I went to the Kentucky Derby this year and it was all about the bourbon. I went to Makers Mark. They have this stuff that is pretty good. Makers Mark 46
I like Oban Scotch. Their most expensive variety costs more than the equivalent of 70 pounds in the US, but that includes import duties. So it is probably within your budget if you buy it on your side of the pond.
@MartinII I buy Little Bay, which I think has a unique kind of flavor. It is the least expensive of the Oban scotches. I just checked online and discovered that in addition to the 14 year old, there is also an 18 year old, of which I was unaware. I was referring to the 14 year old when I responded. (It was $94 when I looked on the shelf at my local liquor store last weekend.)
I would recommend something special. A Lagavulin 16 might be out of your range, but a Redbreast 12 would probably fit the bill. 5 Year or older is serviceable, but it is a special occasion. If he's below 25, don't worry, just get him something with volume. If he's older than 25, get him something aged and indelible. I'm sure no matter what you get, he'll love it.
Price is not the criteria here as many have different taste. Though Single malts are high in price, blended has its own flavours. Most popular is Famos Grose and Dewar tastes good and smooth. JW blue and black labels are fine scotch too.
[i]this is the core of the problem[/i], and why you should stop here, and either ask him, or start choosing from things you [i]do[/i] know about him ... nobody on SW knows him and can possibly make anything but a random suggestion, which is sure to reveal to him that you don't really know him, which defeats the purpose of gift-giving ... it just says "I never took the time to get to know your interests, I'm sorry" @Beautifullyderanged
@BizSuitStacy I have tried a whole variety of them throughout the years. I tend to go to the less peaty ones recently. I just bought an Aberlour and Cardhu.
It's like anything else, if you don't even have a vague idea of why type of _____ the recipient likes, then anyone trying to make a recommendation to you is just being completely random and pulling answers out of the sky. So maybe a person suggests what [i]they[/i] like — your brother may like exactly the opposite, so it's ultimately a waste of everyone's time, never mind money. There's no magic answer, if you don't know a gift recipient's interests well enough that you ask strangers for completely random advice. It's just such a fuitile endeavor, whether it's whisky or any non-beverage thing.
It would perhaps be better to maybe take them to a whisky bar and let them pick out what they like and simply pay for it as your gift. Take them to a whisky tasting event, if there is such in your area. Or forget about whisky and pick a gift from a subject where [b][i]you[/i][/b] already know what he likes.
Or get to know their actual preferences about ____ better, before even considering giving them ____ as a gift. If you knew your brother well enough to know that he already likes ____ X or wants to try ____ Y, that's the only ____ you should give him, not a ____ suggested by a random stranger, even a stranger who is a ______ expert. Better yet, bring your brother along and let hm talk to the ____ expert, and then your brother knows best which ____ that he has never tried before sounds more appealing to him. There is no substitute for his own opinion on which new ____ to risk trying.