just generalized it, you don't like generalization right?
Bobdale · 56-60, M
So have to agree .
ViciDraco · 36-40, M
Imagine if you have three photos on the wall. One of the photos has been knocked to the floor. You walk into your home and see the photo on the floor and say "Oh no, that photo belongs on the wall." And then someone corrects you and says "All three of the photos belong on the wall."
Which statement is more accurate to describe the message you meant to convey? Saying that photo belongs on the wall does not mean the two still on the wall need to be removed. It is an acknowledgement that a problem exists. That one of the photos is not where it should be.
People generally agree that all lives matter, except for some who think that no lives matter. The message Black Lives Matter is a response to people treating black lives as if they do not matter as much as other lives. It is addressing the problem that exists. It is not a claim that the other lives should not matter.
Which statement is more accurate to describe the message you meant to convey? Saying that photo belongs on the wall does not mean the two still on the wall need to be removed. It is an acknowledgement that a problem exists. That one of the photos is not where it should be.
People generally agree that all lives matter, except for some who think that no lives matter. The message Black Lives Matter is a response to people treating black lives as if they do not matter as much as other lives. It is addressing the problem that exists. It is not a claim that the other lives should not matter.
bijouxbroussard · F
No, it doesn’t mean that at all. It’s an acknowledgement of the fact that historically and currently, in many instances black lives have not mattered.
OogieBoogie · F
It's a statement on the fact that although apartheid and racial discrimination and abuse is illegal in the US.... It STILL happens.
They suffered hundreds of years of it.
The point is.... Black lives matter as much as yellow, red, white and all the shades in between. 🙏
They suffered hundreds of years of it.
The point is.... Black lives matter as much as yellow, red, white and all the shades in between. 🙏
JaggedLittlePill · 46-50, F
Bye charmaine.