justbob · 61-69, M
But they can not be. If everything is free there is no motive to work and if nobody works then nobody is growing the food or providing medical care.
View 24 more replies »
Jexie · 26-30, F
Who's gonna pay the people building your house, working in hospitals and schools? They're working too and need to get paid. I used to think that basic things should be free too but reality is much more harsh. It doesn't work that way when you get down to it and it's idealistic thinking. Society already has compensations for people who are less fortunate, and yes, I agree there should be more. But the things you mention just aren't for free, because everyone's playing their part.
Blondily · F
I wish ✨
MayorOfCrushtown · M
exhale
Luke73 · 26-30, M
@MayorOfCrushtown And the only way to make it affordable for everyone is to make it free.
MayorOfCrushtown · M
@Luke73 just tell me who i need to write to. LOL
Luke73 · 26-30, M
@MayorOfCrushtown The politian of your choice, activists that want to change something, your local organizations that help with food or other do other voluntary work.
This comment is hidden.
Show Comment
joe438 · 61-69, M
Who pays for them? You’d be okay with being housed in a barracks somewhere and provided whatever food someone decided to make for you?
Luke73 · 26-30, M
@joe438 I mean profit can be a motivation, I agree, but profit isn't a justification for bad things. I'd make a big profit if I force people to work for me in inhumane conditions. Is it ethical? No. Does it happen? Too much in the name of profit.
Your comment made me chuckle. So you're saying the US is a good example for a government letting people live their lives without interfering much? Have you seen the news lately?
Your comment made me chuckle. So you're saying the US is a good example for a government letting people live their lives without interfering much? Have you seen the news lately?
joe438 · 61-69, M
@Luke73 Lots of companies will share their profits with others in society - not all, but many. They will crow about giving back, but that's fine.
Can you name a country that has less overall restriction? Australia restricts guns and has more limitations on speech than the US - most recently is the clamping down on social media to protect kids. Not necessarily a bad thing, but there it is. The UK is much more strict on permitted speech, and of course the EU has the DSA. Germany and Italy rank among the best on the nanny state indices but still below the U.S. Switzerland is the highest ranked in terms of personal freedoms in many ratings. They protect human rights with a web of severe laws for being discriminatory or racist which is kind interesting in itself. No free housing though, and no free food that I can find reference to. They try, like some in the U.S. do, to provide the most affordable housing they can muster.
We're way off topic at this point. I do like your premise that we should be kind to each other and help out, but can that also go along with having no one try and cheat the system and steal?
Can you name a country that has less overall restriction? Australia restricts guns and has more limitations on speech than the US - most recently is the clamping down on social media to protect kids. Not necessarily a bad thing, but there it is. The UK is much more strict on permitted speech, and of course the EU has the DSA. Germany and Italy rank among the best on the nanny state indices but still below the U.S. Switzerland is the highest ranked in terms of personal freedoms in many ratings. They protect human rights with a web of severe laws for being discriminatory or racist which is kind interesting in itself. No free housing though, and no free food that I can find reference to. They try, like some in the U.S. do, to provide the most affordable housing they can muster.
We're way off topic at this point. I do like your premise that we should be kind to each other and help out, but can that also go along with having no one try and cheat the system and steal?
Luke73 · 26-30, M
@joe438 Well if a company gives a million in charity but earns billions in revenue each year, do they really share their profit? It's a thousand of what they make, so...
Having no restrictions isn't the same as freedom. Freedom isn't just about the things you can do but also about not having to worry about something. And you can't tell me the US is a good place to be especially now... it's taken gigantic steps back from being a free country.
And the biggest problem isn't the people trying to take advantage of the social security system, it's the big corporations that control the system. That's not a democracity anymore.
Having no restrictions isn't the same as freedom. Freedom isn't just about the things you can do but also about not having to worry about something. And you can't tell me the US is a good place to be especially now... it's taken gigantic steps back from being a free country.
And the biggest problem isn't the people trying to take advantage of the social security system, it's the big corporations that control the system. That's not a democracity anymore.
FreddieUK · 70-79, M
A bit naive, I think.
FreddieUK · 70-79, M
@Luke73 I'd like to agree, but I'm afraid it's a basic human trait and you'd be hard pushed to find me a system where there is not a rich elite either at the top, or hiding in the background manipulating some puppets. I believe it is possible to modify greedy instincts and the Nordic countries were quite good at that until recently. Compared to the US, much of Europe is ahead in its regulation of the worst excesses, but there is always the pressure from right wing forces to deregulate.
In yr dreams
1490wayb · 56-60, M
explain how this happens...so the contractors, plumbers, electricians, carpenters, materials, nurses, doctors go to school and work free?? all hospital stays, medical tests and equipment
Penny · 46-50, F
entitled much? lol
Penny · 46-50, F
@Luke73 about affordable housing programs? teh government get builders to offer affordable housing units as a condition to letting them build complexes and stuff. in NJ at least. in Boston they called them the Projects. Theyr ejust like condo units that are more affordable to buy but you have to be on alist to get into them and have the money when your name comes up to buy into one. i think thats how it is. The boston ones might have been rentals. im not sure.
eta- youhave to qualify as low income to get on the list
eta- youhave to qualify as low income to get on the list
saragoodtimes · F
and who's going to pay for all these freebies
Luke73 · 26-30, M
@saragoodtimes We as a society. I think it’s only fair if the more fortunate ones support the less fortunate ones. No one can choose in what living situation they grew up in.
Ferise1 · 46-50, M
@saragoodtimes they can just print more money
Uk has free healthcare
joe438 · 61-69, M
@Jane90 a colleague at the university lived in the UK until recently and said the wait times for appointments was horrible and the Care was rushed. I don’t know if things have improved in the last year, but she couldn’t wait to get over here where you can make an appointment with a doctor and generally get in within a week or two.
gregloa · 61-69, M
Being lazy isn’t a basic human right. Nothing is free. If you want it, you gotta be willing to work for it. Nobody should expect hard working Americans to pay for lazy people’s housing, food, healthcare, or healthcare.
pdockal · 56-60, M
Who will pay for YOUR freebies ?????
saragoodtimes · F
@pdockal the top 10% income earners pay over 70% of all tax dollars. our school and property taxes are over $40,000 a year. it's going up 8% this year. waiting on the bill
pdockal · 56-60, M
@saragoodtimes
First property tax isn't based on income
It's based on the value of the property
Second most rich don't pay their share because of the deductions & how they earn their money
The middle class foots most of the taxes
If you want equity then you need a flat tax with no deductions
First property tax isn't based on income
It's based on the value of the property
Second most rich don't pay their share because of the deductions & how they earn their money
The middle class foots most of the taxes
If you want equity then you need a flat tax with no deductions
Roundandroundwego · 61-69
USA is fascist and thus is an outlaw state without social welfare, fair and square.


















