Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Who fired first? Han or Greedo?

Poll - Total Votes: 7
Han
Greedo
Simultaneous fire
Doesn't matter because Greedo died
Doesn't matter because eventually Han also died
Doesn't matter in general
Show Results
You may vote on multiple answers.
I never really wondered or cared, but upon watching the movie again the other day, it looks to me like Han fires, his shot kills Greedo who then fires spasmodically and way off. If Greedo fired first, he has pretty piss poor aim. Is this even intended as a serious sci fi dork question when someone asks it?
SW-User
I think this is one of those things that Lucas ended up altering in later releases
SW-User
Huh, well alright then. I did not know that
BlueMetalChick · 26-30, F
You are correct.
DanielChristensen · 46-50, M
@BlueMetalChick: Are you referring to the altering of who fired first? Who fired first originally then? I believe I once heard that the Millennium Falcon was originally destroyed as it fled the 2nd Death Star, but fans were outraged in initial screenings. You do recall that Han has a premonition that he will never see his beloved freighter again.
QueenElsa · 22-25
Depends on which version of Star Wars you have
BlueMetalChick · 26-30, F
@DanielChristensen: It's mostly because of how many times it was changed. It was altered in 1997 when the few frames were added of Greedo shooting and missing and Han shooting back. Then in 2004 when the movie was released on DVD, the timing was altered again so that Han dodges Greedo's shot instead of him just missing. The reason it's controversial is because Lucas deliberately changed the scene to make Han's character seem "less like a coldblooded killer" and help people empathize with him because it's more understandable to kill someone when they're gonna shoot you, but personally I kinda like the idea of Han being that deadly.
DanielChristensen · 46-50, M
@BlueMetalChick: How do you feel about the altering of Hayden Christensen for the old jedi force ghost in the original film? I kind of like seeing the young Anakin restored, next to his friend and master, but it also feels kind of shitty because 1) I didnt find Haydens acting to be that great and 2) Okay, Vader chose to save his son in the end, but he lived a lifetime of mass murder and all kinds of delicious villainy before that. Does he deserve a nice force ghost? Idk, not for me to decide, of course, just my ponders. Read the Darth Vader comics. They are awesome.
BlueMetalChick · 26-30, F
@DanielChristensen: I think it wasn't so much because he saved his son but because he killed Darth Sidious, his own master, and ultimately fulfilled the prophecy of his destiny to be the one to return order to the galaxy.
BlueMetalChick · 26-30, F
In the 1977 original version, Han shot Greedo. Greedo never fired his gun. In the remastered high definition release of the movie, a blaster bolt from Greedo's weapon was added to the scene to show that Greedo shot first and Han retaliated. George Lucas said that he had intended Greedo to have shot first the entire time but had overlooked the need to add an animation of Greedo's gun discharging.
DanielChristensen · 46-50, M
Oh interesting, thank you.

 
Post Comment