Cat owners, what does your cat eat that surprises you?

My finicky cat usually only eats dry cat food. But he surprised me last night by seeming VERY interested in my tofutti cream cheese and Tassos olive medley toast!

Silly me...I offered it to him, positive he would turn up his nose, and he ended up licking the olives, and licked a good amount of tofu based "cream cheese", too! I had to rip my toast in half...human side and cat side...🤣🤣🤣

This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »

cherokeepatti · 61-69, F

Every Siamese i had would crave one strange food. One would always watch up eat slices of watermelon in the summer and she would wait till we had abandoned our plates and then drink the juice up. She wouldn’t even drink milk but craved watermelon juice. Another ate a banana when I peeled one and it fell on the floor, couldn’t believe it and she was well-fed. So I gave her some bananas to eat once in a while. Another one like to eat a single M & M when i dropped it on the floor or would beg for a tiny corner of a Hershey bar, just a taste is what he wanted. And another Siamese would eat biscuits, homemade or from the cans, but only if she could steal them. She would sniff at any that I offered to her and walk away but if she could steal them she would eat 4 or 5 if they were left unguarded in the pan.

UnderLockDown · M

@cherokeepatti "but only if she could steal them."
Made me laugh.😆 I've had a cat like that.

cherokeepatti · 61-69, F

@UnderLockDown I had to stick those biscuits up on to of the refrigerator to keep her out of them. Nothing near it to jump on and then jump on top of it. She would do it every single time if I didn’t do that. She even watched my ex with his plate on a stool in the living room, caught him looking the tv. I was behind them and watched her eyes, when he was distracted she put her paw up to the plate, hooked a biscuit and silently slid it down off of his plate. My laughing made him ask what happened and I told him. That cat looked like something out of a cartoon show they way she did it

4meAndyou · F

@cherokeepatti Your pet stories are always amazing!

cherokeepatti · 61-69, F

@4meAndyou I could have written a short book about that damn cat.

4meAndyou · F

@cherokeepatti You should...about ALL your cats...and call it Kool Cats I have known and loved...😉

cherokeepatti · 61-69, F

@4meAndyou You wouldn’t laugh if your Siamese cat f*cked a skunk. She came up missing for 3 days and I kept smelling a skunk at night outside.After 3 days she came to the door and meowed, she was hungry. I looked at her and said “My baby!” And picked up up and then threw her back down because she stunk so bad.

cherokeepatti · 61-69, F

Oh shut up, UnderLockdown.

4meAndyou · F

@cherokeepatti Was the skunks name Pepe Le Pew????🤣🤣🤣

cherokeepatti · 61-69, F

@4meAndyou I know how that cartoon idea originated.

4meAndyou · F

@cherokeepatti 🤣🤣🤣 I don't envy you having to bathe the skunk off a cat. 😳

I've got to go and eat something...I am seeing lightnings in from of my eyes.