Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

BREXIT? Yes or No?

Poll - Total Votes: 28
Yes! Britain should leave the European Union.
No! Britain should remain in the European Union.
Instead! - Britain should join the planet Mars!
Show Results
You can only vote on one answer.
As an American who follows global events, I have an opinion, but frankly it's not my call. So I won't post my opinion in this text. Maybe...(maybe, not yes)... in the responses below.

BREXIT? Yes or No?

(If you don't know what BREXIT is, that's fine, but please don't comment without knowing).
SW-User
Voted to remain. It's going to be impossible anyway to completely leave the European union
SW-User
This is has been going on since 1990, it's not overstated. If nothing else, it's understated, the media being what it is. It is a central issue - the law is badly worded and requirements are too heavy, what's more... and probably worse, the judicial system and lawyers are heavily biased towards extreme solutions that damage businesses, rather than be even-handed and fair to all.
SW-User
@SW-User Yes, Europe is more progressive than the UK by a long shot. Note how the family of a very, very, very wealthy aristocrat were able to avoid all taxes not least inheritance tax when he died: the Duke of Westminster. In France they beheaded members of the parasitic aristocracy... The Queen in the 7th richest woman in the world but pays next to no tax. Meanwhile there is homelessness, and a complete lack of support for the vulnerable including the elderly and the mentally ill. The UK is in the dark ages
SW-User
Well the Queen is a special case. Can't answer to that one. I'd be curious about the rest of the elites. As for European progressivism - it stopped being a good thing a while ago, and now borders on forms of autocracy. American and European concepts of freedom (and human rights) are different, and the Europeans stick their noses up at us (and even claim we're the arrogant ones), but individual rights matter in America and that what makes our country great. Europe is great for other reasons- fine, they can have it. The Declaration of Independence doesn't just apply in 1776 - it applies now... as a statement that emphasizes our separateness, in part because of our demand for respect to individual rights. Europeans see things differently.
SW-User
Thanks for the two videos. It's good to get both sides.
Although I'm wary about one of the comedy elites giving us a very one-sided view, and facetious view.
SW-User
Well I do agree with that... I'm very wary of US and European media.
SW-User
@SW-User Tune in to Aljazeera and also news from Russia: gives a very different perspective... Read between the lines too: what's the agenda?
SW-User
@SW-User If you are getting news from Aljazeera and from Sputnik, then it's mostly nonsense and bias, often purposeful.
ArtieKat · M
@JarJarBoom: No, Brexit is not the equivalent of North Dakota saying "we don't want to be part of the US anymore". The United States of Europe does not exist - back in the 1970s the United Kingdom voted to remain in what we had joined: The European Economic Community (E.E.C. aka The Common Market). The EU is not the same animal at all.
Carver · 31-35, F
I'm an American too but I think Britain will be much better off without the European Union. I think this video says it all, brings up a lot of great points as to why Brexit should happen:
[youtube=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rNJ05NfM-4Y]
SW-User
@Carver Well put!
SW-User
The UK has chosen to Leave (the European Union).... Happy Independence Day!
elVato · 46-50, M
EU is a sinking ship. Their weird social engineering in shuffling around all the muzzy refugees is just incomprehensible. If Britain leaves, France would be next to go, then it's game over. Germany and that weirdo Merkle and her self-hate would just have to sit & spin while their new 'citizens' burn down the place around them.
ArtieKat · M
At the age of 62 years, 11 months and 4 days, I've just exercised my democratic right to vote, for the first time in my life! National governments can be replaced fairly easily - and, as an old aphorism had it: "It doesn't matter which party you vote for because the government always gets elected" - there is little to choose between them. An unelected bunch of bureaucrats hell-bent on controlling a "United States of Europe" fills me with dread, however. Any opt-outs the UK currently has will be steamrollered out of the way in the name of "The European Project".

Can you guess which way I voted?
suzie1960 · 61-69, F
I'm English. Brexit will be a disaster for the UK. It's similar to a small state (Rhode Island?) leaving the Union.
SW-User
@suzie1960 on the positive side re a convenient scapegoat - they will no longer be able to use the EU as a convenient scapegoat for those laws
Being themselves directly accountable to the people - the British Parliament will have to face the music for its decisions
suzie1960 · 61-69, F
@SW-User It's still early days but the EU is moving towards greater unity. A lot of the problems are caused by the UK vetoing attempts to bring the member states closer together and other varoius motions. In some ways, they'll be well shot of us.

Our Government is even trying to dictate the terms of our leaving the EU rather than negotiate a settlement. Pretty typical really. They're trying to have their cake and eat it. They want all the benefits of EU membership with none of the obligations - they're not going to get it and the sooner they understand that the better.

There is also the problem of the borders with Ireland and Spain. The idea of Schengen is to remove internal borders while strengthening external ones. As a member of the EU we can have an open border with Ireland and free travel between Gibraltar and Spain. When we leave, absent any special arrangement, we have to be shut out. That means closing the borders with Ireland and Spain. No more free cross-border trade or travel.

Many workers in Gibraltar live in Spain, travelling to work will present major problems for them. Businesses in Gibraltar will find it difficult to recruit workers.

