Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Would Noah's flood actually be possible?

Discuss
Top | New | Old
Lostpoet · M
Yes, the world used to be a giant Snow ball what's a little rain in comparison.
zonavar68 · 56-60, M
@Lostpoet If the world was once a giant snow ball that suggests it's position in orbit around the sun has changed from where it is now and that the planetary 'wobble' that causes the seasons and is controlled by gravity of the moon has undergone some drastic variations. Maybe asteroid hits.
Lostpoet · M
@zonavar68 Nope I think it was just natural events that caused the last Snow ball Earth you can Google it.
ArishMell · 70-79, M
@Lostpoet Well, of course it was a natural event but the rather lyrical term "snowball" means only the planet's seas and atmosphere were far colder than now. There was a similar amount of water on it as now, so when the much of the land was covered in ice, the sea-level was correspondingly low.

On the other hand, when the Earth's overall climate was a lot warmer, there was far less terrestrial ice so the seas were higher - at maximum well over 100m higher than present level - covering a lot of land but by no means all of it.

There was never enough water on Earth to have covered all the land.

By its own history's standards the Earth is relatively cool at the moment, and we are still in Ice Age - a period of alternating cold and warm phases. Although whether we are in an interglacial (albeit one presently being accelerated artificially) or seeing the end of the Ice Age completely, only time will tell.
peterlee · M
Ice ages occur. They cover large sections of the Earth, so why can’t floods?
peterlee · M
@ArishMell The model used when Genesis was written when the Earth was thought Flat. . What is written there must be seen in that paradigm.

However that does not preclude the existence of a localised flood, which to the people of the day would be considered a flood of the whole known world.

The Gilgamesh tablets record events of 4000BC in Assyria and suggest a major flooding, similar to one recorded in Genesis much later.

In the modern day, the people of Bangladesh would see their entire world flooded from their perspective.

Genesis is not a History or Scientific Textbook, and should not be treated as one. However the stories contained have immense theological significance.
ArishMell · 70-79, M
@peterlee Thankyoufor explaining the history.

I Ihave always regarded the Old Testament stories as pure parables; but with quite definite purposes for their authors..
zonavar68 · 56-60, M
@ArishMell I would presume that the 'world' as defined by an ancient being is a lot different to what we know the 'world' to be today. That includes the ancient being commonly referred to as Iesus Yeshua.
whowasthatmaskedman · 70-79, M
No.. Just No. There isnt enough water.. But the Minoan volcano eruption made a nice local Tsunami in the Mediterranian..😷
zonavar68 · 56-60, M
If all polar ice at both north and south poles plus all land glaciers and all snow coverings melted concurrently, sea levels would definitely rise but nowhere near enough to cover the highest mountains so even they are hidden and unreachable for 40 days/nights.
Zaphod42 · 51-55, M
@zonavar68 One year. It rained for 40 days and nights, but they were adrift for a year before the dove brought back the olive branch.
ArishMell · 70-79, M
No.

There is simply not enough water on the planet, counting that lying on land as ice and snow, and that held in aquifers and living organisms, for any Waterworld-esque inundation.

The flood myth has no historical basis, but might have been based on some rare, and unusually severe, local flood maturing in folk memory for a long time before some scribe decided to use it as a parable.
swirlie · 31-35, F
YES it was possible! I was there, it happened and Noah being American himself, made it a bigger flood than any other country had ever seen. MAKE FLOODS GREAT AGAIN, was Noah's mantra.
val70 · 56-60
A flood covering the person's known world, sure.
Zaphod42 · 51-55, M
Raining enough water to cover all the land everywhere on earth? Where did it go after?

The geologic record shows that there was a period in history where it rained for roughly 1.5 million years straight, and it still didn’t cover all the land everywhere 🤷‍♂
swirlie · 31-35, F
@Zaphod42
That 1.5 million years of rain was a shitte post from Donald Trump's early ancestors.
I can't believe tens (hundreds??) of millions believe all that nonsense.
Burning? Ignoring the voices saying you need to build green infrastructure?
No it's completely different.

 
Post Comment