Changing the Democratic leadership
This would make more sense if the Democrats had suffered a loss in the recent election, but their victory was at least in part due to strategic decisions Schumer and Jeffries made as to which races to fund and by how much. The calls to replace them make no sense in light of that, especially when the main reason is their ties to AIPAC and their failure to pass wish-list bills when the Democrats were in the minority. Electoral-Vote.com has a good analysis.
https://www.electoral-vote.com/evp2026/Items/Nov13-4.html
Well, time to put this donkey out to pasture, perhaps.
In this series, there are some topics that aren't too time-sensitive, because they won't be actionable until January 3, 2027. However, the choice of leadership is something that is being wrestled with right now. The general presumption, given the way inertia works, is that Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) will be promoted to Senate Majority Leader, and House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D-NY) will be promoted to Speaker.
This is almost certainly what will happen, but there are certainly some Democratic voters and officeholders who are not happy about it. Schumer is a bit long in the tooth (75), is very bland, and tends to use verbiage that comes off as spineless or conciliatory. Jeffries takes money from some very unpopular folks, like AIPAC and the crypto industry, and he also tends to use verbiage that comes off as spineless or conciliatory. Further, both men are seen as old blood when a lot of voters are looking for new blood—Schumer because he's been in Washington forever, and Jeffries because he's Nancy Pelosi's guy.
We will start our assessment with Jeffries. We have considered the matter carefully, and have concluded that for the 260 or Democrats who get a vote here, trying to cashier the would-be Speaker would be extremely impolitic. Here are five reasons why:
One of the big storylines in this election was Black voters exercising their political muscle and making the Democratic Party and the Congress a bit more diverse. It would not be well, mere days or weeks after such a development, to set aside the man who is set to become the first Black speaker in history.
Speaker of the House is a pretty tough job. The Speaker must do a lot of fundraising, a lot of recruitment of candidates, a lot of cat herding, and a lot of serving as the de facto spokesperson for the Democratic Party (especially when the president is not a Democrat). Jeffries is not great at that last job, but he's pretty good at the others. If the Democrats were going to replace him, they would need someone who has at least some experience with these tasks. That means someone already in a leadership position. And none of the people in leadership, besides Jeffries, is Black—which brings us back to problem #1. If John Lewis was still alive, maybe. Or if Barack Obama was willing to take the job (remember, the speaker need not be a member of the House), then maybe. But Lewis rising from the dead is roughly as likely as Obama agreeing to serve.
Members of the House have to run for reelection every 2 years. Earlier this week, Rep.-elect Don Leonard (D-OH) told reporters about some friendly advice he'd received from people who will be his new colleagues: If you challenge the throne, you're going to find yourself without committee assignments, and without funding for your reelection campaign. Leonard reiterated that this was not phrased as a threat, merely a heads up as to how things work. In any case, the point is that any member who rebels is taking a big risk with their career.
Meanwhile, the Speaker needs the votes of a majority of the entire House (in other words, at least 218 votes). So, an apostate Democrat would need to find 217 other Democrats willing to join in the apostasy. That is a LOT.
While Jeffries is kinda "old blood," by virtue of having been in office since 2007 and in leadership since 2017, and being Pelosi's protégé, he's only 56. It's not like a replacement would be all that much younger. In fact, he's one year younger then the median age for members of the House right now.
So, Jeffries should (and undoubtedly will) be chosen as the next Speaker.
With Schumer, we think the calculus is considerably different, for these reasons:
He actually is pretty old and, more importantly, he has basically become the living embodiment of "entrenched, feckless Democrat" in the eyes of much of the Party. He's been in Washington since 1981, and he's been in the Senate since 1999. Replacing him would make a very powerful statement that voters are getting the changing of the guard that many of them clearly want.
Senate Majority Leader is a somewhat easier job than Speaker, because there is less of everything—fewer cats to herd, fewer seats that need recruits, fewer fundraisers. The filibuster, for as long as it lasts, also cuts down substantially on the cat-herding duties.
