Random
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Sound of Silence... Original or cover

Poll - Total Votes: 13
Five Finger Death Punch
Simon & Garfunckel
Show Results
You can only vote on one answer.
Which version do you like the best of The Sound of Silence?

For .me it's absolutely Five Finger Death Punch. I heard the song a thousand times probably and thought it was stupid. I never knew what the song was about until I heard FFDP' do there version .


FFDP ?
[media=https://youtu.be/u9Dg-g7t2l4?si=KSXOVY_PTNmgIjF2]


Or Simon & Garfunkel
[media=https://youtu.be/4fWyzwo1xg0?si=KBUqtFvfFOmEje35]
Top | New | Old
Iwillwait · M
Disturbed's version was so unexpectedly good that I am partial to hearing it, but the Original is, what it is, a "Masterpiece," in song writing.
JeNeSaisPas · 51-55, F
ninjavu · 56-60, M
It's by Disturbed, not FFDP.
ninjavu · 56-60, M
@goodlil666 😂 No worries. I played the Disturbed version over and over when I first heard it and told just about everyone I knew about it. I saw Draiman interviewed about it and it was cool how he and Simon talked about the Disturbed version.

Just wanted to make sure the right band got the credit.
goodlil666 · 56-60, M
@ninjavu Right, no doubt . I can't believe I was that hammered.

It is such a a powerful song it was meant to be sung with attitude and emotion.

What was Simon's take on Disturbed' s version?
ninjavu · 56-60, M
@goodlil666 Like a couple of people have said, the original will always be the masterpiece, but the Disturbed version is very powerful in how he interprets Simon's words.

I don't remember *exactly* how Simon reacted, but it was an email exchange. However, he was very positive and complimentary. I wish I could remember which talk show it was on, but maybe it was the Conan show that @LunadelobosIAMTHEDRAGON posted.
Gibbon · 70-79, M
The original. However I'll admit when I first heard Disturbs version I thought to myself that is one serious badass cover.
Both are masterpieces.

And Disturbed live on on Conan was better than the recorded version.

[media=https://youtu.be/Bk7RVw3I8eg]
Crazychick · 36-40, F
The Simon & Garfunkel video is not available in my country but I've heard it before anyway. It's a hell of a lot better than the Disturbed version. I haven't heard Five Finger Death Punch and I don't want to with a name like that.
goodlil666 · 56-60, M
@Crazychick Yeah that was my mistake , sorry . I was a little bit drunk when I posted that.
Ontheroad · M
The original by Simon & Garfunkel will always be my favorite, but I very much like the cover by Disturbed and also the cover by Pentatonix.

[media=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gdVjVtpr55M]
Crazychick · 36-40, F
@Ontheroad That version is weird.
goodlil666 · 56-60, M
@Crazychick I never understood the meaning of the song until I heard that version. That's the way it should have been done the first time. That song begs to sung with emotion and attitude. It one of my favorite covers of all time.
I don’t like how people use the Disturbed version. It’s background music for sanctimonious TikTok videos.
goodlil666 · 56-60, M
@LeopoldBloom I haven't seen any of those videos . But I seldom watch Tiktok videos.
Imsleepy · 31-35
Not a big fan of the song, but I like the Disturbed version better.
HumanEarth · F
The OG by S & G of course
Crazychick · 36-40, F
@HumanEarth OG? I thought that was an alien creature in Red Dwarf. Lol :)
goodlil666 · 56-60, M
DaveE54 · 56-60, M
Eh Disturbed for me
goodlil666 · 56-60, M
Sorry about mislabeling the Disturbed video, I was a bit hammered when I posted that.
NinaTina · 31-35, F
[media=https://youtu.be/id-ToEPO60Y]
LordShadowfire · 51-55, M
I didn't know FFDP did a version of it.
goodlil666 · 56-60, M
@LordShadowfire They didn't I was a lil hammered when I posted that. Sorry

 
Post Comment