Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

What makes a person truly evil? Are they born that way or did their environment make them that way?

SW-User
I think psychopaths are born that way. And then the environment moulds them into how bad they will get.
Neena · F
@Aidolovemostofyourthoughts: Yeah . Mostly it is the environment . If we can try and make those environments good so that the new born are grown into goodness , it would be really great .
SW-User
@Neena: But it is first and foremost the way they are born. Psychopaths as well as sociopaths lack the empathy sensor in their brain. Most truly evil things are done by people who are labeled psychopaths.
Evil things are done out of circumstance. Also, evil can be very subjective thing for people.
Neena · F
@Aidolovemostofyourthoughts: So we are left with only few options . Either makes a suitable sensors with auto correcting mechanism or people around them be more responsible . And the so called psychopaths themselves have a responsibility to learn what is right .
Picklebobble2 · 56-60, M
Many are a product of the environment they were brought up in.
Parents with deficiencies of their own. Both mentally and emotionally.
Some had other experiences. Maybe suffered violence or sexual abuse that meant their understanding of normal and abnormal behaviour is more extreme from the norm.
Some may feel they have no control of themselves. Or more likely, believe they are being controlled by something, someone else.
Then you get 'functioning psychotics.'
People who don't need reminding to do the normal things in life. But have an extreme liking/hatred for a certain type of person or group and develop irrational reasoning for it.
Neena · F
@Picklebobble2: You are right ! Society has a big part to play in making a person good or evil .
Picklebobble2 · 56-60, M
@Neena: There's an expression that goes.....It takes a village to raise a man.
I think this is largely true.
Unfortunately, folk are often ostracised by some of their peers for whatever reason.
This leads them to retreat into worlds of their own and the result of that can often have tragic consequences.
One thinks of many of the American school shootings for example.
Sad thing is those things occur with such horrible regularity. Yet America is neither interested in curbing it's guns nor those who want to own them. Nor do they want to shrink the sizes of their schools. And so they go round and round.
NeloAngelo · 26-30, M
truly evil? it depends on your point of view. as a wiccan the catholic church would brand me as evil. as a man overzealous feminists might brand me as being evil, as someone who takes forever to order a subway sandwich everybody can call me evil. its neither born nor environment. just how you are percieved.
Neena · F
@NeloAngelo: I am glad that you could categorize that quickly . I couldn't :)
If I am standing behind you in a queue , I will make sure that I am in no hurry :)
Neena · F
@SimplyTracie: I agree , little girl :) You got to cool down a bit ..haha :)
SimplyTracie · 26-30, F
@NeloAngelo: I've learned to accept certain behavior as part of society.

Maybe I'd just punch you so you hurry up. 😂😂😂
Some people have survived traumatic childhoods but aren't evil...I think it's within you, part of your makeup
Neena · F
@Loulou: Very well said ! and hats off to those people . We should really appreciate them and look up to them as examples .
It's certainly an interesting topic
Neena · F
@Loulou: yes , it is :)
Allelse · 36-40, M
Our nature, how we're raised and our life experiences all influences our decisions, but in the end the choice is up to us. There are those who are more influenced by their nature, others are more influenced by the way they were raised. But again it all comes down to choice. Even if you're a functioning sociopath you've made the decision at some point not to go out killing everyone you dont like, while others have done the opposite.
Neena · F
@Allelse: Well said , Allesle :) . No one gets the perfect circumstances . One who can defy the wrong circumstances and follow a wise path is truly great ! May be life is an opportunity for us to correct the wrong path we have chosen in the past .
Allelse · 36-40, M
@Neena: Thank you. Perhaps it is.

For a long time all I had was the 'Nature, nurture and life experience' but it was missing something, a vital part and I realized that it was choice. That was the finale piece, choice.
GwydionFrost · 56-60, M
Society defines what is evil and what is not. Ergo, if someone is truly evil, it is because society says they are. Nothing more, nothing less.
Neena · F
@GwydionFrost: Yes and the society consists of us . In most cases we agree to the standard set good good and evil .
GwydionFrost · 56-60, M
@Neena: As a general rule, "evil" usually consists of placing oneself over others, most often at their expense. Anything considered "selfish" is "evil".
Neena · F
@GwydionFrost: I agree . Evil is triggered by selfishness .
SimplyTracie · 26-30, F
I agree with Otaku-san. We are all born innocent and our upbringing causes us to do evil acts.
SW-User
@SimplyTracie: [quote]OTAKU-SAN.[/quote] I LOVE YOU.
Neena · F
@SimplyTracie: I agree . But if we know that we are in a wrong path we should try and correct ourselves .
SimplyTracie · 26-30, F
@ThePhilanthropeOtaku: 😊
It could be a condition of either or both. We are a products of our environment. But, we are also ourselves.
Neena · F
@JoanieNewHampshire: Well said !
Thank you, I'm a nature first nurture second kind of person.@Neena:
Neena · F
@JoanieNewHampshire: so nice :) great to know .
A truly evil person does hideously wrong things with the full understanding of how wrong they are
Neena · F
@likatiga: You are right !
SW-User
It's more of how they were raised. No one is born evil.
Neena · F
@ThePhilanthropeOtaku: true !
NorthernRoses · 22-25, F
100% learnt. No one is born evil.
Neena · F
@NorthernRoses: Rightly said . But defying the wrong circumstances and following the right path proves our greatness .
ABCDEF7 · M
50% Genes, 50% up bringing and life experiences/environment.

Note: Yoga can even change your DNA.

So it's in your hands.
ABCDEF7 · M
@bijouxbroussard Simply Google it. I hope you will find the answers.
@ABCDEF7 The only thing I found was a [b]theory[/b] that yoga can ‘reverse’ (quotes theirs) molecular reactions in one’s DNA to stress.
ABCDEF7 · M
@bijouxbroussard Did you checked research done at Coventry University.

https://www.coventry.ac.uk/primary-news/meditation-and-yoga-can-reverse-dna-reactions-which-cause-stress-new-study-suggests-/
That's a good question; I've always wondered about it. I tend to think even those we categorize as "evil" are severely mentally and emotionally ill. And I tend to think they are so as a result of their upbringing and experiences.
Neena · F
@bijouxbroussard: Thank you . That's true . Sometimes I wonder whether we tag a person as evil and make him dip more into evilness . It would be better if we can give them a chance to come out of evil state to the goodness state . We may not succeed 100 % and failures are bound to be there but its worth a try .

 
Post Comment