Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

If you dress up as a native American on Halloween

Poll - Total Votes: 15
Of course
Yes
Absolutely
Show Results
You can only vote on one answer.
Is that "cultural appropriation " ?
If a man dresses up as a woman and calls it "drag queen" is that gender appropriation? If you dress up as a zombie, is that "undead appropriation"
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
My wife feels that drag queens are, in fact, mocking women when they dress up in exaggerated costumes, and I'm sure she's not alone in this. I would say that this is cultural appropriation or the equivalent. I wouldn't say a man dressing as a woman as part of a gender transitioning process is the same thing, however. Drag queens are playing a role while people who are transitioning their gender are only attempting to live as the gender they feel most comfortable with. They're not the same thing and acting as if they are is evidence of ignorance.

Dressing as a Native American or any other historically oppressed minority isn't just cultural appropriation; it's offensive. Dressing as a zombie isn't because zombies don't exist in real life. The "zombi" is a dead person in Haitian voodoo tradition who is controlled by a magician and has no free will of their own; they're similar to the golem in Jewish tradition except golems are formed from clay and were never human. In modern American tradition, hypnosis and Manchurian candidates fulfill the same role.