I like butter pecan out of that list cookies and cream. Though this loaded brownie chunks and cookie dough at store is good. Or mint chocolate chip. Though vanilla with captain crunch cereal mixed in sounds good.
My absolute favorite would be Turkey Hill All-Natural Vanilla Bean. (Breyers used to make a similar vanilla, but they discontinued it and generally went downhill in their other flavors.)
Of the choices you list above, I'd take the strawberry.
