Which pair of boots should I get out of the two?

While I personally prefer the first pair, a determining factor for you might be what's the purpose. What will they be worn for?

I like the first ones but those heels look like they would snap real easy.

Neither are my taste. Having said that of the two, I would choose the black

It depends on what you intend to wear them with

The Aqua are very Sexy. The Black look kinda clunky.

Black. You can wear them more often.

The first pair would be my choice!

First pair

The top ones

second

Top

Black

A

Kinky lol

both are good 👍 everyone wins 😁