jomsim · 31-35, M
It's a debate I've seen had. The winning argument seemed to be that the father was complicit and knew the risks (even with contraception). There's also an issue that no person can demand another person undertake a medical procedure.
However, we should have sympathy for people who are lied to and tricked into becoming fathers (it does happen) and then have to be financially responsible for decades through very little fault of their own.
Maybe there needs to be a sliding scale where people pay different amounts and if someone is lied to (and it can be proven), they shouldn't be as liable. Although you know this will just result in people pretending they've been lied to.
However, we should have sympathy for people who are lied to and tricked into becoming fathers (it does happen) and then have to be financially responsible for decades through very little fault of their own.
Maybe there needs to be a sliding scale where people pay different amounts and if someone is lied to (and it can be proven), they shouldn't be as liable. Although you know this will just result in people pretending they've been lied to.

SW-User
Not his body so no, he can’t decide on abortion if he can’t get pregnant. Should be rather obvious 👀
View 2 more replies »
Mamapolo2016 · F
@SW-User But if she chooses not to, she doesn’t. It seems unbalanced.
NativeOregonian · 56-60
@Mamapolo2016 Only if he can prove he was trapped into the woman's pregnancy.
Mamapolo2016 · F
@NativeOregonian The woman doesn’t have to prove anything.
NativeOregonian · 56-60
I would say the only time a man should ever be allowed to ask for their responsibilities removed is if they can prove they were trapped through seduction, happened to a cousin of mine in 1990.
SmartKat · 61-69, F
That’s a tough one. It doesn’t seem fair that a man can be forced to fork up support money, IF he was sure birth control was used, and IF he made it clear to the woman beforehand that he did NOT want a kid.
But how could either of those things ever be proved? It would be a lot of he-said she-said.
Not to mention, most people probably don’t think clearly enough to talk about this in the heat of the moment.
If it can’t be proven that the woman got pregnant on purpose, knowing it was against the man’s wishes - I’d rather err on the side of caution and have the man make support payments.
But how could either of those things ever be proved? It would be a lot of he-said she-said.
Not to mention, most people probably don’t think clearly enough to talk about this in the heat of the moment.
If it can’t be proven that the woman got pregnant on purpose, knowing it was against the man’s wishes - I’d rather err on the side of caution and have the man make support payments.

SW-User
Honestly, if you're a man that has sex with women, you've already accepted responsibility.
I think that if they want an abortion and the woman doesn't, they should leave. But that doesn't clear them of their responsibility. At the end of the day, it's their semen that impregnated the woman.
If a guy wants to avoid the responsibility of a child, they can just not have sex. Or get a vasectomy. But I don't think that they have the right to request an abortion when it's not even their body that's pregnant.
I think that if they want an abortion and the woman doesn't, they should leave. But that doesn't clear them of their responsibility. At the end of the day, it's their semen that impregnated the woman.
If a guy wants to avoid the responsibility of a child, they can just not have sex. Or get a vasectomy. But I don't think that they have the right to request an abortion when it's not even their body that's pregnant.
DunDunDun · 22-25, F
@Quizzical yeah cause it's her fucking body, you trying to argue that women should be tied up and held captive and forced to carry their unwanted babies full term, or that women should be forced to get abortions by assholes who won't get a vasectomy, don't want kids, and just go around getting women pregnant? it's not about the man, he's the one who's pregnant so it shouldn't be up to him

SW-User
@Quizzical He isn't carrying the kid. So he has no say in whether or not someone else chooses to.
Mamapolo2016 · F
Good points. @SW-User
Yes required. No they should not be allowed to demand an abortion, that is sick.
It takes two too tango... Unless the man was held down and raped or drugged and had his semen stolen then he has a responsibility to the child that he and his child's mother created.
I don't understand why a man should get away Scot free for something he's responsible for... He's unlucky I'm the sense that once a child has been conceived he has no rights on weather its born or not but he is lucky I'm the sense that he's not the one carrying the child or the one to give birth. Theres a reason why theres more dead beat fathers than dead beat mothers... Its easier for them to get away... Lucky them.
Shared custody is different but usually theres a primary home, usually its the mother but if it is in fact the father then she should be the one to pay child support but theres so many complications... Some good women loose their children because the father is a liar with money and vice versa... That's a cruel and unfair reality.
