Will Amanda Knox return to Italy for a re-trial or not?

So by staying in the States she is hiding from justice....why is that fair?

The Italian Supreme court has said there should be a re-trial . They could have recommended that the appeal was correct and there was no need for further action.

I have no idea how they run their stuff, I can only respond in light of what info I see on the news. And, I agree, with your comment, I just don't know. I have already gone out as far as I can to give an intelligent answer, anything after this point will be bullshit, I haven't read anymore.

Ok...thanks for posting anyway.

Morals don't come into it....hiding from the law is never a good thing unless you are guilty

You really have not studied the case at all. The court is not finding her guilty. They identified procedural issues. Thank God you are not allowed to be close to anything important.

Are you able to read? The original trial jury found her guilty. Her subsequent appeal on preocedural grounds was a success. The Supreme court has now quashed that appeal and ordered a re-trial. I am fully aware of the legal issues...whereas you appear not to be.

Still not guilty as the prosecutors want to retry her and still innocent until her retrial

To prove I was innocent

So if she refuses to go back and is found guilty at the re-trial in her absence....then what?

But she WAS acquitted. They shouldn't be able to appeal an acquittal in the first place. It's not like a mistrial, where no decision was reached. She'd be a fool to voluntarily return, but it depends on the extradition laws; if they can refuse to extradite someone back here who might face the death penalty, we should be able to refuse to extradite where there's no double jeopardy statute. One could be acquitted and retried again and again indefinitely based upon that.

The original trial verdict was a conviction. On appeal she was acquitted on the grounds of poor evidence. That decision has now been over-ruled, and a re-trial has been ordered.

Then they shouldn't have acquitted her, they should've thrown out the verdict and retried her then. An acquittal is having been found not guilty. Obviously Italian law is different than U.S. law, but like I said, she would be a fool to voluntarily go back and let them possibly railroad her, especially if she knows herself to be innocent.

Well she was convicted of a crime in Italy

Do you think she is guilty?