Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

If i tell you that any of the apparent design you saw in the universe was not the work of god... [Spirituality & Religion]

...but of time traveling humans or aliens, can you prove me wrong any more than i can prove you wrong about god?
Am i then just as justified in believing that as you are in believing a god is responsible?
Bushranger · 70-79, M
It was the white mice. You can believe in anything you like: faith doesn't require proof. But it you want to convince me, you'll have to provide evidence.
Speedyman · 70-79, M
Why should there be. Truth is truth. @Bushranger
Bushranger · 70-79, M
@Speedyman Not talking about truth here, but about examining concepts by way of hypotheticals and imagination. But yes, truth is truth, it just requires a determination as to which truth is the real one.
Speedyman · 70-79, M
Absolutely that’s why I believe the truth@Bushranger
Italianlover · 61-69, M
I say this for thought: if GOD DOES NOT EXIST AND MAN SAYS THIS GIANT BALL( MASS) EXPLODED AND HERE WE ARE.. THEN WHERE DID THIS MASS COME FROM AND WHAT CAUSED IT TO EXPLODE? NOTHING SELF EXPLODES WITH OUT EXTERNAL FACTORS. JUST BECAUSE YOU DONT UNDERSTAND GOD DOES NOT MEAN HE DOES NOT EXIST! IVE SAW MIRACLES WITH MY OWN EYES!
newjaninev2 · 56-60, F
@Italianlover [quote]what are we evolving to[/quote]

There’s no way of knowing... it depends on a constantly changing environment, and the consequent effects on allele frequency and distribution.

Do you understand that evolution issn’t teleological... there’s no goal, no ‘target’.

Ask me again in 20,000 years (although our species is very likely to be extinct before then)
Italianlover · 61-69, M
@newjaninev2 our wonderful college professors at work. Kent State is proof they're dumb asses. You're brainwashed my man. Good luck you're gonna need it
newjaninev2 · 56-60, F
@Italianlover Your response makes no sense, and I cannot see how it is germane to what we are discussing
kentex35 · 100+, M
yes you are entitled to free speech and thought and to me your argument is valid because of those inalienable rights. Although I feel differently in that there has been little discussion by scientists on your theory. I know that wasn't your point necessarily about how this all happened. I appreciate that you do in fact use your brain to question.
God or time travelers would appreciate that you used that ability to question.
kentex35 · 100+, M
@Pikachu I didn't mean to imply I that his idea or beliefs are less valid than mine. Theory was not the word I should have used it looks like my belief was more concrete than time travel aliens. I've watched history channel ancient aliens I find that very interesting. my favorite story part talking about the ark not being big enough to carry two creatures from every species but if an account soon just took DNA from every critter that could be stored till after the flood. The floods been proven the Divine intervention is faith. Anyway sorry if I acted like I was better. Not my intention. thank you
@kentex35

No worries, i didn't get the impression that you were being condescending.
kentex35 · 100+, M
@Pikachu thx
AceWarbringer · 36-40, M
Lmao. Dont force them to think! Their heads might e'splode!

Ok. So by your theory the timeline is circular. Any action is already predetermined by the fact that in order to have these future humans come back to start the loop again, all actions must lead up to the start of the loop right? (The loops start is arbitrary. All actions just run the loop)

Not sure I like that theory, takes away all efforts to improve because the loop is "god". And or is just another exploration of the singular God scenario.

I prefer rules bound in chaos myself. Who set the rules? Dunno, good idea to ponder because we don't have really any evidence to make a decision yet.

And the chaos gives us room to grow and improve. To make a struggle worthwhile.

We as a species languish without a goal to chase. By strangling our chances through hardcore belief that everything is predetermined... Is a harmful blow to our own growth.
xRedx · M
Wouldn't it be your job to prove me that? After all, you're the one stating it. Before you go on assuming like you often do, I haven't and will not mention my religion. I'm not advocating for or against your view, but you'd need to explain your claim. In any case, you can choose to believe in what you wish.
SatanBurger · 36-40, F
@xRedx Lmao no you just don't want to answer the question for the reason I stated.