Shared and civil custody, which ever parent earns less, which is usually the mother, the other parent should help. It is not easy to be a single parent and its not up to their new partner to provide though I don't know why anyone would be with someone who didn't look at their parents child as a part of the parcel, they should but still irrelevant. Birth parents are equally responsible but many things need to be taken into account
It takes two too tango... Unless the man was held down and raped or drugged and had his semen stolen then he has a responsibility to the child that he and his child's mother created.
I don't understand why a man should get away Scot free for something he's responsible for... He's unlucky I'm the sense that once a child has been conceived he has no rights on weather its born or not but he is lucky I'm the sense that he's not the one carrying the child or the one to give birth. Theres a reason why theres more dead beat fathers than dead beat mothers... Its easier for them to get away... Lucky them.
Shared custody is different but usually theres a primary home, usually its the mother but if it is in fact the father then she should be the one to pay child support but theres so many complications... Some good women loose their children because the father is a liar with money and vice versa... That's a cruel and unfair reality.
Shared and civil custody, which ever parent earns less, which is usually the mother, the other parent should help. It is not easy to be a single parent and its not up to their new partner to provide though I don't know why anyone would be with someone who didn't look at their parents child as a part of the parcel, they should but still irrelevant. Birth parents are equally responsible but many things need to be taken into account
Mamapolo2016 · F
@MushroomFaerie As I said, I don’t know what I think is a solution - but it’s an interesting question.
I have known many many single parents - mostly women, but some men.
And it is a complicated issue.
I have known many many single parents - mostly women, but some men.
And it is a complicated issue.
@Mamapolo2016 it sure is. Society is the problem in that and many other aspects. Hunter gather communities did not have these issues and they did not have sexism.
DeezNutz · M
No. Not his body.
Quizzical · 46-50, M
@DeezNutz A lot of men try for full custody. Most are dissuaded as they are told that they have very little hope of getting it. Of the ones that go through with it, a very small percentage win.
The figures are really rather interesting.
Courts have a HUGE bias towards mothers in custody cases, even when her character is dubious.
The figures are really rather interesting.
Courts have a HUGE bias towards mothers in custody cases, even when her character is dubious.
DunDunDun · 22-25, F
@Quizzical "Yet a man has no rights, only responsibilities.
That's hardly fair."
Unlike women in most places, men can just go get sterilized. Which means they have more reproductive rights than women and can easily prevent themselves from getting anyone pregnant. But sure, men only have responsibilities and no rights.
That's hardly fair."
Unlike women in most places, men can just go get sterilized. Which means they have more reproductive rights than women and can easily prevent themselves from getting anyone pregnant. But sure, men only have responsibilities and no rights.
robb65 · 56-60, M
No. If all a guy had to do to get out of child support is demand the woman get an abortion how many guys would demand that just to get out of it? You know, no way she would get an abortion so I'll just "insist" anyway.
Mamapolo2016 · F
That is a problem, no question.@robb65
CharlieZ · 70-79, M
No man can ask unilaterally for an abortion here.
Neither to avoid his legal duties as father (even if some intent to).
Moreover, the ones who avoid (not only finantial support) but to take his place in his kids life have, here, a bad social reputation of not being men enough.
Neither to avoid his legal duties as father (even if some intent to).
Moreover, the ones who avoid (not only finantial support) but to take his place in his kids life have, here, a bad social reputation of not being men enough.
CharlieZ · 70-79, M
@Mamapolo2016 May be my STRONG fatherly reflexes make me (may be with a not fair bias) difficult to relate to that situation that I´ll refrain to comment, out of my scope.
As someones know, I used to be the "single father" of three with a non "available" mom.
This shaped my emotions and I can not grant to be too "objective".
Thinking it the other way round...
What when is the father who desires to keep the baby and rise it only by his own?
I know, to solve this collides with the woman´s choices over her body, considering the high "investment" of pregnancy.
But, in other levels (may be not practical ones), I wonder.
As someones know, I used to be the "single father" of three with a non "available" mom.
This shaped my emotions and I can not grant to be too "objective".
Thinking it the other way round...
What when is the father who desires to keep the baby and rise it only by his own?
