Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Stay with new therapist?

So I began seeing her back in January. I have been with her nearly 4 months. She is positive and kind and empathic...but doesn't SAY much to me about my issues. If I talk about having no self esteem from decades of horrible abuse, instead of asking further questions or brainstorming NEW ways I can view myself..she mainly agrees or nods. To most issues. I talk for 45 out of 50 minutes. She will offer typically one line towards the end that I find positive. But with the level of anxiety that has made my life stuck..I need more than one line really in 50 minutes. However I am so stuck I just grasp at that one thought and am grateful for it anyways. But to try to find ANOTHER therapist is daunting. To start my story AGAIN with someone new; It can feel exhausting sometimes. Would you just ask directly for tips or possibly find another fit?
CountScrofula · 41-45, M
I think you need a therpaist who actually deals in useful techniques. Self-regulating therapy, CBT, and DBT for example. Look for someone who has expertise in these practices. My wife goes to a therapist who is extremely good at helping her gain control of her anxiety and it has taken years, but it is really working.
Coralmist · 41-45, F
@CountScrofula thanks for saying that me talking and them just basically listening is not real therapy
Starcrossed · 41-45, F
@Coralmist my understanding is that your brain processes thoughts differently when you do it.


Perhaps related, I remember learning a long time ago that people naturally look back and forth when on silent walks while in deep thought.
Starcrossed · 41-45, F
We've also been trying brain spotting a couple times recently and that seemed to have some interesting results.
JoyfulSilence · 46-50, M
I know what it is like having to explain my medical history over and over. When I was in the hospital and rehab, there was a rotation of doctors and nurses, and although they had information on a computer, I still had to repeat a lot. Even question their treatment.

Like one person agreed to stop a drug that was no longer needed and causing problems, then another person gave it to me later because the computer still said so. It was so annoying. Please update the computer record! Later I found they kept giving me the drug, but under a different, generic name. I was like, WTF? After that I started questioning all my drugs.

I was on one the past four weeks: awful enemas. They seemed to make things worse at times. Then I got sick for other reasons, and paused the last three doses. When I recoved, I said to hell with it, I am done with enemas. I tossed out the last three bottles.

I want my old life back! I am sick of all this medical attention.
Coralmist · 41-45, F
@JoyfulSilence I agree doctors really need to update the next nurse or doctor..and the patient is ill..they don't have the energy to keep retelling their whole history..ughh. they did it to my sister in the hospiral too.
JoyfulSilence · 46-50, M
@Coralmist

What was worse was having my father visit or call. He would interrogate me like I was on trial. I could not recall what people said. If a nurse or doctor were present I would just hand them the phone. They found him annoying, too.

I tried harder to remember what people said just to get my father off my back. He was helping me with stuff so I had to be nice. But he caused me unnecessary stress. I just wanted to sleep, he wanted medical reports.
JustDJ76 · 46-50, M
Anxiety does make it hard to speak up for yourself sometimes. Sometimes finding the right words is hard too and saying them the right way can be difficult as well. Have you considered writing how you feel in a letter or possibly emailing your therapist, if they have one?

A good therapist is there to help you and will understand.
twiigss · M
You could try this: Tell the therapist a small part of the larger story, and after you say that small part you say, "what are your thoughts about this?". Or after you tell the small part, maybe tell the therapist how it made you feel and then say, "but I want to know what you think?"

At least that way you're trying to engage with the therapist and have a back and forth rather than just you talking for 50 minutes. Maybe the therapist doesn't know when to interject and ask questions? It's just a thought but, that could be why she just nods and agrees. Information overload.
Coralmist · 41-45, F
@twiigss Ty...I could try that🌺 I do leave pauses for her to ever challenge my fear or issue or maybe extend a bit but ..unfortunately she doesn't. I may try your idea asking her directly of her thoughts.
Lostpoet · M
I saw a therapist once and she explained to me that they want you to tell them these things and then go home and examine them for yourself because coming to terms with past traumas and accepting them and the emotions caused by them is the first step. Therapists are also conscious of moving things to fast which can cause a person to not want to talk about things and cancel their appointments.
Coralmist · 41-45, F
@Lostpoet That is true.. but I have gone through this trauma alone too long. I haven't found a way to heal myself. I think a lot just don't want to delve in further..they are getting paid a good amount to know ways of attacking thoughts or methods OF new thinking..she hasn't mentioned any. But I might give it a bit longer as she is a positive person and I need that.
exchrist · 31-35
I suggest informing the therapist of your desire for my interaction. If they know thats what you want and need either they might give it or you will have to find someone else.
That being said in alot of instances a patient just needs to vent so the therapist might have alot of those type of clients. Make them earn their keep as they say. Its easy to fall into a rut and what is familiar simply becomes routine/standard.
This has been going on for a while. What stops you from telling her that you need more feedback?
ninalanyon · 61-69, T
@Coralmist Perhaps it's time to try a different idea, or two. Perhaps join some kind of club or association. Or if you are religious perhaps join some kind of congregation.

Or perhaps try to identify your least worst problem and confront it directly, if that works move on to the next one.

Don't take me too seriously, I'm lucky enough to not have many problems. But as @OlderSometimesWiser says you seem to be stuck in a rut, perhaps just getting out of the rut might help even if only a little.

What I can say is this: in my journey from an occasional very private cross dresser to someone who confidently goes out in public dressed just as I want, what worked for me was to repeatedly take tiny steps. In my case it was things like: add a bit more jewellery, wear brighter colours, wear shorter skirts, higher heels, lipstick, get my ears pierced. I could never have gone from dressing male to doing all that at once but doing one tiny thing and waiting until that felt ordinary, then another small thing and another wait for ordinaryness, and so on seems to work for me.

Perhaps something analogous could work for you.
Catzgano · 31-35, F
@ninalanyon trauma work is different and many people say they treat it but really dont
Coralmist · 41-45, F
@ninalanyon @ninalanyon That is a great Way to diminish a a fear...little by little making things ordinary. Ty for your ideas🦋
Catzgano · 31-35, F
I would choose another only because you should not be stuck after 4 months in like the same position. Some therapists say they treat traumas or eating disorders but actually know little about them or think they can like fake it.
Coralmist · 41-45, F
@Catzgano Exactly the last one said she knew trauma and then said negative things u would never say to someone with trauma. My new one said she specializes in it but doesn't offer anything on trauma itself or how to heal it when I discuss it. I think many just act like the patient ONLY needs to vent so they just nod. We need HELP that is why Im there!😮
Guardian · 56-60, M
CB Therapy is all about you talking to yourself focusing on you. She's not supposed to say much. It appears to be working; you're very self-reflective.
okaybut · 56-60, M
Telling the story again might even be beneficial, so I would not let that affect your decision.
Jenny1234 · 51-55, F
Ask her to give you tips or direction for new ways you can view yourself.
caccoon · 36-40
Find another therapist! Sometimes therapy means graduating from one therapist to another. She has given you what she could

A good therapist should make you feel safe, and ask about things without pushing you. Someone who can help you ask the right questions to find healing 💙💙 good luck
😟😔

If youre the one putting in so much effort....bypass the therapist and be your own.

There's enough information and help on YouTube for you to find a path forward that resonates with you .
And not empty your wallet to someone who isn't earning it.
Coralmist · 41-45, F
@OogieBoogie I think I do need a person .. i have debilitating PTSD that unfortunately online aid doesn't fully help. I guess I will need to ask for feedback more.. for now anyways. Ty my friend 🫂

 
Post Comment