Because the job is easier, and because senators generally have more experience than members of the House, there are a number of very plausible replacements for Schumer among his colleagues.
Because senators have a 6-year cushion, they are taking less of a risk in challenging the throne. Not no risk, but less of a risk, especially since there aren't a couple hundred other senators available to take seats on committees. Further, the Senate Majority Leader is elected only by their own conference/caucus. So, an apostate senator need only round up roughly 27 other apostates, as opposed to 217 others.
It is certainly possible that Schumer will be challenged, when his seat is up in 2028, by Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY). And if she does challenge him, she will likely win. It would be a black eye for the Democratic Party if their Senate leader went down to defeat in the primaries.
For some, or all, of these reasons, there have already been several senators who have come out against another term as leader for Schumer. That list includes Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) and Sen. Elissa Slotkin (D-MI), who pretty much represent the two ends of the Democratic political spectrum. Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed (D-MI) has also suggested he won't back Schumer, and several of his newly elected colleagues have also hinted in that direction.
It is still likely that Schumer will keep his job (and he is VERY unlikely to yield it voluntarily, since he is surely eager to take a 55-45 or 56-44 majority out for a spin). That said, it's not impossible that he'll be demoted. We took a look at the possible replacements, and came up with eight of them, taking care to eliminate: (1) members who would just be a case of swapping in one Social-Security-eligible bland white guy for another, (2) members who are likely to be running for president in 2028 and so will be too busy to run the Senate and (3) new members. With those caveats, here is our list:
Chris Van Hollen (MD): We mention him first because he's already announced a challenge to Schumer, and has been endorsed by Sanders. At 67, he's not much younger than Schumer. He's also not that much more charismatic. However, he's popular with his colleagues, and he's also one of the progressives' favorite senators, since he's taken a hard line on money for Israel, and since he's directly challenged ICE, including a visit to Kilmar Abrego Garcia while Abrego Garcia was being held outside the United States.
Cory Booker (NJ): He's young for a senator (57), is very charismatic, is very popular with his constituents and his colleagues, and knows a thing or two about some well-executed political theater (remember the semi-filibuster). Also, having Black men leading both chambers would make quite a statement. We do realize that he might end up running for president.
Elizabeth Warren (MA): She's actually older than Schumer (77), but she's beloved by both the progressives and the eggheads. She would drive Donald Trump absolutely nuts, and her elevation would break a glass ceiling, as there's never been a woman who served as Senate Majority Leader.
Elissa Slotkin (MI): She's quite young by Senate standards (50). Like Warren, she would break a glass ceiling, and like Warren, she knows how to go toe-to-toe with the Trump administration. She might be too centrist for many Democrats, however.
Catherine Cortez Masto (NV): Cortez Masto would break two glass ceilings, as the first woman and first Latino or Latina to serve as Majority Leader. That should please the lefties. Meanwhile, the fact that she's actually a moderate should please the moderates. Plus, she knows a thing or two about winning in purple states, and so would be good at recruiting swing-state candidates.
Mark Kelly (AZ): We realize that he might also be running for president. But if not, there is nobody on this list who would be better at doing battle with Trump.
Adam Schiff (CA): Ok, Schiff would be pretty good at battling Trump, too, especially since he prosecuted the first impeachment. Also, California has only had one Majority Leader, and that was for just 2 years from 1951-53 (William Knowland).
Raphael Warnock (GA): We think he offers the most attractive opportunity of all. He's 57, Black, very charismatic, and also able to lock horns with Trump. Further, he bet big on Scott Colom in Mississippi and won. If the Democrats really want to try to get a foothold in the Solid South, who better to lead that effort than Warnock?
