Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Why does a person get down on bended knee?

Marriage? Something else? What is the symbolism of doing so?

I've never been engaged or married, or asked a woman to get married, or been to a wedding, so the whole thing is a totally foreign concept and I don't see why the 'bended knee' bit is supposed to be important.
Top | New | Old
Rudboy41 · 41-45, M
Good question, the only thing that comes to mind is the gesture of being honoured or when we accept a special accolade, think of the posture that men have while they are being knighted by a queen. It feels similar to me, the body language of a man on bended knee ( game of thrones bend the knee?) With a proposal the woman is his future queen and the man is asking for the honour of being having her as his wife, of receiving the accolade of having the title of husband instead of just boyfriend.
subhubby · 56-60, M
I got down and kneeled for my wife and gave my vows to her on our last anniversary. For me, it’s to show my devotion and desire to obey her and love her and attend to her forever. It’s a way to show your love I think.
zonavar68 · 56-60, M
@subhubby Why does the other person then not have to do the same thing for you, to show true two-way and mutually respectful devotion? This is the flaw I see in marriage. The proposee (usually a woman) gets all the benefit of the proposer (usually a man) but doesn't have to bring anything to the table her/himself.
Infamous607 · 51-55, M
@subhubby Not sure about the obeying part. But yeah .this.
Monalisasmith86 · 41-45, F
@zonavar68 women want to without being judged
exexec · 70-79, C
Our son proposed to his wife on bended knee in front of a group of friends. She was the last one to realize what was happening. I never proposed to my wife, but after dating for almost 8 years, she knew what the ring meant when I put it on her finger.
zonavar68 · 56-60, M
@exexec Nice. That's so far away from where I feel about the idea of marriage that I couldn't see it being something I'd do. Being single sort of rules it out by default. lol
It’s a tradition that symbolizes respect, honor, and devotion. It dates back to medieval times when knights would kneel before noblewomen as a sign of loyalty and admiration.
@FreeSpirit1 not only beautiful but a historian as well
@zonavar68 that sounds like an answer a guy with a submissive fetish would say. My answer is more in line with the true meaning of it
zonavar68 · 56-60, M
@FreeSpirit1 I respect your opinions. I have never been married, or proposed (or been proposed to), or even been to a wedding. My parents divorced when I was 12 and it was awful (for me not having any understanding of relationships, or sex, etc.). I've never liked marriage since I see it as a toxic concept, esp. when it's very one-sided (or looks to be) all in favour of the proposee (usually a woman) at a huge cost to the proposer (usually a man). It could be part of the reason I never could fully understand the full gamut of what sex, dating, relationships, is even though I tried as an adult without ever having any help from parents during my teen years. Everything about sex and relationships I find completely frightening now.
hippyjoe1955 · 70-79, M
zonavar68 · 56-60, M
@hippyjoe1955 Except a marriage proposal isn't a prayer. I didn't know it was convention to get down on one knee to pray.
DrWatson · 70-79, M
@zonavar68

Actually, the original meaning of "pray" was simply "ask", not necessarily of God.

For example, "I pray thee, cease thy counsel", is one of many instances when Shakespeare uses the word that way. This old tradition of kneeling when asking for a woman's hand fits the old meaning of prayer.
Infamous607 · 51-55, M
Because you are telling the person with that gesture that you love them and trust them enough to lay down your life and service to them .
I’ve never seen a man FORCED to kneel during a proposal.
zonavar68 · 56-60, M
@Mamapolo2016 Fair point - not that I've ever seen a real-life proposal take place. It's not really valid to base it only on proposals in films and on TV.

If a man *doesn't* do it though with the feminist cohort start labelling the man as sub-standard and not insubordinate enough? ;-)
@zonavar68 Some men are romantic and some aren’t. I would assume that if he’s proposing, they’ve known each other a spell.

A proposal isn’t a contract, it’s a request. If she finds it vital that he kneels, she can say no.

On the other hand, if he doesn’t kneel, it says something about him, yes. If she likes what it says, again, her choice.

Again, I have never seen nor heard “the feminist cohort” criticize a man for not taking a knee for a proposal.

Some women want to be worshipped (which is what it implies, kneeling). Some women want to be loved.
Pretzel · 70-79, M
consider it training for our position for the rest of the relationship :)
DrWatson · 70-79, M
Imagine the middle ages, with men wearing swords.

If one man kneels to another, he is making himself vulnerable to being killed. Even if they both drew their swords at that point, the one with (literally) the "upper hand" has the advantage.

So men knelt to signify their obedience to a king. It is a pose of non-aggression.

When a man proposes marriage, the kneeling position represented that same kind of vulnerability. She might pierce his heart with a metaphorical sword if she said no.
zonavar68 · 56-60, M
@DrWatson Many women still do say 'no' apparently, unless they perceive their future partner has lots of money and meets the '666-rule' requirements, etc.
markinkansas · 61-69, M
to look up her skirt . grin
AthrillatheHunt · 51-55, M
Ancient act of submission and loyalty . Ancient
zonavar68 · 56-60, M
@AthrillatheHunt so why is a man required to submit to a future life partner?
AthrillatheHunt · 51-55, M
@zonavar68 see the above
no choice when the mob hits you with a baseball bat. have a bendd knee the rest of your life
Thrust · 56-60, M
The feather Indians get down on Wounded Knee!

 
Post Comment