Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Why is it that

Every time maga has an event, a huge number of people are injured or die?

40 people at the parade. While there was no violence, why was this number so high?!

At the "No Kings" protest, over 12 million attended and 1 person died. Only one.

It's like death and misery physically follows maga like a shroud.
Top | New | Old
Madmonk · M
You asked why it seems like every time MAGA has an event, people get injured or die. Let’s break that down with some facts.

At the MAGA parade in question the one modeled after a military-style celebration there were reports of around 40 people being injured. But here’s the important detail: those injuries weren’t due to violence or attacks. According to Time Magazine, most of the incidents were medical in nature things like heat exhaustion, crowd-related stress, and minor accidents. No one was assaulted. There were no riots. Just a dense crowd on a hot day with poor crowd control and not enough shade.

Now compare that to the “No Kings” protests. That movement reportedly brought out between four to six million people across thousands of cities, according to estimates cited in The Daily Beast and data analyst G. Elliott Morris. Despite the massive turnout, the protests were overwhelmingly peaceful. There was one fatality a shooting in Utah that police are still investigating but overall, there were very few incidents. The Washington Post confirmed that outside of that, there were only some scattered threats and vehicle-related injuries, and nothing organized or widespread.

So why the difference?

Part of it comes down to the structure of the events. The MAGA parade was one centralized event in Washington, DC, with a concentrated crowd in difficult weather conditions. That kind of setup is much more likely to result in heat injuries and other physical issues especially with older attendees. On the other hand, the “No Kings” movement was decentralized and spread out across the country. That made for smaller local crowds and reduced the risk of large-scale problems.

Another factor is planning and intent. The “No Kings” protests were highly organized, with local leadership, marshals, and often community or police coordination to keep things under control. The parade, while flashy, didn’t have the same kind of infrastructure to manage the crowd’s health and movement.

So no its not that MAGA events are cursed or followed by a shroud of death. It’s that different kinds of events bring different risks. The MAGA parade happened in tough physical conditions without much crowd support. The “No Kings” protests were well-organized and distributed across a wide area. That’s the real reason for the difference in outcomes.

Sources: Time Magazine, The Washington Post, The Daily Beast.
samueltyler2 · 80-89, M
@FoxyQueen in the No King event I attended, the average age seemed to me to be over 60! That was upsetting since it is the youth that will inherit what we leave to them and so they need to be involved.
MoveAlong · 70-79, M
@Madmonk Don't go messing up a good social media thread with facts. It spoils the fun.
FoxyQueen · 51-55, F
@samueltyler2 I think it depends on the local community. At ours, it was a good mix.
TheShanachie · 61-69, M
I have ignored the parade since I find it to have zero importance or purpose and had not heard that people died there. If we can talk to the coroner, maybe get some autopsy results? Get some demographics on participatants in the event? Some police reports? We might could come up with contributing factors that can prove reasons for the high mortality rates. Sorry I misread the question but if we use basically the same investigative techniques we can look for trends to determine common reasons for these injuries excluding the autopsies and coroners reports.
FoxyQueen · 51-55, F
@TheShanachie No one died, there were 40 injuries that required hospitalization, but they don't say the cause.

However, given that his supporters are anti-vax, I think it's safe to assume they are also anti doctor and haven't seen a health practioner on the regular since childhood. While it isn't causation/correlation, it could be that their over all health was a contributor, since nothing has been sited as to what happened.
TheShanachie · 61-69, M
@FoxyQueen true, I also see a lot of the lower educated people don’t drink enough water during hot and humid weather exposure and tend towards Mountain Dew and other Pepsi products. This could explain some of the high percentage of numbers compared to the NoKings protesters who tend to be higher educated and drink more water to avoid dehydration during these events.
FoxyQueen · 51-55, F
@TheShanachie I think that is fair. Even though it was 77° in DC, water is still a necessity.
ChipmunkErnie · 70-79, M
Any idea WHY they were hospitalized? I couldn't find anything exact online, but it sounded mostly like health issues, not violence.
samueltyler2 · 80-89, M
This was obviously a rhetoric question.
Teslin · M
I am not surprised based on his followers.
I’d say you are using selective and incomplete statistics.
FoxyQueen · 51-55, F
@BiasForAction how so?

 
Post Comment