Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Why is America voting on a tuesday ?

almost every other country votes on a sunday, which kinda makes sense. you want people to be able to participate in a vote and thats difficult if you have a job, especially when i see the long lines for voting in America. why is that ? cant you just open another voting "office", this all seems terrible organized and planned.
CountScrofula · 41-45, M
So first - the US is one of the only countries that doesn't centrally plan its election. It's not one election, it's 50+ little ones.

Tuesday is a pre-car idea. Church on Sunday, travel to vote on Monday, vote on Tuesday. Vote in November after harvest is done.

And the long lines for in-person voting are on purpose. Elections tend to veer to the right when it's harder to vote.
CountScrofula · 41-45, M
@ChipmunkErnie Yep, absolutely but I think a lot of it is the early in-person and mail-in voting has been a historical compromise around the limited polling stations.

Other countries just tend to have sufficient polling stations.
CestManan · 46-50, F
@CountScrofula
Elections tend to veer to the right when it's harder to vote.

Why is that though? I do assume you mean "right wing"? One might argue that tRump is pulling every trick in the book but obviously this has been going on long before he was on the scene.
@MethDozer Although, electors tend to be party loyalists, so it's not like the electors will meet and pick someone they aren't pledged to. There have been "faithless electors" but not many, and some states have legal penalties for electors who violate their pledge. It's theoretically possible for Elon Musk to attempt to bribe each elector with 100 million dollars to vote for his preferred candidate, but keeping something like that secret, especially when it became obvious that the electors were ignoring their pledge, would be very difficult.
Most states have early voting, and it's estimated that at least half of all voters will have already voted by election day. In 2020, the Republicans discouraged early voting, but have encouraged it this year, with many rural voters taking advantage of it by voting on the day most convenient for them. Early voting is much better than other proposals, like making election day a national holiday.

The long lines are deliberate. You see these in Republican-controlled states in urban areas that tend to vote Democratic. Here in Georgia, it's even illegal to offer water to people standing in lines. Where I grew up, in California, polling places were in peoples' living rooms, and I rarely had to wait more than a few minutes to vote. In Oregon, 100% of voting was by mail, so it was even more convenient.

There can be long lines for early voting as even fewer polling places are open. This year, we arrived at ours about 15 minutes before it opened and didn't have to wait too long.
@MethDozer Neither does a corrupt electoral college
@FreeLilly Not necessarily, although all of them should comply with the Voting Rights Act.

Article II, Section 1 of the Constitution says "Each State shall appoint, in such Manner as the Legislature thereof may direct, A Number of Electors..." So if you want elections held under national standards under the direction of the federal government, you'd need a constitutional amendment. One strength of our system is that it's decentralized, so "stealing" an election would require the coordinated actions of thousands of people, which would be nearly impossible. As the other commenter said, it's not one national election; it's 50 separate state elections.

That being said, I think we should abolish the Electoral College and elect the President by national popular vote.
I already voted. @LeopoldBloom
Pretzel · 61-69, M
From Britannica

"Still, some days of the week were better than others. Two days were definitely out of the question. Most Americans were devout Christians and thus set aside Sunday as a day of rest and worship. Wednesday in many areas was a market day, when farmers sold their crops in town. In addition, a travel day was sometimes required. In rural areas, the nearest polling place might have been several miles away, and, in an era before automobiles, getting there could take a while. If people couldn’t use Sunday or Wednesday as their travel day, then that meant election day couldn’t be on Monday or Thursday, either. And so Tuesday was perceived as the best option."
ChipmunkErnie · 70-79, M
Not sure, but I assume voting on a Sunday was a no-no for many early Americans because Sunday was reserved for doing things in the service of their Christian god. The GOP is fighting voting access being widened, but in many states these days you can vote by mail, vote by drop off box, and vote in person at early voting stations. In my state early in-person voting started this past week and mail in ballots go out 45 days before the official "Election Day". As to long lines, that's because there are a heck of a lot of Americans registered to vote.
@ChipmunkErnie I've also heard the additional reason that many less religious Americans used to get drunk as a skunk on sundays and were too hung over to vote mondays. Could be just a good story though.
ChipmunkErnie · 70-79, M
@ElwoodBlues I dunno -- so many places in "the old days" had blue laws that banned alcohol sales on Sundays. I seem to remember some cities even banned alcohol sales on election days because politicians used to buy drinks for people if they'd go and vote for them.
StevetheSleeve · 31-35, M
Eight states vote exclusively by mail and it really doesn’t matter what day is the official Election Day. Not having it on a Sunday probably has something to do religion, but long lines on a Tuesday do seem ridiculous
OldBrit · 61-69, M
UK always vote on a Thursday
SunshineGirl · 36-40, F
@OldBrit Gives the outgoing PM a long weekend to clear out of No. 10.
Kiesel · 56-60, M
Been that way since 1845
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Election_Day_(United_States)
1490wayb · 56-60, M
we used to be a GOD fearing nation
Elessar · 26-30, M
@Toofargone It's utterly ignorance to look at American history while forgetting altogether (or even being totally clueless) about enlightenment, dude.
@Toofargone The first amendment clearly states that there is no official government religion, while also guaranteeing freedom of worship. Obviously, people will be influenced by their religion, and politicians are no different, but the US is the same as other countries in this regard. While many countries have official religions, the word "God" appears nowhere in the Constitution. One reason for the strength of the US is our acceptance of diversity in worship. It's also why, unlike most other Western countries, religion is still popular here.

Nobody worships the mafia.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
Our elections are normally on a Thursday for some reason.

I think Tuesday is chosen because it injects some excitement into what is otherwise the most boring and depressing day of the week.
ChipmunkErnie · 70-79, M
A note re long lines: for one thing the US population is around 345,000,000 compared to Switzerland's 9,000,000, so our elections are a much larger endeavour than in your country.
cherokeepatti · 61-69, F
That’s the way it’s done here. People can vote early for a few days but not on Sunday. People do need a day off, even poll workers.
hippyjoe1955 · 61-69, M
I live in Canada and I don't know of any elections being held on Sunday.
The polls stay open late and work has to let you off if you need to.
Subsumedpat · 36-40, M
With early voting allowed that is no longer an issue.
Northwest · M
almost every other country votes on a sunday

That would be in the Western "Christian" world.
Jimmy2016 · 61-69, M
I voted two weeks ago..........
@Jimmy2016 Chump, waste of time
Jake966 · 56-60, M
That’s why there is early voting
Sam17 · 18-21, M
Think it's Friday here
MethDozer · M
By law work has to allow you to leave to vote

 
Post Comment