Random
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Abortion question for pro-lifers. Thought i'd try this in the form of a poll:

Poll - Total Votes: 10
Little Girl
Embryos
Show Results
You can only vote on one answer.
[c=#BF0000][b][i]Please only vote if you are a pro-lifer. Everyone including Pro choicers are welcome to comment below of course.[/i][/b][/c]

I came across an interesting test for pro-lifers. If you're against abortion and think that humanity begins at conception or a fetus is a person what would you do in the following circumstance:

[quote]You're a firefighter and you're responding to a fire at a fertility clinic or some such.
You enter the building and you see on your left, a 3 year old girl and on your right a tank full of hundreds of fertilized embryos ready and intended for implantation.
The tank and the girl both weigh roughly the same amount

Do you save the little girl or do you save the embryos?[/quote]

If you truly consider the embryos to be human life then obviously you must save the hundreds of humans lives over the one.
If you would save the little girl then you must consider how truly you hold those embryos to be people.
If you’re expecting logic from a pro lifer ,you’ll be waiting a long time,
@Ryderbike [media=https://youtu.be/4Sc2vm6aBMc]
Torsten · 36-40, M
I would pick the girl but that isnt taking a life in the process like abortion does.
If I was a firefighter and had to pick between two adult females to save or one pregnant female, I would be saving two lives no matter the choice.

If people want to kill their unborn children, thats their choice. Not everyone has to like or agree with it though.
Also I dont wanna hear shit from the "my body, my choice" crowd after the whole covid vaccine spectacle
Torsten · 36-40, M
@Pikachu [quote]I don't think realizing that a child is a real person and embryos are not means we should feel nothing for the loss of potential life.
It's a common strawman for prof lifers (and i'm not accusing you personally of this) to pretend that abortion is no big deal to pro choicers.[/quote]
I dont agree with not feeling anything for the loss of potential life. You might just think of a tank of embyos but I think of it as more than that. I think of the women who are trying to have a child and cant and their only hope could be those embryos.
I have a friend who cant have children and seeing everything she goes through in the attempts of having a child is rough to see.
So yeah embryos are potential life and not so much a lives at that state, but they would mean the world to other people

[quote]I don't think it is because as you said, in your mind you're saving two lives either way.
In this scenario you're saving either one human life or, (according to the pro life rhetoric) 100 human lives.
In this scenario one is forced to consider just how much they actually consider an embryo to be a human life as compared to a human who is actually alive.[/quote]
well when you put it like that, thats fair.
@Torsten

[quote]I dont agree with not feeling anything for the loss of potential life[/quote]

Oh i'm not saying that at all. Sorry if i didn't make that clear.
That's why i don't like when pro lifers pretend that pro choicers want to hand out abortions like candy.
It's still a big deal.
Torsten · 36-40, M
@Pikachu all good

I missed the part where you said prolifers pretending abortion is no big deal to pro choicers and I think that has escalated due to the loud minority of certain pro choicers who actively celebrate abortions.
Those are the radical pro choicers of course and I am just as against radical pro lifers with their views. Point i am trying to make it people mostly see the radical people and deem the rest on that side to be all the same.
Zonuss · 41-45, M
Life begins at conception.
Think what you must.
The little girl obviously.
Why ? Because she is in the flesh and it's the law. All lives are equal.
But in this case it's only natural to save the person who is living a life [b] outside [/b]of the womb. You're not smart son. Bring it on. 🙂
Zonuss · 41-45, M
@Pikachu Wow this was a cop out.
You're losing your edge Piki.
🙂
Zonuss · 41-45, M
@SW-User No. You're lame as fuck. And you just proved my point. Loser. 🙂
SW-User
@Zonuss lol oh no
There is no point in answering this question because any answer would result in arguments or insults..
Having made that point. Any reasonable person would be compelled to save the child who is conscious, aware and afraid looking to the person for help..

I'm pro choice but even if I were not my answer would be the same
Pretzel · 61-69, M
that's an interesting conundrum
evidently not for me as I am not rabid pro-life
but an interesting "what if"
well done!
Pretzel · 61-69, M
@Pikachu Poo!
Pretzel · 61-69, M
@Pikachu evil genius look
Iwantyourhotwife · 22-25
Question about this scenario.

