Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

If you dress up as a native American on Halloween

Poll - Total Votes: 15
Of course
Yes
Absolutely
Show Results
You can only vote on one answer.
Is that "cultural appropriation " ?
If a man dresses up as a woman and calls it "drag queen" is that gender appropriation? If you dress up as a zombie, is that "undead appropriation"
Nanori · F Best Comment
Can't I just fking enjoy my time?
Bill1372 · 51-55, M
@Nanori unfortunately if you’re enjoying yourself- somewhere, somehow someone on the face of the earth will be offended you’re having a good time so they will want you to stop. Lol

BlueVeins · 22-25
I don't really believe there's such a thing as "cultural appropriation," but I think ppl don't like the idea of dressing up as a native person bc it gives off vibes of mocking or otherizing ppl, legitimate or not. Personally I think it should be OK to dress up as specific indigenous figures if it's done tastefully, but I understand the sensitivity to it.
WillaKissing · 56-60
I get your sense of humor. I do not put cultural or gender appropriation into how I dress up Halloween or not. I just love to cross dress in any thing I find appropriate to wear Luv.
WillaKissing · 56-60
@FreeSpirit1 Oh, I figured as much that some other "Wokie" coined it. I just do not like or think it fit as a heterosexual crossdresser. We are good my lady.
@WillaKissing Are you the official spokesman? 😁
You have to check the weekly woke memo
WillaKissing · 56-60
@FreeSpirit1 Oh, God no. I would never qualify for the woke agenda or sensitivity levels.
My wife feels that drag queens are, in fact, mocking women when they dress up in exaggerated costumes, and I'm sure she's not alone in this. I would say that this is cultural appropriation or the equivalent. I wouldn't say a man dressing as a woman as part of a gender transitioning process is the same thing, however. Drag queens are playing a role while people who are transitioning their gender are only attempting to live as the gender they feel most comfortable with. They're not the same thing and acting as if they are is evidence of ignorance.

Dressing as a Native American or any other historically oppressed minority isn't just cultural appropriation; it's offensive. Dressing as a zombie isn't because zombies don't exist in real life. The "zombi" is a dead person in Haitian voodoo tradition who is controlled by a magician and has no free will of their own; they're similar to the golem in Jewish tradition except golems are formed from clay and were never human. In modern American tradition, hypnosis and Manchurian candidates fulfill the same role.
adhane05 · 31-35, M
"Culture appreciation" would be a better term and I'm all for it.
chrisCA · M
It is just in poor taste.
Someone who would do that is just looking for a reaction.
Only when it's a guy dressing as an undead Pocahontas. 😁
Harmonium1923 · 51-55, M
I’d pose the question differently. I’d ask Native Americans, women, and zombies respectively, how they feel about other people dressing up as them for entertainment. To me those opinions matter more than those of people doing the dressing up.
MrBrownstone · 46-50, M
@Harmonium1923 Ask women about drag queens
Harmonium1923 · 51-55, M
@MrBrownstone That’s what I said.
calicuz · 56-60, M
If one is not African American, is it ok to dress up as an African Slave from 1600s?
JohnnySpot · 56-60, M
It boots us nothing to feel rage for things of long ago that transpired, we must curb our fury and allow sadness to diminish.
Hmmm...I think of it as play-acting.

Me--as a Caucasian guy--pretending that I'm Native American (like that Caucasian gal who claimed to be black)...when I'm not...THAT *would* be "cultural appropriation".

I guess the more lopsided the depiction, you have to be aware you might legitimately offend people.
Axelerator · 31-35, M
Of course, just think of the terrible opression the undead community has suffered lately. Can't even show up as a real rotting corpse to work, because of all us living bigots...
ninalanyon · 61-69, T
Is this cultural appropriation too?
[media=https://youtu.be/mOYZaiDZ7BM]
In case people don't recognize it, it's Rednex and they are Swedish.
GerOttman · 61-69, M
You just decided my costume this year. Ima be a native American drag queen zombie this year! It'll be epic!!!
JohnnySpot · 56-60, M
Unless you have permission from the chief, yes.
JohnnySpot · 56-60, M
And even then you'd still have to attach some kind of disclaimer.
ProfessorPlum77 · 70-79, MVIP
I don't know. It is hard to keep up, these days.
🤔
SW-User
I was going to dress up like a mexican

 
Post Comment