Upset
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

I should not have to win a debate about structural inequality to get a friend to acknowledge that I've been hurt.

My privilege is real, but so is my suffering. I acknowledge the advantages I've had as a white man. What I reject is the suggestion that those advantages somehow negate the abuse, violence, and exploitation I've experienced. You don't get to use my demographic identity to tell me what I'm allowed to feel about my own life

I don't dispute that women face particular risks or that being male can confer certain social advantages. What I dispute is your attempt to use those advantages to invalidate my experiences.

I've experienced emotional abuse, financial victimization, dangerous behavior from someone who should have protected me, and physical assault by a woman.

My being white and male didn't prevent any of those things from happening.

You're confusing a statistical advantage enjoyed by a demographic group with immunity from suffering at the individual level.

More importantly, you're making the fallacy of relative privation: arguing that because someone else suffers differently or more severely, my experiences don't deserve acknowledgment.

I don't need to prove that I've suffered more than women to establish that I've suffered. And I shouldn't have to

Privilege did not shield me when my father so angry that he had to feed his 15/16 year old child and he couldn't do it easily on account of my autism It meant he had to take me out somewhere to eat and he lashed out by driving erratically weaving in and out of traffic.

I've been stolen from, assaulted violently, defrauded, beaten up, you name it. and my "privilege" didn't stop any of it from happening.
Top | New | Old
jademonkey19 · 41-45, T
Nope, you should not have to debate structural inequality to discuss your pain. Your pain and your experiences are valid.

Part of intersectionality requires that we make each other's struggles our own - we're all caught up in a system that's designed to commodify and brutalize everyone (including white men).

 
Post Comment