X gender in passport

@zonavar68 Trolling?

@zonavar68 So if someone has their penis removed, they're female?
If a woman gets a penis attached, that woman is now a male?

@BohemianBabe I said 'at birth'. So a trans person is always still the sex/gender they were born as regardless.

@zonavar68 So those cases where a male is born without a penis, it's actually wrong to call him a male?

@BohemianBabe I also covered those very rare situations. Basically, if the DNA has XY sex chromosomes the person is male, if XX the person is female. I don't know if YY is possible. This is why gender and sex are the same, and trans people cannot legitimately claim to not be the sex/gender they were at birth.

@zonavar68 but why don’t they not register the x in general both have X chromosomes? And how does it go with intersex persons?

@zonavar68
What if the person has XXX, XXY, or XO? What if different cells have different chromosome matches?
Also, how do you know what a person's chromosomes are? If someone looks like a woman, do you ask for proof that they have XX?

@zonavar68 Most people don't actually have their chromosomes checked by a doctor. So how do you know you have XY? When a woman on a dating site checks "woman," do you think she actually got her chromosomes checked?

The chromosome argument is legit the worst one. Nobody cares about chromosomes, like 90% of society doesn't actually know what their chromosomes are. If you were in a relationship with a woman who, years later, found out she doesn't have XX, you wouldn't care.

@BohemianBabe The XX vs XY is how the DNA is coded to make a person female or male, therefore a woman cannot by XY and a man cannot be XX.

This is why a trans person is a 'false premise' biologically as their DNA doesn't change despite having 'gender re-assignment'.

@zonavar68
Nope, there actually have been females with XY, and males with XX. These cases are rare, but they do happen.


HRT changes DNA. So while a person can change their gender and not their sex, they can also change both their gender and their sex.

@BohemianBabe making them artificial freaks. *flame suit is on* 8-)

@zonavar68 So you don't take any medicine? You'd never get surgery?
If someone gets a pacemaker, are they now an artificial freak?
I wear glasses, I guess I'm a freak. I mean, I am a freak, but not for this.

@zonavar68 Why?