Was Hitler a socialist?

@helenS Ah, thank you!

@helenS

You think Fashism didn't have theories? And even if we agree on the fact that they had theories... why would all of them be based on "violence" and "hate"? Not a lot of political movements have theories that are based on violent and hate and do good in elections... ussually they have a lot more going on too. 😅

And Socialists were pretty happy with Marx, if I recall correctly they saw Marx as the guy that gave "Socialism" a "scientific" background. Which it didn't really have before Marx. Depending on what "Socialist" you read, most of them came to the conclussion that at a certain moment of time a "revolution" had to break out that overtrew the old system and went to a new. These "revolutions" aren't really peacefull. Marx actively stood with armed revolt and a lot of leftist thinkers wrote books pondering on how to use violence. It's inherit to a lot of socialist thinkers. That it lead to violence isn't just a coincedence it's part of the program.

@SW-User Exactly.

@SW-User Perfectly stated.

@Picklebobble2 Absolutely. Good post and I agree with every word.

@bijouxbroussard It truly boggles my mind. Have we, as a society, forgotten the lessons that history has taught us?? I learned this in high school.

@MistyCee I love the honesty of this guy.

@Burnley123

@plinkplonk I think he grew up in Canada but his fans are mostly American. If Ted Cruz had a dumb, frat boy nephew then it would be crowder.

@Burnley123 He's just another blow hard spitting into the wind 🙄

@plinkplonk Yeah but it saddens me that crowder and his ilk have so many followers

@wildbill83 pfff. I'm not responding again until you have something of substance to say. Watch the vid.

nah, I think I'll just mute/block you instead... from the looks of things, you're about as wacko as all the other weirdos on SW...🤔

@wildbill83 Snowflake

Like almost all socialists, the nazis were evil, obviously. to them universal didnt mean worldwide; it was just for aryans. Its inherent in their name, the NATIONAL socialists. Are you having trouble with this?@Really

@redredred Personally, I prefer to know someone's argument before I comment. The video deals with every single point you raise.

Its a well documented calumny by Herbert Marcuse who tried to distance the third reich from its obvious socialist nature so as to rehabilitate socialism in the post war years. Hitler and Mussolini died thinking of themselves as socialists. Any case made to the contrary is simply excuse making about as credible as the flat-earthers.@Burnley123

@Burnley123 So in other words, you're saying that a socialist party, with socialist leaders, and socialist ideologies... isn't really socialist.

and you're Republican? and? so? therefore?

Are you implying that because you believe the meanings of words aren't definitive, that you're not really a Republican?

Better yet, what is the purpose of this post?

@wildbill83 Im British and against my monarchy. I'm saying people mislabel themselves for obvious reasons.

Again, please watch the video and engage with the substance of the argument, not the positions you are (badly) attempting to put on me.

@Burnley123 I skimmed though it enough to realize that watching the whole thing would be about as useful as watching a Michael Moore "documentary"....🙄

@DonaldTrumpet Godwin's law, ten points lost by Griffindor

@Burnley123 WhOTz u squeakinGz BouTz?

@Really Or telling the truth. Socialism is opposed to the truth. For a socialist it is the equivalent of sunshine to a vampire.

@hippyjoe1955 My ideal solution something which hasn't happened yet. My best existing role models are Nordic.

Hitler was a socialist as much as you are a hippy.

@hippyjoe1955 Oh I didn't know that. Wikipedia? Anyway thanks for the pearls of wisdom.

Oh shit, I've let myself get trapped into responding in kind.

Bailing.

@MistyCee Three arrows is very dry but his analysis is really good. He's exactly what you would expect from a smart but boring German.

@Burnley123 I just couldn't get past the moron at the beginning.

@MistyCee lmfao. He is an idiot but peopke like him.

@Ryanoliver2011 Ridiculous. Watch the vid

@Ryanoliver2011 Lmao that's some advanced stupid you have going on over there 👍

@Cmstars He wasn't that either

@Burnley123 Clearly.

@Cmstars I love the way on this site people comment without watching the video with non arguments.

@Burnley123 I'm watching it right now but I'm sure you meant those with the opposite opinion. People never watch the video even on my posts, they just jump.

@SatanBurger Exactly. Why would want to know what someone thinks before arguing with them?