Looks like fun times ahead.
SW-User
Ok, I understand. But two things - first, there are plenty of reports of the EU's efforts toward greater unity being primarily a project of its elites - not of the populations of the countries involved. In many countries the populations are becoming upset with the interference of this extra national body, and not just the EU Parliament - but the bureaucrats and the courts into everyone's business. Stratfor and Geopolitical Futures are two think tanks that think the EU is facing tremendous strains to its unity.
Second point - this is an extra national government - dictating to sovereign countries. The UK is not a occupied country, or one that has totally failed its population and needs intervention. It's a sovereign country with a thousand plus year history, and it's freedoms and opportunities are being decided elsewhere?? Something really doesn't sound right.
The border issue is workable. I know it's problematic - and everyone knew it would be - but that's a workable problem. As for the negotiations - why shouldn't they push for the best deal? And I don't understand why there is a price to leave at all?? 60 billion Euros?... Seriously?!? I don't understand why your government doesn't just say "no" we're not paying that - let's negotiate the rest, but that is off the table. Period. I mean, the arrogance of the EU to demand payment of any kind - almost justifies Brexit by itself. It certainly confirms it.

Just my thoughts.
SW-User
Sky News and BBC have called it for BREXIT with 70% of votes in... though London will close the gap some.
SW-User
Yes!!!!!! 😆😃😄

If only to shove it to the armaggedon crowd -Britain will live on!
SW-User
Thanks for your comment.
Does it matter what celebs think? I mean, more than regular people. I don't know about the effect in Ireland, but I'm not buying the 'racist' argument. I think British culture has suffered from neglect, and an unwillingness to defend values. I think that's often pooh-poohed as racism, when it's clearly something else.
Myzery · 41-45, F
Not that it is my opinion that Britain should stay in the EU, but I thought I would post a video that kind of has the opposite position of Carver's just so that those who haven't heard of the Brexit can get a slight view of both sides. Even though John Oliver is now and American...and this issue is really complicated.
[youtube=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iAgKHSNqxa8]
Carver · 31-35, F
Myzery, I watched John Oliver's take on Brexit and while I do think he does bring up some valid points as to why Brexit would be bad for Great Britain in some areas, he didn't go a whole lot into how Britain would indisputably benefit from leaving the EU. And I think the pros outweigh the cons on this one.
SW-User
Ok. Thanks for you comment. Personally, I think it will hurt in the short-term, but in the long-run opens up much greater opportunity. I see both sides, but that's what I think recent the recent historical record shows.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
SW-User
yep... how 'bout bad spellin'...
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
Doran10 · 80-89, M
I only know what I have reading in newspapers/newsmagazines, but it seems that leaving the EU will cause economic upheaval and not just in the UK.
JarJarBoom · 41-45, F
I actually have been following this (no idea why) I think it makes more sense for them to remain in the union, economy-wise it will protect them in the long run.
SW-User
Artie, Carver, Duh... the election is neck and neck; much closer than the pundits said... a few have changed their prediction. We'll know in about 6 hours for certain.
SW-User
Yeah, but that's Obama... and he's a European in outlook. They comment on everyone's business.
MsMelissa · 31-35, F
I really hope they leave. The EU is just wrecking that country with muslim middle age throwbacks.
brexit is about 400K votes ahead on Aus radio.. c'mon britton. get on out of there
alan20 · M
I've always seen myself as European and been thrilled by the diversity of our continent. Also British and Irish - I live a mile from the border with the Irish Republic. So I've voted to remain and am hoping for the best vis-a-vis the result.
SW-User
I am hoping they leave. It seems the more optimistic thing to do and regains their sovereignty back closer to democracy. I've never forgiven the EU for intervening to stop them deporting an Iranian hate preacher
elVato · 46-50, M
Media here (US) is announcing a brexit loss.
100% US propaganda; but 'cmon Britain, you think your citizen votes count?
That hasn't worked here in decades.
hope so.. id like a to see the so called Kaos its going to create.. like every other country bailing on it..
SW-User
Oh... well... the Mars Vote was beginning to catch up...
... don't apologize... it was a flippant question choice... LOL.
SW-User
@guys was an Australian website but seems to have dissappeared

Might have been earlier opinion poll
ArtieKat · M
BTW, you guys across the pond: for President Obama to meddle in the affairs of a NATO ally is incredibly rude.
SW-User
I just finished it... it's a very good video Myzery. You can tell which way I lean, but I respect the video.
Myzery · 41-45, F
True. And he doesn't have as much of a horse in this race as some...
here is another.
[youtube=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=waQAPRtOoXI]
SW-User
It might take a while to fully appreciate it. I'll have more thoughts in the morning.
Myzery · 41-45, F
Carver: That is a bigger trend on the "Stay" stance.
And I am not disagreeing with you at all. I just thought for those that didn't realize what the Brexit was, they could see people talking from both sides. I selected John Oliver's first since he goes into more detail than most of the others on that side I could find. I think it might be worth leaving the EU.
SW-User
My thoughts exactly... I see nothing on the news.
ArtieKat · M
@Faerylight: I don't know where you're getting your information from, considering that the polling booths don't close for another 2 hours, and there's no official exit poll as there is for General Elections. None of the UK rolling news channels is making a guesstimate yet.
SW-User
It's beginning to consolidate!
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
berangere · 80-89, F
Yes Britain did well to leave the European Union,they now have more control over what happens in the country,more money that can remain in the country and be put to better use than being paid up to the European Union and more control over immigration.
SW-User
ArtieKat · M
@djce45, My apologies for voting flippantly in your poll for Britain to join the planet Mars. I can assure you I was rather more serious in the polling booth earlier!
ArtieKat · M
@Djce, I do indeed wonder if the 23rd June will become our Independence Day. I don't think that most of us who voted for Brexit can quite believe it yet.
Myzery · 41-45, F
Glad that video was better. lol
I am not trying to change minds. 🙂
Would be too late anyways.
JarJarBoom · 41-45, F
Is it the equivalent of North Dakota saying "we don't want to be part of the US anymore"
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
SW-User
Either way looks like Remain :-/
Honeylove · 46-50, F
A bit late to vote
SW-User
@Honeylove Well yeah... it's an older post.

 
Post Comment