Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

A Serious Question About The Japanese Interment Camps.

One of the most despicable acts by the US government was the segregation and interment of over 120,000 people of Japanese descent. These individuals, the majority of whom were American citizens, were forcibly removed from their homes in the western United States following Executive Order 9066 and detained in remote camps such as Manzanar, Tule Lake, and Minidoka.

The United States was attacked by Japan on December 7, 1941. Only days later, Hitler declared war on the US, and now Uncle Sam was in WW2, not only in the Pacific but now in Europe, like it or not.

The Axis Powers were Germany, Italy, and Japan.

My question is this:
Why were Germans and Italians in the US, not placed in camps like the Japanese?

I look forward to your input.
Top | New | Old
SunshineGirl · 36-40, F
Good question.

I guess Asians were most visible in Amerucan society, while Germans and Italians were felt to be more effectively integrated.

In the UK internment was mainly for people of German heritage and perhaps had a more practical justification as our country bordered German occupied France.

There was, and still is, prejudice towards people with German sounding names. Our own royal family re-named themselves as "Windsor" (they were originally Saxe-Coburg-Gotha) in 1917 to distance themselves from their north German roots.
The Germans and Italians did not bomb us > Japan did.

The US was not interested in joining the war until The Bombing of Pearl Harbor (where 2400 people died) Japan appeared to be an immediate threat to us - where the government felt the need to protect its citizens from further attacks.

Right or wrong, when looking back upon history, you need to take into consideration what intellectual knowledge they had available to them and ask yourself .... Was this done with malice or a need to protect others? I personally feel like it was a mixture of both and we have to learn from the mistakes of our forefathers with humility.
basilfawlty89 · 36-40, M
Economics, feasibility, and good old fashioned racism.

Economically German and Italian Americans were major contributors to the US economy back then. They were also full citizens (getting back to that soon).

Feasibility wise, it would be a gargantuan task. There were more Germans and Italians in the US. In fact the largest ethnic group at a stage were German Americans.

Finally, racism.
Japanese were subject to social and legal prejudice (hencs why they weren't full citizens). At that time, racial pseudoscience predominanted in the Europe and the US.
MarkPaul · 26-30, M
Well, they were stereotypically distrusted in the media and often threatened and discriminated in society at large for the duration of the war. Some might say after the war as well.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
RedBaron · M
@PicturesOfABetterTomorrow There was no specifically Jewish mafia or mob operation.

Jewish gangsters like Lansky and Bugsy Siegel trafficked and did business with their Irish and (mostly) Italian and Sicilian counterparts.
@RedBaron That is a bit of an odd statement. This is well known historical fact. Even former mobsters disagree with you on that claim.


And the rest is a non sequitur.
RedBaron · M
Probably a typo, but they were INTERNMENT camps.

An INTERMENT camp is basically a cemetery.
BohoBabe · M
Why were Germans and Italians in the US, not placed in camps like the Japanese?

They were. But the media wants us to think that white people can never be victims of racism, even on an ethnic level, so they don't talk about this.
basilfawlty89 · 36-40, M
@BohoBabe much less, the Germans were literally only those with foreign ties to Germany and the Amerikadeutscher Volksbund.
BohoBabe · M
@basilfawlty89 It was mostly Americans from Germany, but also native-born Americans with German ancestry. Same for Italian-Americans.
Convivial · 26-30, F
I think at the time there was still a great mistrust of Asians in general...
@Convivial still? It was concocted for the US needs.
Convivial · 26-30, F
@Roundandroundwego the states had a complete n. moratorium on immigrants from Asia at the time... Do yes
@Convivial Chinese exclusion laws.
Over 2.5 million conscientious objectors were put in containment camps, too.
Because they were very valuable parts of the war economy and the political system. The race thing was made up to justify the results. Fascists. Never understand. You ain't capable.
Patriot96 · 56-60, C
Govt ignorance. Asians were easily recognized
@Patriot96 You would know since you are determined to make history repeat and deport all non whites.

 
Post Comment