Upset
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Is being agreeable and having no backbone a good reason to break up with someone?

Not only my first boyfriend broke up with me because I’m on the autism spectrum but also because he says, its an embarrassment having a bigger and talIer girlfriend, agreed with everything he says, well some things, I butter up (sugarcoat) things than to be blunt and straightforward. That irritated the crap outta him and also he said I had no backbone and he can’t be with a girl that can’t stand up for herself and let people walk over her. You’re a “yes” person and you can’t even be honest and I shouldn’t have to drag an opinion outta you!” He treated me like garbage and I took it. He looked at me saying, “REALLY?! Are you seriously going to let me treat you like this?! Your dad is right about one thing about you. You’re WEAK!” And just walked off. He cheated on me with another girl and he broke up with me over video chat and the girl he cheated on me with is petite and not tall and broad like me.
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
SavannahMay · 22-25, F
Yes, it is a good reason to break up with someone. Just not in the way that he did. But I wouldn't want a relationship, or even friendship, with someone who can't be real and honest with me. That would be like talking to a strange who doesn't know me well enough to be comfortable with or care about me enough to be real and upfront. I have broken off friendships in the past over that, and even a relationship.
SavannahMay · 22-25, F
That being said, there are some very sensitive people out there who would probably prefer that kind of a relationship. But as they grow as a person, as we all do, I don't see that relationship being sustainable. Nobody will want to be with someone long-term who won't help them grow by being honest and helping them do so. But if you just want a relationship for right now, and don't want to think about 2, 5, 10, 20 years down the line, I'm sure you could find someone who vibes with you at this specific point in their lives.
LaylaTheTallGirl · 22-25, F
@SavannahMay I understand that but he didn’t have to cheat on me! That’s wasn’t cool. My guy friend said that he shouldn’t have cheated on me but he had a point about me being too passive aggressive, I sugarcoat a lot of shit and I am way too agreeable. He said I was a yes woman and men don’t want that. He told me I didn’t have the guts to have my own opinion and be upfront.
SavannahMay · 22-25, F
@LaylaTheTallGirl I never once said he should cheat on you, but you cannot control what he does. You can control what you do. Cheating is never justifiable, and of course he first should have broken things off with you. But I absolutely understand him not wanting to be in the relationship if he feels you are not honest with him. Man or woman, what do you contribute to the relationship if you aren't willing to give advice or an honest opinion? WHat is a relationship without someone who can help you grow and do better and advise you on the future that you supposedly want to share with them? Of course a partner wouldn't feel fulfilled in a relationship where you aren't honest. A relationship built on dishonesty will never be healthy, and no GOOD partner wants a significant other who just sits there without any advice or opinion.
SavannahMay · 22-25, F
@LaylaTheTallGirl Let me ask this instead: If you just sit there, agreeing with everything- offering no advice, opinion, constructive criticism- if you are not helping them grow or do better or navigate their life, how are you contributing to the friendship? What are you offering to them? Why would they want to put in the effort to keep up that relationship, be it a friendship or significant other, if they feel that you are willing to offer no support in them growing as a person and making the right choices in their lives? How are YOU supporting THEM, as you should as someone who claims to care about them? How are you showing them that?
With that in mind, can you truly be mad that they don't want a relationship with you? When they feel that you don't care enough to slow down for them as you walk, or to be honest with them, or give advice? By not doing those things, you are showing them that you do not care about them, their choices, or their future, even if you don't mean to. And to continue doing this after they have told you it hurts them only shows them that even more.
LaylaTheTallGirl · 22-25, F
@SavannahMay Now you guys are making me feel bad. I didn’t mean to hurt my friends and now none of them wanna talk or hang with me right now.
SavannahMay · 22-25, F
@LaylaTheTallGirl

I'm going to respond to this message AND the one you left for me under Lucyy's comment for the sake of not writing two different replies.And its longer so I'm going to space it out how Lucyy did on her replies because I kind of dig it lol.