Again, it is very unlikely that Schumer gets pushed aside. If he does, though, then the Democrats should do something to recognize his service to the Party, and his role in building this majority, by giving him a title like Leader Emeritus (in other words, the same honor that was bestowed on Nancy Pelosi when she stepped aside). Otherwise, maybe we'll have to dust this list off in 2029, if AOC does challenge Schumer and win.
In this series, there are some topics that aren't too time-sensitive, because they won't be actionable until January 3, 2027. However, the choice of leadership is something that is being wrestled with right now. The general presumption, given the way inertia works, is that Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) will be promoted to Senate Majority Leader, and House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D-NY) will be promoted to Speaker.
This is almost certainly what will happen, but there are certainly some Democratic voters and officeholders who are not happy about it. Schumer is a bit long in the tooth (75), is very bland, and tends to use verbiage that comes off as spineless or conciliatory. Jeffries takes money from some very unpopular folks, like AIPAC and the crypto industry, and he also tends to use verbiage that comes off as spineless or conciliatory. Further, both men are seen as old blood when a lot of voters are looking for new blood—Schumer because he's been in Washington forever, and Jeffries because he's Nancy Pelosi's guy.
We will start our assessment with Jeffries. We have considered the matter carefully, and have concluded that for the 260 or Democrats who get a vote here, trying to cashier the would-be Speaker would be extremely impolitic. Here are five reasons why:
One of the big storylines in this election was Black voters exercising their political muscle and making the Democratic Party and the Congress a bit more diverse. It would not be well, mere days or weeks after such a development, to set aside the man who is set to become the first Black speaker in history.
Speaker of the House is a pretty tough job. The Speaker must do a lot of fundraising, a lot of recruitment of candidates, a lot of cat herding, and a lot of serving as the de facto spokesperson for the Democratic Party (especially when the president is not a Democrat). Jeffries is not great at that last job, but he's pretty good at the others. If the Democrats were going to replace him, they would need someone who has at least some experience with these tasks. That means someone already in a leadership position. And none of the people in leadership, besides Jeffries, is Black—which brings us back to problem #1. If John Lewis was still alive, maybe. Or if Barack Obama was willing to take the job (remember, the speaker need not be a member of the House), then maybe. But Lewis rising from the dead is roughly as likely as Obama agreeing to serve.
Members of the House have to run for reelection every 2 years. Earlier this week, Rep.-elect Don Leonard (D-OH) told reporters about some friendly advice he'd received from people who will be his new colleagues: If you challenge the throne, you're going to find yourself without committee assignments, and without funding for your reelection campaign. Leonard reiterated that this was not phrased as a threat, merely a heads up as to how things work. In any case, the point is that any member who rebels is taking a big risk with their career.
Meanwhile, the Speaker needs the votes of a majority of the entire House (in other words, at least 218 votes). So, an apostate Democrat would need to find 217 other Democrats willing to join in the apostasy. That is a LOT.
While Jeffries is kinda "old blood," by virtue of having been in office since 2007 and in leadership since 2017, and being Pelosi's protégé, he's only 56. It's not like a replacement would be all that much younger. In fact, he's one year younger then the median age for members of the House right now.
So, Jeffries should (and undoubtedly will) be chosen as the next Speaker.
With Schumer, we think the calculus is considerably different, for these reasons:
He actually is pretty old and, more importantly, he has basically become the living embodiment of "entrenched, feckless Democrat" in the eyes of much of the Party. He's been in Washington since 1981, and he's been in the Senate since 1999. Replacing him would make a very powerful statement that voters are getting the changing of the guard that many of them clearly want.
Senate Majority Leader is a somewhat easier job than Speaker, because there is less of everything—fewer cats to herd, fewer seats that need recruits, fewer fundraisers. The filibuster, for as long as it lasts, also cuts down substantially on the cat-herding duties.
Because the job is easier, and because senators generally have more experience than members of the House, there are a number of very plausible replacements for Schumer among his colleagues.
