Creative
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

It's strange how some bands can be so highly acclaimed despite not being very influential on other bands

I was just thinking about some major players from the '90s and while they may have been critically and commercially successful, they aren't really regarded as visionaries who changed the musical landscape. The Smashing Pumpkins are a good example. To quote one journalist: "Whereas Nirvana spawned countless mini-Nirvanas, the Pumpkins remain an island unto themselves." Red Hot Chili Peppers were instrumental in the development of rap rock and nu metal, but that's about it. Suede were the original Brtipop group, but they were immediately overshadowed by Blur, Oasis and Pulp.

You look back on all the old bands hailed as legendary today and a big reason why is the impact they made on music that can still be felt today. I guess it goes to show that one doesn't have to be some big music pioneer to be a hit or even to carry on a legacy. Rare as it may be... Can you think of any other older bands or artists whose music might have stood the test of time, but not for how musically innovative it was?
Top | New | Old
4thdimensiondream · 70-79, M
Pink Floyd has def stood the test of time but only a handful of bands today do anything like them. Steve Wilson and Riverside are 2 that come to mind. Progressive rock pretty much died with the end of the 70’s.
4thdimensiondream · 70-79, M
@HowtoDestroyAngels I thought she was looking for more influential bands. There really weren’t many like Floyd. There was many prog bands but even many prog fans debate if Floyd is part of the genre. Thanks.
4thdimensiondream · 70-79, M
@HowtoDestroyAngels I know nothing! I’m still stuck in the 70s! Cheers’
unregisteredhypercam4 · 22-25, M
@4thdimensiondream I completely agree with you, but just to play devil's advocate, there are bands that cite pink floyd as an inspiration. However, I have yet to find anyone else who truly does the same thing - why I used to want to be a musician.
HowtoDestroyAngels · 46-50, M
Soundgarden, Alice In Chains.
The 60's Britbands were highly inspired by 20's to 50's r&b Mississippi Delta and Memphis blues and rock.

 
Post Comment