Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

So I’m taking the plunge this year. Therapy.

In past years, I’ve guided myself through my anxiety struggles thanks to outside resources from medical professionals I could access easily, but last year compacted too much heaviness into my little ole head for me to even try to dissect and rearrange some of the mental aspects that are far too complicated for a layman like me. It’s time to begin facing the hard things I don’t want to in order to make an attempt to find the mental peace and clarity I want from life. But here’s the question that brought me to a full stop. Do I want a male or a female therapist?

Here’s my thing. I grew up with a man. I was extremely sheltered from people in general and wasn’t really exposed to women outside of my family. Even then, I rarely saw those family members. My friends weren’t really girly girls and deep talks didn’t happen that much. Because of that lack of exposure to women, as an adult I found myself emotionally uncomfortable with them…oddly unfamiliar with them and not knowing how to relate to them or even communicate with them. I’d become very quiet in their presence, just smiling and existing until a guy would come around who talked about guy things I knew more about.

My current job has broken that barrier down quite a bit as I’ve had no choice but to lean on women and have seen my girl side really come through to play off of other chicks who I mesh well with. I feel closer to women now than I ever have, but even with saying that I still find it hard to open up to them. It’s hard to even reach out to my girl friends because so many of them…forgive me for saying this…will rope me into their drama and because I was devoid of experiencing softness in my early years, I unfortunately attribute it to weakness, which is something I don’t want any part of as it’s a reflection of my own emotional weakness. I simply don’t have the mental and emotional space to accommodate that right now. I’m the therapist of any group I’m in, but I just can’t be that person right now. I’m not in the severe survival mode I was in last year, but I am fully in a recovery mode that is taking a lot of finesse to even make my way through. Which is why it’s time for therapy.

Now, men. This is tricky because while I’m naturally more comfortable with them, thanks to the exposure to too many of them hell bent on showing their less favorable side, I’m very much on guard when I’m in their presence. I don’t trust them like I used to and I waste no time in challenging their authoritative role when I feel they haven’t earned it in life. It’s a weird dynamic to say the least. I question their words more now, and definitely their intentions and even their methods. And unfortunately I know that far too many get into the psychological field to help their wounded childhoods and strive to feel purposeful as an adult despite their world crashing down on the inside. …Jesus, I’m never going to find a therapist 🙄


So, I know no one can make the decision on which gender would work best for me, but I’d love to hear about those who have taken the therapy route and how they choose the person they did to help them on their journey to better mental clarity.
Top | New | Old
HikingMan · 51-55, M
I just started therapy too.
My therapist is male, but I didn't pick him.
He was picked for me by a friend who does PTSD counseling for combat veterans out in Seatle Washington.

I originally wen to him for help but he refused to counsel me because of our friendship and his licensing not being transferable to MA.
But he walked me through what to expect and did the research on therapists near me. He came to me with a list of about 20 professionals, but I was so nervous and anxious that I couldn't even think straight enough to read the bio descriptions.

I asked him to just pick one, so he took some time reading the bios and finally settled on a guy.

I've had one session so far and we got along well, and he didn't weird me out or anything.
My next session is on the 24th.

What it will come down to is how you're feeling when you're talking.
The thing to remember is that it is All About You!
Most therapists will tell you on your first session that it's very common for people to go to a couple different people before finally settling on someone they feel comfortable enough to bring down most of their walls with.

It takes vulnerability which isn't easy at all. Impossible if you're not feeling it with any given therapist.

I wish you much luck, my lovely friend.
Be well.
PerfectionOfTheHeart · 46-50, F
@HikingMan
The thing to remember is that it is All About You!

That’s something I’m going to struggle tremendously with. Just knowing that spotlight is going to be hyper focused makes me want to naturally close myself off. It’ll be…an adjustment. And I fear I may be a bit combative. That’s probably common though. I’m going to have to try and find someone who can handle me with a kind of firmness that meets softness.

I’m glad you’re on this path though and I hope it helps you flourish in life, even if it’s slowly.

And thank you.
HikingMan · 51-55, M
@PerfectionOfTheHeart
It’s not a spotlight as much as it is a well lit room filled with all the flowers and sunshine and all the garish paintings and ugly statues of your past.

Whatever you say you won’t surprise them or dismay them, and they’ll sit there beside you without judgement as you go through it.

All About You was meant as an emboldening statement to let you know that it’s okay to switch people as many times as needed for you to find the right person
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
BrandNewMan · 61-69, M
Having had both men and women in both extensive couples counseling and in individual counseling for shorter time, personality and their communication style mattered more than gender to me. Both the best and least impactful were women, with men falling in between.

Interviewing can help give you a feel for that, but it is not uncommon to take a couple times to find someone you relate to well enough.

Best of luck as you begin this journey.
PerfectionOfTheHeart · 46-50, F
@BrandNewMan Thanks for that. I foolishly expected myself to nail it on the first attempt 🤦🏻‍♀. Definitely going to meet with multiple therapists and see which one compliments my healing journey the most.
BrandNewMan · 61-69, M
@PerfectionOfTheHeart You may get it right the first time, you never know. Our last marrage counselor was our first interview starting that round and the best we had spread across 4 cycles over a 20+ yr span.

It was not her fault the marriage wasn't saved.
Chiefjustice · 46-50, M
I always have seen, both men or women and noticed both provided advice from a different lense. As i have come to realize inherent gender difference (biolgy) often influences advice given as well as their perception of who we are.

It is not easy! Bless you sis!.
Livingwell · 61-69, M
I've had both - good and bad. It clearly boils down to a simple question. Which therapist do you feel most comfortable with. It's more about personality than gender. You may need to interview a few to find one that clicks. 🤗
PerfectionOfTheHeart · 46-50, F
@Livingwell This is true. An interview process really, the focus on their energy more so than their gender. Solid advice 🫂
I actually made most progress with a male therapist. It was when I was young though, I was supposed to have continued on into adulthood, but I decided to just be private. Just stop thinking about things. Wrong thing to do because now my anxiety I think gets out of control. I still actually feel more comfortable with male. Maybe like you, my friends have always been male
PerfectionOfTheHeart · 46-50, F
@Bexsy Mmhmm, that’s exactly what trying to ignore does. It’s why mine became too big of a beast to tame on my own.
uncalled4 · 56-60, M
I've always felt more comfortable with a woman therapist. I have a lot of women friends. I've enjoyed success with male therapists, but for me, I need that female energy.
PerfectionOfTheHeart · 46-50, F
@uncalled4 Female energy as in more nurturing perhaps?
uncalled4 · 56-60, M
@PerfectionOfTheHeart Not certain. It all just hits differently.
PerfectionOfTheHeart · 46-50, F
@uncalled4 Thank you for sharing that.
Ironhand · 51-55, M
I see a Male but mostly because of my particular situation and circumstances..
PerfectionOfTheHeart · 46-50, F
@Ironhand Well, you could. I’d just expect the room to empty real quick.

But in all seriousness, I understand. Yours is a specific situation where an enormous amount of strength and empathy is required.
Ironhand · 51-55, M
@PerfectionOfTheHeart I think I'd be more concerned if people just were kinda like "Yeah, me too"
PerfectionOfTheHeart · 46-50, F
@Ironhand …same.
I had two short stints with male therapists. Both hopeless. I took the drugs and ran.

 
Post Comment