Suppose someone decides to take all those embryos. Suppose they're just 10, 5, 2, or even 1 embryo. What would be the outcome to sustain their life and growth?

Because if a little girl is saved, you can give her food. If the embryos are saved, then they'll die anyways, right?
@Iwantyourhotwife

I've just been atheist all my life. Even when i wanted to god to enter my life i never actually believed god was real any more than say, bigfoot.
Although to be fair i've not examined the god claims of most religions. Just the Abrahamic ones.

Politically i just gravitated towards political parties that espoused values that i held. I live in Canada so we've got a bit more to choose from politically than Americans so i've voted Liberal, New Democrat and Green.
Iwantyourhotwife · 22-25
@Pikachu that's a pretty interesting back story. And to be fair, I think the Abrahamic religions are the most infleuntial and most important to understand since they impact and shape so much of the world, so that is understandable.

And if you're Canadian, then you're lucky. I'm an American and I must say that politics here is gang activity but labeled politically correct
@Iwantyourhotwife

Yeah i'm pretty happy to not be an American right now lol
justanothername · 51-55, M
Just to clarify, couples don’t store fertilized embryos, only eggs which are usually harvested and then frozen liquid nitrogen for long term storage which effectively puts them in suspended animation until they are required. When they are required they are defrosted and “matched up” with live sperm which can only be sustained outside the body for about 20-30 minutes at body temperature. After this point the sperm is sucked up into a syringe and injected into the egg to allow the fertilization process to happen.
So to answer the question, I’d save the girl.
I do believe abortion should be legal and I also believe women should have a choice to abort or not. How ever in this case, I’d save the girl. Unfertilized eggs are usually replaceable.
Misanthropic · 26-30, M
I'm pro choice but personally I think that is a ridiculous scenario to put people in. Life does start at conception it just isn't developed or as complex as a child.. one ridiculous scenario for another...

An adult and a child are in a burning building who do you save? Probably the child but the adult has more life experience, their body is more developed and they feel; understand things on a deeper level because of the forementioned life experience.

I think personally that women should have the choice though.
Misanthropic · 26-30, M
@SW-User I am not a pro lifer but I imagine even if I was I would choose the child.
@Misanthropic

[quote]personally I think that is a ridiculous scenario to put people in[/quote]

lol of course it is.
The point is to get pro-lifers to really come face to face with just how much they actually consider a fetus to be the same as a person.
Theyitis · 36-40, M
@Pikachu I’m a little surprised you feel the need to give them this scenario. You seem educated enough that you should already know that the anti-choice movement is actually rooted in white replacement theory, and that they think they can get the white population to grow faster if only they could force educated, liberal white women to settle down and be mothers. Failing that, at least they’ll be putting women in their place.

I like to think I know a few who just don’t use their brains when it comes to politics who really honestly believe the anti-choice movement is about saving babies, but it should be clear that for the vast majority of them it’s about control.
Piper · 61-69, F
I didn't vote, although I know that I am very [b]pro[/b]-life indeed. That is why I would save about any living, breathing born being over hundreds or [i]zillions[/i] of fertilized embryos.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
@SW-User

What i'm expecting are mostly excuses or justifications which attempt to skirt the issue.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
AbbySvenz · F
What were they planning to do with that three year old girl there?? 😨
@AbbySvenz
Probably just someone's kid. Or maybe an orphan who came in to use the bathroom.
Man, nobody is picking the 100 embryos.
Zonuss · 41-45, M
@Pikachu Guess you failed.
Not that you aren't used to it by now 😂😂
@Zonuss

...can you actually describe why you consider that to be a failure or were your just reactively attacking what you see as an enemy?🤔
SW-User
In my case I'd save the little girl but would still feel sad for the embryos.
@SW-User

But if you save them they will survive and if you don't then they'll die. Same as the girl
SW-User
@Pikachu and that's why I would be sad, cause if it was for me I'd save them all. But can't.
@SW-User

Well so then i'm wondering how you make the choice to save one life over one hundred.

Both will live or die depending on your choice.
Both have the same potential to grow up and live a full life.

I guess i'm just not sure what distinction you're making unless like me you don't consider an embryo to be a person in the same way as a child is.
SW-User
Awesome. I wish I could watch them mentally squirm.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
Tastyfrzz · 61-69, M
The lady or the tiger.

 
Post Comment