Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

I had very mixed feelings about the tv show Blue Bloods…

I understand that the storylines were pretty much driven by Tom Selleck’s right-wing leanings, but I did enjoy some of the other characters in the series and I liked the family dinner scenes.

It was canceled after 14 seasons in December 2024, but I just read that there’s to be a spin-off that will star Donnie Wahlberg (who plays one of the sons) set in Boston (the original series was set in New York City).

I’m wondering if the new show will have a different tone sans Selleck.

If you watched the show "Blue Bloods", what did you think of it ? Did you like it ?
Top | New | Old
dancingtongue · 80-89, M
I liked the show in the early years. The premise was hokey--a multigenerational family in law enforcement, including two Commissioners, a detective, a rookie, and a powerful Assistant DA who have family Sunday dinner each week -- but an interesting theatrical device to give multiple views on dealing with a given story line that usually was aligned with events in the news. Granted, there was no truly liberal, progressive viewpoint at the table (what would you expect when the family business is law enforcement), but there was plenty of tension from four generations spanning the worst of old school policing to current policing to glimpses of potential police reform, and a prosecutor constantly challenging their methods and dealing with the political realities of her position.

It lost its way in the last few years, imho. As if they had fired the writers and had AI repackaging sequels of the same old stories. They got a brief fresh burst of creativity when Jamie got a female cop partner and wound up marrying her, and having to deal with the workplace issues around that. But I stopped watching about four years ago. Then again, it may be because I lost my partner, a former law enforcement chaplain, who was a big fan of the show. Watching it together and listening to her point out what rang true and what didn't was an added pleasure.

Donnie Wahlberg is a much better actor than his brother Mark, and Boston is his home turf. But politically, I would suspect a further swing right if anything in the sequel. Erin's political issues, given the ongoing turmoil of NYC politics in the Mayoral and DA offices, would be a far more interesting sequel, imho. Or Jamie and his wife, although the actor who plays Jamie is primarily a theatrical actor and only agreed to do this TV show because he was intrigued with the original concept.
sarabee1995 · 26-30, F
I've seen it a bunch of times but not recently. My grandfather liked it, but that was ten years ago. As for how I liked it ... Eh ... Not my fav crime drama. I like NCIS (and spin-off's) and Law and Order: Special Victims and Chicago PD ... all much better than Blue Bloods ... But you are right, the Sunday dinner scenes were cool.
whowasthatmaskedman · 70-79, M
I enjoyed the show..and watched it all the way through. The only real flat spot for me was Franks religious faith. Although casting Stacey Keach as the Bishop was masterful..😷
I only saw a few episodes when I was a teen I thought it was interesting I did not know it lasted for 14 seasons that's interesting.
robertsnj · 56-60, M
Tones:
D Wahlberg is politically aligned with Magnum PI . However it may depend on the who the writers and producers of the spin off are.

I didn't like it. I characters were overly one-dimensional (which is the writers fault not the actors) the black-and-white- moral sales pitch was silly and T Selleck's character as an alcoholic was oddly celebrated as a family value as opposed to being used as an opportunity to add complexity to the character
@robertsnj Yes, it may indeed depend on the writers and producers. The original producer of the series, Leonard Goldberg, passed away in 2019.
Rutterman · 46-50, M
I watched it for a few seasons, then abruptly stopped watching it. Can't remember exactly why. I think I just got bored with it.
@Rutterman I’ve had to take breaks from it over the years. Someone once referred to it as "Copaganda".
Rutterman · 46-50, M
@bijouxbroussard "Copaganda" is kind of how I thought of the show during the time I watched it. Seemed to present a simplistic, almost whitewashed view of the NYPD, as I remember it.
Loved it…..will watch the spin off.
Wonder if it will get as many spin offs as NCIS?
Could see Erin getting her own show.
It is CBS after all!
Ramrod · 46-50, M
I liked it ,i thought it was an interesting show. :)
I. LOVED. IT!
It will be interesting to see what the BS boy can do with it!
@Guardian Donnie Wahlburg was NKOTB, not BSB.
@bijouxbroussard Oooops! But anyway, you knew WHO I meant!!😂
DeWayfarer · 61-69, M
I never watched it.
uncalled4 · 56-60, M
I liked it. Only watched it at work, really.
Last I heard of Tom Selleck he was using precious town water on his avocado farm during a drought
@metaldog That, I didn’t know.
@bijouxbroussard yes not a glowing character reference!!
Stephie · 22-25, F
I never watched a single episode of all those crime shows yet I must have seen them all just by zapping through all those garbage TV channels that feature those cheap shows. One tenth of a second here, a half a second there and before you know it, you have seen the equivalent of an entire season...
@Stephie Thanks for sharing. 🙁
HowtoDestroyAngels · 46-50, M
Bridget dated Tom Brady for a while.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
@AngelUnforgiven I thought it was Mark (later "Marky Mark") who was involved in that.
AngelUnforgiven · 51-55, F
@bijouxbroussard you are right i was thinking of mark. Just hearing the word wahlberg makes me want to 🤮 It just burns me up that he got a slap on the wrist smh it goes to show that some people can get away with anything. Ive seen maybe 2 episodes of bluebloods it just seems so fake with the dinners and their holier than thou attitudes. It was just unrealistic to me.
@AngelUnforgiven I have to suspend a lot of personal belief, because my take-away is that the characters are privileged and clueless about the realities of anyone who isn’t them. I encounter people like that all the time, so I’ve no doubt that such family gatherings really take place. What I can sometimes enjoy is some of the characters as the actors play them and how they interact with each other. I like Will Estes’ character, for example, because he tries to be even-handed. While he’s not what I’d call "liberal", he’s often the lone voice of reason or compassion.

 
Post Comment