You weren't acting like a good friend. I'm sorry if that hurts, or makes you feel bad. But it genuinely sounds to me like you offered your friends NO support. Not even advice or an opinion or help making plans when they asked for it. And of course you didn't MEAN to. I don't think you;re a bad person who is intentionally hurting people. But the fact of it is, you did. And if it WAS an accident and you want to continue having a relationship with them, you need to say sorry, admit what you did wrong, and make sure they know you will work on it. And you need to ACTUALLY work on it, or this will all just happen again, and next time they may not be willing to forgive.

In response to you going through a hard time and them not seeming to care- That's because they feel you have not treated them as if YOU care. That is what they have been expressing to you this whole time. If you will not slow your steps so they can keep up, that will make them feel that you don't care. If you will not help contribute when they make plans, that makes them feel that you don't care. If you will not offer them advice or opinions when they need it, that makes them feel that you don't care. If you lash out and get defensive whenever they try to tell you this, they feel that you don't care. You SHOULD care about your friends being able to keep up, and about their lives that they need honest advice on, and about the plans they are trying to make to spend time with you, and doing these things is how you SHOW them you care. And if you just get mad and try to put the blame on everyone else when they bring this up to you, you are once again showing them that you do not care about their opinions, feelings, or the friendship. That you do not care enough to stop doing the thing that hurts them.

They feel that you have not been there for them. So they are not there for you. You get what you give in any healthy relationship, and you are not putting much in. Listen to what they are saying- because you have now had countless people breaking off relationships/friendships with you because of this, so obviously there is some truth to what they say. Work on improving yourself, because this is clearly a toxic trait you have that MANY people notice and are hurt by. Don't take it offensively, because EVERYONE has traits that they need to work on, and people offering constructive criticism are NOT the enemy.

And once you have worked on yourself and are able to offer the support that a friend NEEDS to be able to offer, then reach back out to them if you want. If you support them, they will support you. But they feel like you don't do that, and have already said they do not want to speak until you learn t do so. It would be, again, inconsiderate of their wishes to keep reaching out when you they have set that boundary and you have not worked on improving yourself.

But honestly, from what I can see in this conversation, they are right. You are looking more at what you want and need, at what your own wishes and wants, at your own issues with their own behavior, and are not focusing on what you are doing wrong and how that hurts those that you are around. And to not be able to acknowledge your own toxic traits is never healthy, and I can very easily see why it would be hard to have any kind of a relationship with someone like that. Like I said, I have cut off relationships for that exact reason.
LaylaTheTallGirl · 22-25, F
@SavannahMay OKAY OKAY I GET THE POINT! Stop saying they don’t care, they don’t care, they don’t care. That’s annoying! I get it. Sheesh! That one girl didn’t have to get so hostile at me for “making” shit worse when I didn’t say anything about the outing and planning. I wish she would have kept her mouth shit and stop calling me out on crap. She snaps at me for dozing off and not paying attention and having to repeat myself. I don’t understand why my best friends like her. Whatever I just need to work on myself but if they don’t wanna be friends with me, whatever! I’m not gonna waste time on idiots that cut me off just like that!
SavannahMay · 22-25, F
@LaylaTheTallGirl Except you're doing the exact same thing in that comment. Bringing it back around to what you don't like about them when they cut you off due to toxic behavior. THAT mindset will lead to the same thing to happen over and over, no matter what group of friends you have. If you get mad when friends call you out, you will never have real friends. The same for trying to turn it around on them when you behave in a toxic way.

I can't help you if you won't help yourself. I guess you just need to mature emotionally to really understand. I do hope you get to a place where you can maintain a healthy relationship one day though, and learn to accept constructive criticism without getting defensive and trying to blame others. I would suggest working on accepting constructive criticism gracefully, working on accepting accountability for your behaviors, and learning to focus on improving yourself before trying to come after everyone else's flaws.

Have a nice day. Hope things improve for you.
LaylaTheTallGirl · 22-25, F
@SavannahMay WHO ARE YOU CALLING TOXIC?! Forget it! You guys wouldn’t understand! Good bye and don’t ever talk to me again!!!!!!!!!! People are RUDE!!!! 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Abwiee · 22-25, F
@SavannahMay I would say it comes from experience vs age. So it seems to be a WIP right now. But yes lol.