I know, to solve this collides with the woman´s choices over her body, considering the high "investment" of pregnancy.
But, in other levels (may be not practical ones), I wonder.
Mamapolo2016 · F
@CharlieZ I knew a couple - he wanted the baby and she didn't. She carried it to term (as you say, a significant investment), and did not even want to see it. He raised his son and she had no involvement.
CharlieZ · 70-79, M
@Mamapolo2016 I know, here and personally, three similar cases.
And some others somehow related even if not the same at all.
Cases of women that discovered they were not happy being also moms, and left when one or more kids where almost babies. No further involvment.
One of them, a close friend of mine (passed away by 2012) that was left with his then four years daughter.
Even my case, totally different, resulted in the same with my own daughters.
But, of course, pregnancy is another issue.
And some others somehow related even if not the same at all.
Cases of women that discovered they were not happy being also moms, and left when one or more kids where almost babies. No further involvment.
One of them, a close friend of mine (passed away by 2012) that was left with his then four years daughter.
Even my case, totally different, resulted in the same with my own daughters.
But, of course, pregnancy is another issue.
Quizzical · 46-50, M
A very interesting question.
This comment is hidden.
Show Comment
This comment is hidden.
Show Comment
DunDunDun · 22-25, F
@RippinKlouds i'm not saying they should have to
DunDunDun · 22-25, F
@RippinKlouds also most unwanted pregnancies aren't created by 13 year old boys...
abe182 · 51-55, M
I think I'll get a vasectomy
This comment is hidden.
Show Comment
Mamapolo2016 · F
That’s a pretty sweeping statement.@RippinKlouds
DeezNutz · M
@RippinKlouds I agree with that sweeping statement.
Mamapolo2016 · F
😊 You May.@DeezNutz
DunDunDun · 22-25, F
No, weird that this is even a debate.
Unfortunately no, the guy doesn’t have a say so since it’s not in his body. But you both are at fault. If you didn’t want a baby you should have been more careful. And I mean that sincerely. With every action there comes a consequence. Even if it was accidental. You live and you learn.
I had a kid at a young age. Did I want one? No. But I took care of the child because I brought them into this world. You don’t get to knock up a woman and decide for her to have an abortion. You might as well have your balls snipped.
I had a kid at a young age. Did I want one? No. But I took care of the child because I brought them into this world. You don’t get to knock up a woman and decide for her to have an abortion. You might as well have your balls snipped.
This comment is hidden.
Show Comment
Jackaloftheazuresand · 31-35, M
He should have the right to an abortion. If he gives up his rights to have a say like people here seem to think then why can't the woman give up the rights to her body by choosing to have sex with him? This is another reason average abortions just shouldn't exist in legal form, it creates complexities we shouldn't have to deal with. You have sex, you accept the child and both lose your rights by choosing sex. Same as felons choose to lose voting by committing their crimes.
Mamapolo2016 · F
That’s where I got stuck. Not in rape or incest - but consensual sex. They both knew the possibilities and one gets a choice and one doesn’t.
It is true it’s the woman’s body, but she does have a choice.
It’s also true many men would opt for abortion rather than child support.
I don’t know. I just thought it was worth discussing. @Jackaloftheazuresand
It is true it’s the woman’s body, but she does have a choice.
It’s also true many men would opt for abortion rather than child support.
I don’t know. I just thought it was worth discussing. @Jackaloftheazuresand
Jackaloftheazuresand · 31-35, M
@Mamapolo2016 I asked a similar question once but mine focused on the stealing of the male's sperm and people there said he still shouldn't have the right to request an abortion. I find that odd because he either becomes a deadbeat father that never knows his child and might leave his own kid with feelings of inadequacy from knowing their father isn't around or he has to support a child he didn't want. He doesn't win at all in that situation and it's wrong.
abe182 · 51-55, M
Yeah we're screwed if it's an accidental pregnancy. 99% is NOT 100%
This comment is hidden.
Show Comment
This message was deleted by its author.
Mamapolo2016 · F
Steady on, folks. This is a discussion, not a duel to the death. There's room for differing opinions.
@PainfulTruth@DeezNutz
@PainfulTruth@DeezNutz
This message was deleted by its author.