Because senators have a 6-year cushion, they are taking less of a risk in challenging the throne. Not no risk, but less of a risk, especially since there aren't a couple hundred other senators available to take seats on committees. Further, the Senate Majority Leader is elected only by their own conference/caucus. So, an apostate senator need only round up roughly 27 other apostates, as opposed to 217 others.
It is certainly possible that Schumer will be challenged, when his seat is up in 2028, by Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY). And if she does challenge him, she will likely win. It would be a black eye for the Democratic Party if their Senate leader went down to defeat in the primaries.
For some, or all, of these reasons, there have already been several senators who have come out against another term as leader for Schumer. That list includes Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) and Sen. Elissa Slotkin (D-MI), who pretty much represent the two ends of the Democratic political spectrum. Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed (D-MI) has also suggested he won't back Schumer, and several of his newly elected colleagues have also hinted in that direction.
It is still likely that Schumer will keep his job (and he is VERY unlikely to yield it voluntarily, since he is surely eager to take a 55-45 or 56-44 majority out for a spin). That said, it's not impossible that he'll be demoted. We took a look at the possible replacements, and came up with eight of them, taking care to eliminate: (1) members who would just be a case of swapping in one Social-Security-eligible bland white guy for another, (2) members who are likely to be running for president in 2028 and so will be too busy to run the Senate and (3) new members. With those caveats, here is our list:
Chris Van Hollen (MD): We mention him first because he's already announced a challenge to Schumer, and has been endorsed by Sanders. At 67, he's not much younger than Schumer. He's also not that much more charismatic. However, he's popular with his colleagues, and he's also one of the progressives' favorite senators, since he's taken a hard line on money for Israel, and since he's directly challenged ICE, including a visit to Kilmar Abrego Garcia while Abrego Garcia was being held outside the United States.
Cory Booker (NJ): He's young for a senator (57), is very charismatic, is very popular with his constituents and his colleagues, and knows a thing or two about some well-executed political theater (remember the semi-filibuster). Also, having Black men leading both chambers would make quite a statement. We do realize that he might end up running for president.
Elizabeth Warren (MA): She's actually older than Schumer (77), but she's beloved by both the progressives and the eggheads. She would drive Donald Trump absolutely nuts, and her elevation would break a glass ceiling, as there's never been a woman who served as Senate Majority Leader.
Elissa Slotkin (MI): She's quite young by Senate standards (50). Like Warren, she would break a glass ceiling, and like Warren, she knows how to go toe-to-toe with the Trump administration. She might be too centrist for many Democrats, however.
Catherine Cortez Masto (NV): Cortez Masto would break two glass ceilings, as the first woman and first Latino or Latina to serve as Majority Leader. That should please the lefties. Meanwhile, the fact that she's actually a moderate should please the moderates. Plus, she knows a thing or two about winning in purple states, and so would be good at recruiting swing-state candidates.
Mark Kelly (AZ): We realize that he might also be running for president. But if not, there is nobody on this list who would be better at doing battle with Trump.
Adam Schiff (CA): Ok, Schiff would be pretty good at battling Trump, too, especially since he prosecuted the first impeachment. Also, California has only had one Majority Leader, and that was for just 2 years from 1951-53 (William Knowland).
Raphael Warnock (GA): We think he offers the most attractive opportunity of all. He's 57, Black, very charismatic, and also able to lock horns with Trump. Further, he bet big on Scott Colom in Mississippi and won. If the Democrats really want to try to get a foothold in the Solid South, who better to lead that effort than Warnock?
Again, it is very unlikely that Schumer gets pushed aside. If he does, though, then the Democrats should do something to recognize his service to the Party, and his role in building this majority, by giving him a title like Leader Emeritus (in other words, the same honor that was bestowed on Nancy Pelosi when she stepped aside). Otherwise, maybe we'll have to dust this list off in 2029, if AOC does challenge Schumer and win.
https://www.electoral-vote.com/evp2026/Items/Nov13-4.html