As for the rest, I have to assume you're trolling that's the best compliment I can give you because otherwise.. 😂
@xRedx Yes, that assertion would have to be proven, same as the assertion that an eternal, invisible, all-powerful being is responsible for the apparent design we observe. The point is that Pikachu's assertion isn't any more or less plausible than the theistic one.
@xRedx

Yes, if i claimed that this was the truth then i would bear the burden of proof just as the theist does.
But as i'm sure you're aware, the rejection of the claim "god is real" is frequently met with "prove god is not real".
My question is, am i as justified in asking you to disprove my future human/alien claim as you are to ask me to disprove a god claim.
trackman11 · 61-69, M
It’s not my business what or who you believe in. I have no desire to mock or belittle it. 🙂
@trackman11

Good attitude.
Me neither.
Italianlover · 61-69, M
@trackman11 good man
Speedyman · 70-79, M
Hilarious! Apparent design now! LikeHamlet was apparently written by Shakespeare! 🤣🤣🤣
Speedyman · 70-79, M
If you believe Sam Harris you will believe anybody! What a plonker! 🤣@newjaninev2
newjaninev2 · 56-60, F
@Speedyman In the quote I posted, Sam Harris isn’t asking you to believe him. He’s pointing out the absurdity of your statement that there’s 'no evidence for atheism’.
Speedyman · 70-79, M
I’m glad Sam Harris isn’t asking me to believe him because he is quite absurd@newjaninev2
Groofydorkgerdo · 56-60, M
No I can't, and you may place your faith in what you wish.
Dshhh · M
yes,, two unprovables are of equal value
Zero
SatanBurger · 36-40, F
Good point, I'd be curious to see how they justify it.
@SatanBurger

Me too. I suspect the bible will enter into it. Beyond that i expect to hear that the universe must have come from somewhere and therefore it is more justifiable to believe a god is responsible.
SatanBurger · 36-40, F
@Pikachu After seeing further responses, you're getting a lot of red herrings, I think we both know why but I won't go into it lol. The answer is if one believes that God just created the whole universe without such evidence other than the bible, than it could very well be aliens or time traveling humans also but they won't tell you that ;)
Carazaa · F
@SatanBurger @Pikachu @Italianlover @newjaninev2 @Bushranger
How can I or anyone prove that God created the earth, and that he is with those who love Him. I think you have to look at the Christian countries and see they are prospering, and Christian families and see that they are successful, and talk to someone who has faith and has seen God move in many peoples lives, and talk to many very successful and happy scientists and their families. The really successful scientists that I have seen in my home, visiting researchers from all over the world, are curious people. Not only about science but about why we are here, where we came from, and how to be happy and be successful. They ski, play the piano, have bands, they paint, write books, travel everywhere, and read everything including the Bible.

Science does not answer the vital questions they have, so they aren't fanatical about what they do in general, it is a reward for being curious and diligent at work and highly educated. The most vital questions are where did we come from, why are we here, and what is our purpose for living, and how to have success. Science only answers some, not all, and it doesn't give a road to successful living, hope for the future, and why we are here, and what happens to our soul, and that there is someone who will help us when we are discouraged.

The Bible answers all those questions. It gives us hope for the future because we know someone loves us and will help us. "We are fearfully, and wonderfully made" God tells us. God has a purpose for all of us. To live our best life. This life is very important, but short. I have a strong faith and believe God gives me wisdom daily of what to do, and he helps me. I would have never been as successful in my field if I hadn't leaned on God. I would not be writing books, I would not have been able to have a business, or overcome so many obstacles, and also have fun, ski, and travel. Why I love the videos is because Dr. Tour is a great scientist and knows many scientists, and like myself he will admit we know nearly nothing. The more we know, the more we know that we don't know very much at all. But the Bible tells us all that we need to know to have a very successful science career, or to be successful in anything in life! Who but Jesus can take away all your sins so you stand spotless in front of God, and who else but Jesus answers prayers, and gives us promises for tomorrow, and tells us the future?
Italianlover · 61-69, M
JUST LIKE AIR, you can't see it or touch it but you know it's there. SO IS GOD!
newjaninev2 · 56-60, F
@Italianlover [quote]can't see it or touch it[/quote]

You can measure the pressure it exerts, you can analyse its chemical composition, you can measure its effects (e.g. Raleigh Scattering), and the only reason it is invisible to [i]human[/i] eyes is that our eyes are adapted to the subset of the electromagnetic spectrum where air has no absorption peaks.

Can’t touch it? lol! What do you think wind might be?
@Italianlover

[quote]JUST LIKE AIR, you can't see it or touch it but you know it's there. SO IS GOD![/quote]

I'm sorry, but that's such a weak analogy. As newjanine explained to you, air is measurable and quantifiable.

Say, did you understand the ape evolution post?
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
basilfawlty89 · 31-35, M
Well I mean, depends on how you define God.

 
Post Comment