This post may contain Mildly Adult content.
Mildly AdultRandom
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Watched the 1984 BBC film Threads, a realistic depiction of living through nuclear war


This is far from any of the usual end of the world melodramas. Unknown actors, no heroics. A science based walk through of what you could most likely expect, including the unrelenting Nuclear Winter.

What made it all the more powerful for me is the first half hour is just showing regular everday people going through their mundane lives. Doing the normal things we do every day. It's almost boring at this point. But when the bombs drop and we see what happens to them it drives the horror home even stronger. Because we can identify these people so easily as ourselves.
I think some of the nightmare images here will be etched on my brain forever.

Author and film historian Stephen Thrower:
" What even its critics had to admit was it told the truth in a totally unvarnished way about the actual genuine detail of the aftermath of a nuclear attack."

Top | New | Old
ArishMell · 70-79, M
Also read Attack Warning Red! - How Britain Prepared For Nuclear War, by Julia McDowall.

She states seeing the film on TV when really, too young to have watched it, made a lasting impression that finally found an outlet in this book, with a huge amount of research behind it.

It can be summed by adding [Did Not] to the sub-title.

She explains the official approach was often vague, kept changing and relied too heavily on memories of air-raids on British cities in WW2. Those were bad enough but the effects of a nuclear bomb are some orders of magnitude worse; and none of the civil-defence actions that worked then, would save many lives burned and irradiated by a thermonuclear explosion.

MacDowall also compares the British with the American public-information efforts, and although the US ones were more coherent and more publicised, schemes like the "Duck & Cover" drills in schools would still be ultimately futile. The most that cartoon turtle did, was terrify a lot of children - and some students apparently refused to perform them. I watched one of the films made for this, and found one or two aspects of it strangely eerie. The best protected civilians, it seems, of the countries' preparations the author found, may have been the Russians and the Swedes.

In discussing the films, Julia McDowell says the BBC was under considerable pressure from a frightened Government not to screen Threads, but did so eventually. The American one was released at about the same time, hoping to steal all the limelight - but failed miserably because Threads was by far the credible one. The author says The Day After presents rosy images such as sparkling clean hospitals working as if normal, but the review and awards audiences knew that would just not happen, and gave all the praise to Threads.


A much gentler but still chilling work of speculative fiction with a credible story line, is Raymond Briggs' When The Wind Blows . The author who gave us the children's Christmas The Snowman, here relates an elderly couple who emerge too early from their improvised blast shelter inside their house, into a bewildering world still and silent save for the wind, and covered in radioactive dust.... I have not read it, but have heard it dramatised very effectively on BBC Radio.
@ArishMell thank you for this, all really interesting.
Picklebobble2 · 56-60, M
It's an excellent movie.
And it doesn't pull it's punches.

There is a similar movie told from an American perspective.... can't quite recall the title I think it might be something like The day after tomorrow. Or similar.
Give me a minute I'll try and track it down.
Jason Robards stars and it's very good.

Oh there you go !
It's called The day after and it's from 1983.

Saw both these movies a year or so ago.
Available on YouTube
Picklebobble2 · 56-60, M
@robingoodfellow Threads is shot more in documentary style that's what makes it feel more visceral
ArishMell · 70-79, M
@Picklebobble2 More credible too, it seems. I have seen neither so can't give a proper critique of either; but MacDowell's assessment of them gives The Day After Tomorrow as stretching credibility too much; hence it gaining few awards.

She does not say so, but I wonder if it was made almost as propaganda, as if to show Americans they'd have nothing much to fear from nuclear weapons exploding above every city because they'd still have lots of gleaming hospitals staffed by gleaming Hollywood stars. Apart of course from being killed outright - though perhaps they'd be the lucky ones.....

Threads on the other hand, suggested terrible direct and longer-term results, so likely that the Government tried to prevent it being broadcast. Presumably it feared the drama might cause widespread panic.
Picklebobble2 · 56-60, M
@ArishMell Well we were deep into cold war politics at the time.
Also worth noting that the UK government hates anything remotely controversial when made or broadcast by the BBC, unless it shows them in a good light.
SW-User
I remember watching this when it came out. I've been waiting for it to happen ever since.
SW-User
Frightening, I have not watched the movie and I stay from these types of films. Some think we are on the brink of world war, I really feel the world is going to come down from whatever axis it is on, and if we collectively breathe, we are much more likely to find that collapse in threat of war.
@SW-User as I was watching I was thinking it was absolutely relevant for right now. And confirms what I already knew: getting annihilated at ground zero is a mercy. Living through it is what you need to fear.
SW-User
@robingoodfellow Yet, this is a time of much discord, discontent, and disorder. It's also much less than humanity experienced before. If we raise our spectre, we raise our emotions that create the conditions for war. If we place wood on a fire, what happens? I'm not saying being blind, but there is something I think that is a collective totality which if we don't raise our ire to those creating the fire, we no longer give wood onto that is their fire burning. That the collective in consciousness has a way of snuffing out the fire, too.

I can understand why you would find it relevant.
SW-User
@SW-User I totally get what you're saying here and agree!!
Piper · 61-69, F
I'd not heard of the film. As disturbing as it must surely be to watch, I appreciate knowing of it.
PhilDeep · 51-55, M
I remember hearing about this when I was a child. I'd like to see it, as terrifying as it sounds.
JSul3 · 70-79
Check out: White Light/ Black Rain: The Destruction of Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
AndysAttic · 56-60, M
I remember watching it. Unfortunately the aftermath is a complete sweetheart to what would really happen.
Thx, I added it to my saved list

 
Post Comment