This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
Iwillwait · M
The immigration process: The right to remain silent is not applicable to a non citizen person.
@Iwillwait how does work during the hearing to determine whether or not someone is a citizen? I think the constitution explicitly says person rather than citizen because you can't make the differentiation before the end of such cases.
Iwillwait · M
@NerdyPotato Pleasantly thought out well articulated argument, however, I am not sure a 5th Amendment applies unless Amnesty is demanded.
@Iwillwait the Constitution explicitly says it applies to "any person". So unless you're not sure whether someone who is allegedly illegal is a person, there's no doubt whether it applies.







