Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Are Sicilians Arabs?

No. Sicilians like the majority of Europeans originated from the Middle Eastern Farmers about 8000 years ago long before Arabs existed. The Moors did conquer Sicily so Sicilians likely carry a small amount of Berber, Arab DNA from recent times.
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
The word Berber does not refer to Arab DNA.
samueltyler2 · 80-89, M
@SinlessOnslaught That is such a minor error. I am not defending anyone, I really do not understand catfish, but i wouldn't condemn "her" for such a minor thing.
@samueltyler2 It was the least of the corrections I could have made. I'm being polite.
basilfawlty89 · 36-40, M
@samueltyler2 actually it's a massive error. Amazigh speak the Tamazight (Berber) languages. It's its own branch and own alphabet of the Afro-Asiatic languages;
Arabic, like Hebrew and Aramaic, is of the Semitic branch of the Afro-Asiatic languages.
@basilfawlty89 💁‍♂
samueltyler2 · 80-89, M
@basilfawlty89 do you know for a fact that there would be no Berber DNA if you did analyses?

I just asked AI to help settle this:

Yes, Sicilians do have some North African ancestry, and this includes Berber DNA.
Here's why:
Historical Interactions: Sicily's location in the Mediterranean has made it a crossroads for various peoples throughout history, including ancient migrations from North Africa, Phoenician settlements, Roman rule (which included people from North Africa), and the Arab/Berber rule known as the Emirate of Sicily (827 to 1061 AD).
Genetic Studies: Studies on Sicilian genetics have identified Y-chromosome lineages, such as E3b1b-M81, that reflect gene flow from North Africa. This lineage is commonly found among Berber populations.
Estimates of Contribution: While estimates vary, one study suggests that the genetic contribution of North African populations to the Sicilian gene pool is around 6%, compared to an estimated 37% from Greek populations.
It's important to note:
Diverse Ancestry: Sicilian heritage is a complex blend of various groups, including indigenous populations, Greeks, Romans, Normans, Arabs, and others.
North African vs. Sub-Saharan African: It's important to distinguish between North African and Sub-Saharan African ancestry. While some North Africans have Sub-Saharan African admixture, North Africans are diverse, and many can appear more European-looking, according to Quora.
Berbers vs. Arabs: While many Berbers converted to Islam and adopted Arabic as their language, they are ethnically distinct from Arabs. Both Berbers and Arabs were present in Sicily during the period of Muslim rule.
Therefore, Sicilians are likely to have some Berber DNA as part of their diverse genetic heritage, primarily due to historical interactions and migrations across the Mediterranean.
basilfawlty89 · 36-40, M
@samueltyler2 tf are you talking about? Most people are mixed. No one is debating that. Genetics don't define culture. Folkore, traditions, language, etc. define them.
Otherwise by that logic most Ashkenazim are Italians as while most have some Levantine ancesty, most of their autosomal DNA is Southern European.
@samueltyler2 The word Berber is a blanket term invented by ancient people with the intent to group together many populations into one and water down their history. I've never heard anyone of North African descent use the term.

If you prompt AI with misinformation, especially ChatGPT or Google, it will respond with more misinformation.
samueltyler2 · 80-89, M
@SinlessOnslaught I guess you have your mind made up. What would you accept as definitive information?
basilfawlty89 · 36-40, M
@samueltyler2 he's completely correct:
Berber is what the Romans called indigenous North Africans. It's used as "uncivilized", its origin is Greek barbaros meaning unintelligeble speech.
samueltyler2 · 80-89, M
@basilfawlty89 So what? True, true, but unrelated. Are you saying that the results of my Google and AI searches is wrong?
@samueltyler2 https://books.google.com/books?id=OxnOEAAAQBAJ&pg=PT277#v=onepage&q&f=false

[media=https://youtu.be/lCBHnAXAvUk]

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berbers
@samueltyler2
Are you saying that the results of my Google and AI searches is wrong?

Yes
samueltyler2 · 80-89, M
@SinlessOnslaught This discussion has gone on way too long. I may be naive, and don't really care since i enjoy this person's posts, even if "she" is not who she says she is. They make for pleasant reading.
@samueltyler2 You asked and I provided. That's all.

Enjoy your entertainment.
samueltyler2 · 80-89, M
@SinlessOnslaught What did i ask for? I said if you have proof that she is a fraud please put it out for us. You then went on a tangent about Berbers.
@samueltyler2
I guess you have your mind made up. What would you accept as definitive information?
Please tell me what you were asking for with this.
This message was deleted by its author.
@samueltyler2 Look, my intent was not to upset anyone. I saw misinformation (entertaining as it may be) and I wanted to correct it because I know and care about people whose lives are effected by the throws of this topic in general. I didn't say anything about catfish in this thread and what I did say was backed up by sources which took time and effort to collect.

If it's gone on too long for you, I understand.
samueltyler2 · 80-89, M
@SinlessOnslaught have you reached out to the OP?
@samueltyler2 About what?
samueltyler2 · 80-89, M
@SinlessOnslaught your claim that "she" is a catfish? I htink you can also report her to administration.
@samueltyler2 Thanks for the help.

Conducting research and making claims based on "Berber DNA" is unreliable at best.