Who determines national security risk, a federal judge or the Department of Homeland Security?

@Penny
Of course, it does. It provides the President (Executive Branch) with the power to revoke visas and remove aliens deemed a security risk. DHS surveil all aliens and determine who is a either a security risk or has violated the terms visitors must abide by. Judge Patricia Giles has no authority to question the decision of Kristi Noem, the Secretary of DHS, to expel any visitor from the USA.

@sree251

@sunsporter1649 Judicial activism is weaponization of the judiciary by people in black robes. They are like members of the Ku Klux Klan.

@Convivial

@sree251 Playing word games doesn't change the facts. Cops regardless of their fancy badge don't hand down sentences on the spot with zero judicial process.


It doesn't matter if you are talking about local cops. The law is the law and basic legal process that literally predates the USA as a country.


And again, courts determine the legal status of immigrants not a random cop. And no it doesn't matter what alphabet agency is on their badge.



And yes this is exactly about cops overstepping their authority. And I don't live in the USA. You clearly are the one who don't seem to understand how the world works outside of a right wing GOP fear based fantasy.

And we also know from the actions of the Clinton administration that even if you are detaining criminals deportation makes the problem worse, not better.

But the GOP operates on machismo, not facts or evidence.

@sree251 And if you seriously believe that policing is outside the jurisdiction of the legal system than congratulations. You have a fascist police state. The very thing alot of these people fled.

@PicturesOfABetterTomorrow
Visitors to the US including those with green cards are subject to USCIS oversight. Permission for them to stay in the US can be withdrawn by the federal government as it deems necessary. This is not a matter to be deliberated upon by the court. The Secretary of Homeland Security is the authority on this matter. It is not a civil or criminal matter for litigation in a court of law.

@sunsporter1649 Judicial activism is another phrase for judges gone wild. This is the problem spawned by DEI policy. Unfit judges, mayors, police chiefs, and even four star generals are wrecking the USA.