This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
greensnacks · F
I think so. I believe it's more of a cultural, geographical and societal influence that creates these "stereotypes".
Its true for ex. That Germans are punctual and straight to the point. Many colder climate nations too. It's debated that the coldness and harsh conditions (in place where you can die out of cold if you're left waiting or beat around the bush) contributed to this.
In contrast, warmer cultures, due to probably the abundance of warmth, food and access to nice weather allowed them to be more cheerful, laid back. For ex. Islanders are very not punctual. Especially if it's a small island. Like even the government institutions don't rush anywhere.
People in Russia don't smile to strangers. Excess laughing is considered foolish. And they're very "depressing" and always talk about heavy topics, like the heavy weather. At least in the northern cities. But it's very cultural to complain here as well. It's bonding. Talking about our hardships helps us stay resilient. Most Slavic people do that. We do it too. We complain a lot. We also always reject the first time when someone offers us something. Is seen as rude to take immediately. Will that make you more humble and down to earth? Yes.
Its true for ex. That Germans are punctual and straight to the point. Many colder climate nations too. It's debated that the coldness and harsh conditions (in place where you can die out of cold if you're left waiting or beat around the bush) contributed to this.
In contrast, warmer cultures, due to probably the abundance of warmth, food and access to nice weather allowed them to be more cheerful, laid back. For ex. Islanders are very not punctual. Especially if it's a small island. Like even the government institutions don't rush anywhere.
People in Russia don't smile to strangers. Excess laughing is considered foolish. And they're very "depressing" and always talk about heavy topics, like the heavy weather. At least in the northern cities. But it's very cultural to complain here as well. It's bonding. Talking about our hardships helps us stay resilient. Most Slavic people do that. We do it too. We complain a lot. We also always reject the first time when someone offers us something. Is seen as rude to take immediately. Will that make you more humble and down to earth? Yes.
greensnacks · F
@greensnacks that being said, even if genetically these can be passed on to a person, if they move or have children in a different environment, they will inevitably adjust to the new environment. Humans are very adaptable. It's why we're everywhere
JimboSaturn · 56-60, M
@greensnacks I agree with your theory. I find the cold climate forged a certain culture. But some things like Irish temper I think is just a prejudice. Since there was conflict in Ireland, people assumed it was solely because of their nature, not religious or political reasons.
greensnacks · F
@JimboSaturn yes yes, i don't disagree. There are many many many factors that include cultural habits etc but each human is individual with their own specifics and personalities. Summing them up oversimplifies a cultular experience and helps feed the stereotypes.
Moreover, I did some more research on this yesterday after the comments I made and I found out "while climate has a role in shaping some broad cultural tendencies, it interacts with a complex web of historical, economic, and societal influences." And what I was describing in the initial comment, were not personality traits, but cultural traits and cultural tendencies.
Moreover, I did some more research on this yesterday after the comments I made and I found out "while climate has a role in shaping some broad cultural tendencies, it interacts with a complex web of historical, economic, and societal influences." And what I was describing in the initial comment, were not personality traits, but cultural traits and cultural tendencies.
JimboSaturn · 56-60, M
@greensnacks I understood that your reply was not meant to by 100% explanatory.