Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Is there a book you were required to read in school that you loved? one you hated?

[i]The Great Gatsby[/i]; and I benefited very much from reading it under the guidance of a teacher who could point out the subtleties.

[i]Ivanhoe[/i] was supposed to appeal to boys, but it was just boring to me.


P.S. After college a high school friend introduced me to [i]Pride and Prejudice[/i] and [i]Emma[/i], both of which I found spectacularly funny and engaging. Frankly, although I love science fiction and detective novels, Jane Austen would be my favorite author if she had produced more books like those two.
@originnone I really liked Northanger Abbey. It's hilarious. I can't believe that it hasn't been made into a movie yet.
originnone · 61-69, M
@LeopoldBloom I read it years ago...honestly don't remember it.
@LeopoldBloom I have read the whole Austen oeuvre. What I didn't mention is that my high school friend became an English professor. He told me that [i]Northanger Abbey[/i] is partly a parody of [i]The Mysteries of Udolpho[/i] by Ann Radcliffe. So I read U[i]dolpho[/i] prior to [i]Northanger[/i] just to increase the pleasures of [i]Northanger.[/i] But I just didn't find any characters as pleasing as Lizzie or Emma. I'll re-read it, and I'll re-read [i]Persuasion[/i] and [i]Sense and Sensibility,[/i] but I expect [i]Pride and Prejudice[/i] and [i]Emma[/i] will still please me the most.
Picklebobble2 · 56-60, M
Loved Far from the Madding crowd ~ Thomas Hardy
Hated 1984 ~ George Orwell
Picklebobble2 · 56-60, M
@originnone Lucky them !
Could never quite figure out why dystopian novels were so 'popular' with exam boards of the time.
SW-User
@Picklebobble2 We had to read that one for science class, along with 1984 at the same time. Double bleak.
assemblingaknob · 26-30, F
@Picklebobble2 oop we surely won't get along
Sunstone · 41-45, F
The diary of Anne Frank. So sad, I've never forgot this book.
originnone · 61-69, M
@Sunstone Yes, it's a tough one to get through....
SW-User
Books I loved from school: Narnia Chronicles, Our Town, The Snow Goose, Madame Bovary, Hamlet, Othello, Sound and the Fury.

Books I hated: Most of the textbooks. They were as dry as dust.
originnone · 61-69, M
@SW-User My wife loved CS Lewis....I loved Madame Bovary...I applaud you for understanding Sound and the Fury. I had to read the Cliff Notes to figure it out! LOL
RileyLandS · 41-45, M
Had to read The Jungle, by Upton Sinclair. It was an incredible book.
originnone · 61-69, M
@RileyLandS I'll have to read it. I haven't.
hunkalove · 61-69, M
I had to read Great Expectations in 7th grade and thought it was great but it's the only Charles Dickens book I ever finished. And I wasn't a big fan of Shakespeare but I have seen every Shakespeare play and still think he is overrated.
originnone · 61-69, M
@hunkalove I didn't love Shakespeare either.
Jorgillo · 36-40, M
loved? nothing. Hated? neither.
---------------
I hated novels actually. I prefer to read informational things. Because knowledge is power and power is freedom
originnone · 61-69, M
@Jorgillo What kind of things do you like to read for example....
Jorgillo · 36-40, M
@originnone philosophy and psychology things mostly, but also love world religions text and poetry
originnone · 61-69, M
@Jorgillo interesting....I was really interesting in philosophy but lost interest when the classes I took were about basically summarizing what some guy said a long time ago....except for philosophy of logic....I did go back and get a masters in psych which I only practiced for a year or so part time....religions - I'm really interested in cults and studied christianity a lot, but I never understood poetry....
rockstar · 31-35, M
I vividly remember how much I enjoyed reading ‘The Adventures of Tom Sawyer’ by Mark Twain. I loved literature, but George Orwell was super boring.
loved - power of One
hated - power of One..
Galway Kinnell’s [i]The Book of Nightmares[/i] is one of my favorites. I didn’t care for Emily Dickinson, I think she’s overrated.
@originnone Here is a section where he is talking to his infant daughter.

I have heard you tell the sun, don't go down,
I have stood by as you told the flower, don't grow old, don't die.
Little Maud,

I would blow the flame out of your silver cup,
I would suck the rot from your fingernail,
I would brush your sprouting hair of the dying light,
I would scrape the rust off your ivory bones,
I would help death escape through the little ribs of your body,
I would alchemize the ashes of your cradle back into wood,
I would let nothing of you go, ever,

until washerwomen
feel the clothes fall asleep in their hands,
and hens scratch their spell across hatchet blades,
and rats walk away from the cultures of the plague,
and iron twists weapons toward the true north,
and grease refuses to slide in the machinery of progress,
and men feel as free on earth as fleas on the bodies of men,
and lovers no longer whisper to the presence beside them in the dark, O corpse-to-be . . .

And yet perhaps this is the reason you cry, this the nightmare you wake screaming from: being forever
in the pre-trembling of a house that falls.
originnone · 61-69, M
@LeopoldBloom I'm sold. I added it to my amazon list.
@originnone

On the path,
by this wet site
of old fires -
black ashes, black stones, where tramps
must have squatted down,
gnawing on stream water,
unhouseling themselves on cursed bread, failing to get warm at a twigfire -

I stop,
gather wet wood,
cut dry shavings, and for her,
whose face
I held in my hands
a few hours, whom I gave back
only to keep holding the space where she was

I light
a small fire in the rain.

