Sad
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Controversial opinion but.

Ukraine isn't the only war going right now.

There's a civil war in Ethiopia and unnecessary bombing by Saudis in Yemen and killing kids there.

Why has this war affected you more than the other wars? Cause the people involved are white-ish?

See, all wars are bad. It's just so sad seeing normal people suffer. But, imagine supporting sending weapons to ukraine and pressuring Russia when your goverments are already doing full business with Saudis.


I'm not comparing wars. Every war sucks and should never happen, including when the Americans tried to control the middle East. I'm just pointing out the underlying racism.


There are no good guys in a war. It's always the civilians who suffer. This time, the civilians are considered white.
ChipmunkErnie · 70-79, M Best Comment
Because it's the only one with the possibility to expand into a World War.

And, oddly, if you go back to WWII, you'll find that the Nazis didn't consider Ukrainians -- or Russians -- to be "white" or Aryan or whatever; Slavs were an inferior race according to their beliefs. That's why they slaughtered even more Slavs than they murdered Jews. So the whole race thing depends on your point of view; in reality we're all just human.
Doometernal · 26-30, M
@ChipmunkErnie agreed. A decent perspective that i wish even the people who disagree with me can understand

i think you completely miss the point of the war in ukraine.

this was is happening in europe.. that makes it a whole different level of desaster. i dont know how much you know about Kekkonen and the "Spirit of Helsinki" a treaty that has bond all european countries to peace. the usa was never a fan of it but it was also the reason why nations like france and german didnt join the iraq conflict.. it was a bond that cemented peace for 50 years. a commitment. and putin teared that to shreds... he did the unthinkable and there is now a world before and after the ukraine invasion.

this is bigger then the suffering of the people right now that happens in all wars, this one set civilization back a hundred years.
SW-User
@Northwest Is what? Responding to you? Not really.

Actually taking anything you say seriously would be rather demented though.
Northwest · M
@SW-User Nice try with your other alias. Goodbye drone.
SW-User
@Northwest 😂 k bye
BlueVeins · 22-25
I generally agree that we should be concerned about other wars like Yemen and that racism is one of the many factors that contributes to the invasion of Ukraine getting more coverage in this moment. But sometimes there are good guys in war, you know? Like it's true that war is bad, but Ukraine didn't choose to be in a war; warfare came to them. The same is true of Poland and China in World War 2. Ukraine's obviously done some bad shit such as banning military-age civilian men from fleeing, but 'good' and 'perfect' are two separate things and zeroing in on the relatively minor sins of the party that's still in the right overall.
Doometernal · 26-30, M
@BlueVeins You are comparing two different things.

Who armed the Ukrainian rebels and gave them billions of dollars in finding each year?

Who disagreed on Russia's terms when they agreed and signed to diplomatic agreements saying that NATO shouldn't expand?

You corner down Russia like that and then they chose to destroy a neighbouring country for stupid reasons.

Who is in the wrong here? Both the west and Russia.

There are no good guys in this war. This is not Hitler era world war 2 type of war. This is a war that has been solved through diplomacy 10+ years ago before the NATO expansion started.
BlueVeins · 22-25
@Doometernal
Who armed the Ukrainian rebels and gave them billions of dollars in finding each year?

Vladimir Putin

Who disagreed on Russia's terms when they agreed and signed to diplomatic agreements saying that NATO shouldn't expand?

Ukraine is not responsible for for any deals made between Vladimir Putin and the gremlins that live in his brain. Even if there was, it's not Ukraine's fault that other eastern European countries joined NATO.

You corner down Russia like that and then they chose to destroy a neighbouring country for stupid reasons.

NATO isn't "cornering" Russia; countries proximate to Russia have been applying to join NATO and have been accepted. All sovereign states have a right to form military alliances with whoever they wish. By that logic, it would be immoral for Russia and China to ally with Cuba. And by the way, the main reason why eastern European countries even wanted to join NATO was because Russia kept attacking its neighbors unprovoked.
BlueVeins · 22-25
@Doometernal Also if you've read any of Putin's writings on Ukraine, you'll know he doesn't even believe in Ukrainian sovereignty regardless.
BlueVeins · 22-25
@Doometernal Russia terminated the Kharkiv Agreement in 2014, what are you talking about?
Doometernal · 26-30, M
@BlueVeins do more research.
BlueVeins · 22-25
@Doometernal If surrendering isn't the point, then what the Hell is? If you don't want Ukraine to be able to defend itself and you don't want Ukraine to surrender, then what do you actually want?
SW-User
I think it's important for people to have perspective, however it doesn't diminish the concern about this war, especially due to its potential to go nuclear or turn into a global war, which, whether we like it or not, the conflict in Yemen does not have such a potential. It's also simply a fact that people will relate more to a conflict that is "closer to home" metaphorically or literally. I am not saying that is good or bad, but it is a factor; it is human nature. People will be more affected by a death in the family than a shooting in their hometown and they will be more affected by that shooting than a war in Europe. There's a "hierarchy of concern".

