Sounds like an internal struggle. You can respect his wishes but if he's going to complain about what he asked for, oh well buddy. I understand not wanting attention but then feeling sad nobody remembered. It's not something others can help though.
I don't ask for anything on my birthday because I don't need anything. Cards are a waste of money. I do appreciate a happy birthday though. I also like a nice meal.
some people just hate birthdays, they hate getting older or just reminds them they aren't where they wanted to be in life.
Could be something happened in his youth to make him not want anything on his birthday. Narcissists in the family, especially a parent, can ruin any holiday or birthday. It brings back memories each year.
who knows........ some folks like being a martyr. maybe have a talk with him about why he feels that way. respect his wishes, but, if he ever pulled some horseshit saying no one remembers my birthday, just remind him of his own words. cant have it both ways.
@GunFinger Maybe get a gift and a card, and keep them in reserve. If he really wants no attention, fine. If, on the other hand, he complains about no one caring, pull them out and say "surprise!"
@GunFinger Well, beautiful, I could say a million Things but I will just leave it at this.He sounds like a genuinely decent-hearted person I don't think it wasn't you would be with him but I'm just not sure well you get the drift