This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
DrWatson · 70-79, M
I think there is some truth to this, but only to the extent that personality is influenced by culture.
So, for example, people from Latin America, Italy, and Greece tend to be more "huggy" and effusive than people from Germany, Norway, or the UK.
I also think that some of those "ethnic traits" occur in lots of different cultures, but each culture claims it to itself. Thus your example of "Latin temper" and "Irish temper."
My mother, who was born in Italy, used to joke about "Italian time." (If something was supposed to happen in 20 minutes, maybe it would happen after an hour.) But I have since learned that this "trait" gets pinned to lots of other cultures as well. I suspect that it is rooted in agrarian cultures where people don't need clocks.
I would be surprised if any of this were genetic. Although, in recent years we are discovering that genetics is a lot more weird and complicated than people thought, so who knows!
So, for example, people from Latin America, Italy, and Greece tend to be more "huggy" and effusive than people from Germany, Norway, or the UK.
I also think that some of those "ethnic traits" occur in lots of different cultures, but each culture claims it to itself. Thus your example of "Latin temper" and "Irish temper."
My mother, who was born in Italy, used to joke about "Italian time." (If something was supposed to happen in 20 minutes, maybe it would happen after an hour.) But I have since learned that this "trait" gets pinned to lots of other cultures as well. I suspect that it is rooted in agrarian cultures where people don't need clocks.
I would be surprised if any of this were genetic. Although, in recent years we are discovering that genetics is a lot more weird and complicated than people thought, so who knows!
bijouxbroussard · F
@DrWatson Yes, especially about the time issue. My grandmother used to joke about people arriving on "CFT" (colored folks’ time) and as I grew up I encountered comparable terms by Asian and Hispanic friends. Apparently the only people who show up on time are WASPS. 😅
My parents didn’t get that memo; punctuality was stressed when we were growing up. Even now, I tend to arrive at appointments early.
My parents didn’t get that memo; punctuality was stressed when we were growing up. Even now, I tend to arrive at appointments early.
DrWatson · 70-79, M
@bijouxbroussard
I was talking about this one day with a neighbor who is originally from the Bahamas. She had to adjust to people's expectations about this when she moved here. It occurred to us that the predominant ethnic group around here is German -- and Germany is a country that actually prides itself on making clocks! 😂
I was talking about this one day with a neighbor who is originally from the Bahamas. She had to adjust to people's expectations about this when she moved here. It occurred to us that the predominant ethnic group around here is German -- and Germany is a country that actually prides itself on making clocks! 😂