I'm under no illusion that the U.S. and the West are always the "good guys" and I think it's important for us not to repeat our history. During the Iraq War, anyone who questioned it was a traitor who hated America and loved the terrorists. Now politicians running for office brag about not having supported that war or at least apologize for having supported it. History changes our perspectives but we often seem to learn little from it. I can only hope that doesn't happen this time.
msros · F
Russia and Ukraine are countries which export loads of stuff to many countries in the world starting with oil. The sanctions applied to it are affecting a lot of Africa and other countries that depend on Russia and Ukraine. That is why this war is hogging the news and also because of Europe being involved.
Doometernal · 26-30, M
@msros that's a good answer.
SW-User
I get that the west is hypocritical and that people should be talking about what Saudi Arabia is doing but this literally has nothing to do with race. There's outrage when Israel bombs or shoots Palestinians and there WAS outrage during the Iraq and Afghanistan invasions. The 2015 migrant crisis was relentlessly covered by the news.

It has everything to do with what media outlets and governments *choose* to talk about but fuck all to do with race or ethnicity. Saying otherwise is just beyond stupid and it detracts from valid points pertaining to western hypocrisy.
CountScrofula · 41-45, M
I think what makes Ukraine different is that its the first time our media is showing us the victim's perspective from bombing because normally we're the ones sending the bombs.

It's hard to not diminish the real and very human suffering going on while at the same time going "Where were all of you when we killed a million Iraqis for no fucking reason?!"
spjennifer · 61-69, T
@Doometernal Please understand, I wasn't saying it was good that 14k civilians died nor that we should have been there, simply stating accepted facts. War is never nice and many civilians were killed by their own insurgents while attacking us too. No doubt that the reasons we were there are questionable and History won't be kind to GWB, Chaney and Rumsfeld on that.
BlueVeins · 22-25
@spjennifer The Associated Press counted 110,000 just from body counts alone, and just from 2003 to 2011. I get that a lot of those weren't directly shot or bombed by US soldiers in particular, but we started the war so we should take ownership of its consequences. If we hadn't invaded Iraq, there would be no ISIL.
spjennifer · 61-69, T
@BlueVeins I'll believe that number but it is still far below the 1 million stated above. The Kurds were already warring with Iraq long before we got there and Saddam was killing his own people too. While yes, the war by the US may have been unjustified, Saddam was still a cruel Dictator who needed to be removed, if not by us then by who as Iraq had the 4th largest Army in the World at the time? As to whether ISIL wouldn't have existed if we hadn't invaded Iraq is open for debate as evidenced by it still existing today in Afghanistan despite our best efforts to eliminate it.
CrazyMusicLover · 31-35
Because it affects me, people around me and probably will even more in future. If Ukraine gets defeated we will be next.

If you refer to civilians being killed it's equally horrible everywhere. It doesn't matter who is on the footage from war it affects me emotionally equally.
Elessar · 26-30, M
@CrazyMusicLover You guys are NATO though. If you get attacked chances are that we all become a pile of ash (best case scenario) or slowly die of radiation poisoning and/or starvation no matter where we're sitting right now.

I'd be far more worried if I were a Finn or a Moldovan, if Ukraine fell, tbh
CrazyMusicLover · 31-35
@Elessar Nobody says that in the case of attack there would be nuclear weapons involved. I think it's very unlikely. I don't rely on NATO, they can dump us as a trash if they decide it's worth the peace in the west. We're not important to other European countries, we would be no economic loss to them.

I don't think they have intention to take Finland and Moldova was confirmed to be on their list already. Then probably Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania.

Well, I don't know but internal tension is no fun either. People are getting gun licences and buy guns, some are getting scared and nervous about refugees...I just wish this won't radicalize people to join far-right groups.
Elessar · 26-30, M
@CrazyMusicLover The whole NATO and the credibility of the west would crumble if even a single country was left on its own after invoking art 5 however, with repercussions that would spare no one. There would be no peace at that point, no other country would be safe, not even ones that are somewhat "distant" from the conflict at the moment, countries would fracture under internal dissent. The various economies would get wrecked in the process too, other currently neutral countries (🇨🇳) would initiate other expansionist campaigns elsewhere, considering NATO no longer much of a treat. I don't really envision that as a likely scenario, to be honest, it's as likely to trigger a world conflict as it would be engaging directly Russian forces, and in addition to that, to initiate it with a much lower morale on our . If the west didn't want to risk its economy over this conflict why impose sanctions or donate equipment, intel and weapons in the first place to a country that it's not obligated to defend? And *after* that, refuse to defend a country that it's obligated by a treaty to?

Anything involving a direct confrontation between NATO and Russian forces may easily escalate into a nuclear exchange, even if the initial response was conventional. It's been avoided for so long for a very very good reason. I don't think even Putin is that crazy to escalate to that before hitting some other place harder to defend, which is the reason why getting NATO membership is getting so popular in Finland and Sweden right now.

Yes, we're on a hell of a sh*tty ride and I can really imagine the tension is even higher over there. 🙁
SW-User
I don't know if I'd consider it racism. Too often, people's attention is aimed where they are pointed. It's what's new and news right now.

I agree war is not good no matter.
Doometernal · 26-30, M
@SW-User same news outlets also showed pics of kids in Yemen bombed and starving with no food.

