Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

You think it's appropriate to reward the quality/imagination of a child's costume with different candies?

Like if it's a cheap ballerina costume just a tiny sweet. But if it's Frodo Baggins complete with hairy feet-shoes they get a toblerone.

Some lazy kid who only put on a cape over his normal clothes gets a cough drop.
ViciDraco · 36-40, M
Not really. It feeds into the toxic hypercompetitive environment we find ourselves in. Just let the kids be kids and have fun
@ViciDraco While I agree with the last bit, any toxicity in a competition stems from the competitors. Assuming any judges present are unbiased. Would you rather they learn minimal effort gets rewarded? Or that they're entitled to reward simply for taking part?

I agree kids should be left to be kids. But not at the risk of failing an important lesson in life.
@PolyamorousPlaymates "But not at the risk of failing an important lesson in life" ((shakes head)) You really are a work of art lady. 😵
ViciDraco · 36-40, M
@PolyamorousPlaymates it's Halloween. Plenty of other time for life lessons. The candy isn't a reward for anything at all, it's part of the pageantry. Life isn't always about working for things.
Hell no, the last mentoned has his own special skills, in fact may end up having to support you in old age. What you are considering is borderline child abuse.
@Grateful4you How is this child abuse? I'm giving them candy. The degree of which depends on them.
@PolyamorousPlaymates It's a psychological reasoning, kids are much more aware/perceptive than we think.

Look, I know you aren't a mean/abusive parent but he going to feel a sense of failure or at least feel less that the others, (Not to mention his siblings will likely laugh he got such a lousy cough drop.

Just please reconsider.
@Grateful4you You want to talk psychological? We tell our kids every day to NEVER take candy from strangers. Then devote a whole day and night to doing just that.

I know how perceptive kids can be. But they're also kinda stupid and will learn bad behaviors unless tempered by the parent/guardian.

They'll see others putting in less effort for equal reward. So they learn to live like this. As adults, they put in minimal effort and expect to be rewarded. The world doesn't work like that and now they don't know what to do.

@ViciDraco There'll always be excuses NOT to do something. Every opportunity is a chance to learn and teach. Failing to do so is to raise an ignorant child. That's my opinion.

Finally, I never once stated I'm going to do what I asked about. It was just a question I was thinking about and everyone else made assumptions.
I think I might have to take in consideration what their circumstances are. They could come from a rather poor family and can’t afford a super nice/quality costume.
SW-User
I just keep the curtains closed and don't answer the door. They go away eventually.
Astro · 56-60, M
No that's not fair. Some kids can't afford the fancy outfits
BrandyCream · 22-25, F
I can understand the idea behind it, but is not something I would do.
NeuroticByNature · 41-45, F
I gave extra candy to the ones that went all out.
Selah ·
You're a sociopath.
@Selah I asked a question therefore I'm a sociopath. Your logic is sound.
justanothername · 51-55, M
That sounds pretty reasonable 👍
Butterflykisses24 · 51-55, F
caccoon · 36-40
Uh, no, because they can't control how much money was spent on their costumes?

 
Post Comment