The black
wood reddens, the deathwatches inside
begin running out of time, I can see
the dead, crossed limbs
longing again for the universe, I can hear
in the wet wood the snap
and re-snap of the same embrace being torn.

The raindrops trying
to put the fire out
fall into it and are
changed: the oath broken,
the oath sworn between earth and water, flesh and spirit, broken,
to be sworn again,
over and over, in the clouds, and to be broken again,
over and over, on earth.
revenant · F
Anything poetry. I am just allergic. I remember that teacher screaming in my face in front of everyone because of my bored face.....I do not know the intention of the poetry writer nor do you but I can make it up for you if you wish and appear very so called intellectual.....😂
ChipmunkErnie · 70-79, M
Loved? Probably not loved, but many I liked/enjoyed. Hated? Maybe LORD JIM by Conrad back in high school. For some reason I just could NOT get through it. In college I read it no problem, seemed almost like a different book.
originnone · 61-69, M
@ChipmunkErnie hmmmmm....I'll look it up...
woodyemma2013 · 36-40, F
Loved a few of them wuthering heights, goodnight Mr Tom, lord of the flys all great books. I'm not a massive fan of Shakespeare but can't say I hated any of them
Picklebobble2 · 56-60, M
@woodyemma2013 My Son HATED English lessons in school. And never read.
Until one day he came home with Magorian's Goodnight Mr.Tom.
Don't know why but it just appealed to him.
woodyemma2013 · 36-40, F
@Picklebobble2 it's an excellent book. The film is good too.
originnone · 61-69, M
@woodyemma2013 I'm not familiar with Mr. Tom. The others are great...and...I appreciate Shakespeare but don't prefer it.
Starcrossed · 41-45, F
I liked Lord of the Flies, in college computer science we had to read this dystopian sci-fi Moths to the Flame the Seductions of Computer Technology and that book still haunts me.
originnone · 61-69, M
@Starcrossed I read it a while back and loved it.
assemblingaknob · 26-30, F
One I loved: the mayor of casterbridge
One I hated: far from the madding crowd
originnone · 61-69, M
@assemblingaknob Oddly.....years ago I wanted to read something by Hardy. I decided on either the mayor of caster bridge and the Tess of Deuberville. I picked the second.
assemblingaknob · 26-30, F
@originnone never read Tess. The opening chapter was so boringgggg pffftftttt I hate old times books. My dad says they probably wrote reallyyyyy slow because many times these were published in newspapers and the writers would get paid for each time, so they'd intentionally write lengthy paragraphs xD. But maybe my dad and I just aren't classic lovers and he just made it up.
originnone · 61-69, M
@assemblingaknob Your dad is a wise man.
foldedunfolding · 41-45, F
i loved Jane Eyre and Paradise Lost! Hated the long-winded Robinson Crusoe!
originnone · 61-69, M
@foldedunfolding Jayne Eyre was awesome. Not so fond of the other two.
foldedunfolding · 41-45, F
@originnone when it talks about the weeping odorous balms of eden in paradise lost..it was gorgeous to me
DearAmbellina2113 · 41-45, F
I loved [i]Great Expectations[/i] and[i] Romeo and Juliet[/i]. Hated [i]The Great Gatsby [/i]and [i]Of Mice and Men[/i].
originnone · 61-69, M
@DearAmbellina2113 I'm surprised "Of mice and men" was on the list; "the great Gatsby" I get.
GuyWithOpinions · 31-35, M
Animal farm was good. The boy in the striped pajamas was good.
originnone · 61-69, M
@GuyWithOpinions I've not heard of the second one....
GuyWithOpinions · 31-35, M
@originnone its about a little boy in an auswitz enternment camp
originnone · 61-69, M
@GuyWithOpinions Ugh...I've been trying to avoid those type of books. I did read one by Victor Frankle recently....
TinFoilHat · F
Loved all of Thomas Hardy & Graham Greene
I wasn't a fan of The Grapes of Wrath 💤💤💤
Lord of the Flies was imposed on us so we'd know that civilization won't work.
ImpeccablyImperfect · 51-55, F
Loved:
Island of the Blue Dolphins
To Kill a Mockingbird

Disliked:
Lord of the Flies
originnone · 61-69, M
@ImpeccablyImperfect I never read Island, but I bought it for my wife last year when she could still read. To Kill a Mockingbird is a wonderful book. I loved Lord, but I can see why someone wouldn't.
Good question I’m sure there was but I can’t remember the names of either.
SW-User
Lord of the Flies and Frankenstein were the only two I really cared for
Death Of A Salesman - not a fan

The Chosen - Chaim Potok --enjoyed that one
Loved - the outsiders
Hated - Speak
A Separate Peace, which intrigued me.

Lord of the Flies, which I found grim.
originnone · 61-69, M
@bijouxbroussard I hated A Separate Peace in high school but read it again later and loved it.
Bobboo78 · 46-50, M
Wot you meen
Plays.
Anything that was a play or by Thomas Hardy
originnone · 61-69, M
@V00doo agreed on hardy
I loved most of them

I hated Chaucer
And Middlemarch by George Eliot

 
Post Comment