You cannot blame it on news even though we kinda agree that news media is corrupted.

There should be some personal responsibility involved
SW-User
@Doometernal I did say NEW and news.
I'm probably too tired to do this justice.
Doometernal · 26-30, M
@SW-User hehe
SW-User
I think you are right about the racism, but there is a really obvious non racist reason why Western people care more about Ukraine, Ukraine is part of Europe so it's really close to home, literally and economically.
Doometernal · 26-30, M
@SW-User so you're explaining that there's a non racist bias but also considering individualist bias where no one wants awar at their home front.

if the individual bias is what matters then everyone wants war to end immediately ASAP. As far as we have seen every action from the west points to a serious escalation of a problem that has been solved diplomatically a long time ago.
SW-User
@Doometernal I'm saying that people care more because racism. They also care more because it's in the West and feel like it could be just as easily their home and could effect their lives more directly.
Viper · M
I don't think it's as much about race as it is about location and whom might get involved and how big it might get.


The middle east is at war? Um, with all due respect when wasn't the middle east in some type of war? That's sort of their norm.


Ethiopia is having a civil war (though what exactly is civil about a war), but it's not bringing bringing in other major countries.



Why the Ukraine war is so important, has absolutely nothing to do with the fact they're white...

But the fact that Ukraine was trying to get into NATO, and that this potentially could lead to WW3 as Russia is directly involved, NATO and China are indirectly involved.
Northwest · M
Yes, we are hypocrites, but pointing fingers, is not going to resolve the humanitarian tragedy in the Ukraine.
Doometernal · 26-30, M
@Northwest agreed.

Only way it can be solved is to bring USA and russia to a negotiating table at once

But oh wait, it was already done 10+ years ago! And USA broke the agreement rules.
Northwest · M
@Doometernal You don't really need to try hard. It's clear you're an anti-US social media activist, and NO the US did not break any agreements.
SW-User
I think there is something to what you are saying, but I think more of it is that this has awakened all the nightmares of the Cold War era and WW II before that.
Northwest · M
The pink dummy blocked me. That's OK, "she" will be back using one of her other aliases on SW 🤣
WhateverWorks · 36-40
Mainly because this one has the potential for WW3 with nukes
Khenpal1 · M
Few things is different. It has global impact , like 400 millions in Africa and regions around will have problems with food. If you live nearby any war will affect you , geopolitically when industrialized countries fight it turns ugly for everybody. Ethiopia, Yemen are hardly known to the rest of the world.
SunshineGirl · 36-40, F
Yes, and that may explain why people are more willing to open up their homes and borders than they were to Syrians . . for now. But it really doesn't matter what people's motivations are. All that matters is that some people are noticing and caring.
US never wanted to get dragged into Ukraine war, nor did it start it. So diplomacy is understanding the dependencies of countries on each other and delicately balancing it so that relations can be cordially maintained.

Sadly,
One of my co workers is Ethiopian and we have discussed what is happening there. He was anazed that I as an American was even aware of it. Of course, I used to live in West Africa.
DCarey · 46-50, M
You probably think somebody ordering vanilla ice cream is racism.
Doometernal · 26-30, M
@DCarey well, it's easy to think that world is simple at your age . Grow up.
DCarey · 46-50, M
@Doometernal Funny, I was going to tell you that. Grow the fock up. The reason so much attention is paid to the Russia/Ukraine war is because of the potentially catastrophic ramifications of nuclear-armed Russia actually using those weapons. Not the same in Ethiopia. By the way, I didn't see you mention the Azerbaijan/Armenia conflict. Why is that? Racism?
SW-User
Because it's a war with white people
basilfawlty89 · 31-35, M
Oh there's definitely racism.
Ukrainian refugees and asylum seekers are readily allowed in.
If you're brown, they tell you you're invading and want to deport you because you'll "adversely affect the culture".
Doometernal · 26-30, M
@basilfawlty89 so saddddd
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
Chickie · F
@Doometernal I feel like I am hushed by most Americans or can't say what I want to say because they would always retort to the "veterans sacrificed themselves for our freedom!!111" sounded like someone brainwashed and uneducated. There's a reason why they don't teach Americans about that stuff I am not for it, going to war was their choice, seeing their friends die, is their choice, I don't feel bad for them getting traumatized and I noticed a lot of people in the military are not right in the head, killing and raping people.
Doometernal · 26-30, M
@Chickie i have a different perspective regarding this.


Soldiers as individuals are just like us. But soldiers grouped together as army are controlled by people who sit at the top.

Have individual pity on those people but always condemn the people and the government who sent them to participate in a war.

Secondly, army recruits deliberately find poor and problematic people because they make the best cannon fodder for a war.

So, have pity on them as individuals. But do not respect them because they are part of an army.
Chickie · F
@Doometernal I won't have pity for them, I just can't. I lose respect for the army a long time ago.
This message was deleted by its author.
Doometernal · 26-30, M
@CopperCicada agreed.

Constructive form and making it look nice doesn't hide the racism part.

And yes, some things like this has to be direct instead of behind filters.
This message was deleted by its author.

 
Post Comment