Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Remember when in the US, I think it was up in Buffalo there were people dying from the cold weather and some people were still in their cars?

Well, I wanted to ask this hypothetical question and then see what you think.

So you're driving down the highway in a gasoline powered car, low visibility, lots of snow, 15 degree weather outside. You're driving in your car, all nice and hot as you have the heater on, all of a sudden you run off the road and into a ditch. There are other cars around you, your car didn't flip, it didn't get all banged up, and it still runs.

I've seen video where once people get into a spot like this, they are getting out of their cars. So here's where I'm asking questions. Wouldn't it be better to stay in the nice, warm car vs. going outside into 15 degree weather? Now I know, other cars could be coming to hit yours but, what if you're getting out of your car and a car hits into your car which then injures you. It would have just been better to stay in the car then wouldn't it? And, I mean, if the car still runs, you can at least run the heater to stay warm until help comes.

Maybe I just see thing differently? I understand that by staying in the car, you run the risk of, "what happens when other cars hit into yours?" but at least you're semi safe for the moment. I just think that by getting out of your car, not only are you exposing yourself to the elements, you could be hit by other cars.

Am I wrong on this, or am I missing something? I just don't understand why you would get out of your car.
Top | New | Old
Notanymore · 41-45, M Best Comment
Always, keep food, water, warm clothes, communication, blankets and other essentials in your vehicle. ( Get home bag) . Stay with your vehicle if it's safe to do so, and the elements are treacherous. Make absolutely sure your exhaust pipe isn't obstructed if you run your engine. Many people have survived. It's essential to have proper equipment and provisions and a little bit of smarts.
twiigss · M
@Notanymore Thanks for the answer!! Everything you said makes perfect sense to me, and is logical to do these things. I am definitely not prepared like that, but I do have my phone and a cigarette lighter phone charger, but I'm pretty good with making sure that in the morning my phone is at 100%.
Notanymore · 41-45, M
@twiigss that's extremely important, especially in inclement weather. A get home bag can be very easy and affordable. Survivalism is probably my favorite hobby, so I put much more thought effort and money into it than necessary, but it doesn't take a lot to make a terrible situation survivable.

BlueVeins · 26-30
Depends how cold it is, what equipment you've got to work with, and how bad of a spot you're in. Obv the real ideal case is to drive out of it, but that's not always possible. 15 degrees really isn't that bad though for survivability.
twiigss · M
@BlueVeins I'm not exactly sure what the temperatures were in Buffalo, but apparently there was a person in their car waiting for help, and they died from the cold temps in their car. So I'm thinking, well how? Were they not wearing a jacket? Or were they somehow exposed to the elements?
BlueVeins · 26-30
@twiigss If they were old or anemic, it makes sense, or if they were stuck for a crazy amount of time. I don't know all the ins & outs of that story.
twiigss · M
@BlueVeins Yea same. I remember a headline, some reports but nothing too specific about those people.
itsok · 31-35, F
It’s easy to decide what you’d do when you have lots of time and comfort to think on it. I don’t think it’ll feel the same when you’ve lost control of your car and are in a ditch in bad weather.
twiigss · M
@itsok Well, I do usually go to the idea that if I'm in a warm car, why would I leave that for cold weather? I can stay in there, make a phone call/text message for help.
itsok · 31-35, F
@twiigss what I was saying is that you can respond differently in traumatic situations. The well thought out plan you make beforehand isn’t necessarily what you’ll do
twiigss · M
@itsok Oh yea no I knew what you were saying. I guess I didn't say what I meant properly lol. Basically I already have it in my head to stay put. So like even if I was in a situation like that, I would 95% most likely stay in the car.

But you are right in that it's easier said than done. And I agree with you. You can think about what you'll do, but when put in that situation, you'd probably do different than what you said you would do.
samueltyler2 · 80-89, M
First question, why go out in the storm?
Sounds good to me!
ProfessorPlum77 · 70-79, MVIP
There is a danger of carbon monoxide poisoning in cars with gasoline powered engines.
twiigss · M
@ProfessorPlum77 I would think if you are outside of the car at the tailpipe, but I've never had a problem with carbon monoxide coming into the cars cabin, unless I was having problems with the muffler.
Lilymoon · F
I'm staying in the car and hope someone helps me. No way I'd go out especially at night. 🤷‍♀️
candycane · 36-40, F
Electric cars die and have no heat
twiigss · M
@candycane Yea I read some articles about that. So it's understandable with the electric cars. What about a gasoline powered car?

 
Post Comment