Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

What would you do?

Poll - Total Votes: 17
I would tell him the boy is not his grandson.
I would keep my mouth shut. Let everyone be happy.
Show Results
You can only vote on one answer.
My wife and I watched a movie last night from the mid 1950's. You have to remember that back then being a unwed mother was seriously frowned upon and made you a social outcast. Okay, so here is what happened. This girl was a unwed mother. She went to Mexico to have the baby. Her friend had just gotten married to a rich man. She decided to give the baby to her friend to raise. The rich guys father didn't approve of the marriage and cut his son off. Shortly afterwards the new husband dies in a car crash. Five years go by. All of a sudden the rich father gets an anonymous phone call saying he has a grandson and his daughter in-law is a unfit mother. He has a private detective check into it and is told yes she does have a child, but he appears to be well taken care of. A month later he gets an anonymous letter saying he has a grandson and his daughter in-law is a unfit mother. The rich father in law is really mourning the death of his son and starts having talks with his daughter in-law. She let's him see the boy. Then the father in-law asks for custody of the boy. The daughter in-law is getting by, but that's all. He tells her he can give the boy everything. About this time the boys real mother shows back up and is murdered. The murdered woman's roommate is charged with the crime because they had a fight the day before the murder. Her lawyer eventually finds out the truth. That the murdered woman is really the boys mother. So now the boys real mother is dead. No one has a clue who the real father is. The rich father in law offers her $100,000 for custody of the boy. In today's money that would be millions of dollars. She accepts and signs over custody. The lawyer confronts the woman and about killing the real mother. She flees with the police on her tail and gets in a terrible car accident and is rushed to the hospital. The doctor, the lawyer, his assistant and the police are all in her room. The doctor tells her she is dying and asks if she has any last words. She admits to killing the woman, but doesn't tell the real reason. She opens her mouth to say the woman was the boys real mother and shuts up. In a last thought she saves the boy and secures his future. The lawyer and his assistant goes to see the rich father in law to tell him about his daughter in-law dying. They see the boy and how well he is being taken care of and how the rich father in law is showering him with love and attention. The assistant asks the lawyer if he is going to tell the rich father in law the boy is not his grandson. The lawyer says no.

What would you do? Would you tell the father in law the boy wasn't his grandson which would send him to an orphanage or would you let the grandfather keep believing the boy was his grandson and give him a wonderful loving home?
eyeno · M
I'd let sleeping dogs lie.
eyeno · M
@Stereoguy with all the hate in this world, love from others or anyone would always be the welcomed choice.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
Nimbus · M
@eyeno [image=https://giphy.com/clips/chuber-bark-lazy-barking-TVktRDyqObYNP3Putm]
I'd let it go. The boy deserves a good life and a secure future. Taking that away from him is cruel.

That story reminds me of an Egyptian movie from 2006 or 2005. It's different but som parts are similar. A simple guy who has a wife and a small child. He works as a security guard and witnesses a crime, some rich dude kills a guy.
The rich guy's father threatens the guard and tells him he'll pay him to lie while testifying in the court. The guard decides to be a hero and says the truth.
The rich guy's father kidnaps the wife of the guard and kills her.
The guard breaks into the rich guy's father villa and gets arrested and sent to prison where he serves 5 years.
The child goes to live with the guard's father in law.
5 years later the guard is out of prison and all he is thinking about is revenge. His father in law is against the idea and keeps telling him to move on and stay away from those people but he ends up helping the guard anyway and the guard ends up killing the rich guy's father in a self defense scenario he and his father in law plotted.
Dan193 · 31-35, M
I have to say you did a really goot job at retelling this movie. Also great story, I didn't imagine old movies to have this convoluted plots.
Regarding the ultimate decision, if it was up to me, and I trusted the assistant not to blow me up, I'd probably wouldn't say a thing either.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
Dan193 · 31-35, M
@Stereoguy Good, then it all works out.
I see on other replies u said that you would've chosen the same. What about your wife, what did she say?
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
Carissimi · 70-79, F
Following the Buddha’s teaching on “Right Speech: Is it true? Yes. Is is factual? Yes. Is it endearing? No. Will it be of benefit? No, it will cause harm and suffering to both. There is one more that I can’t remember, but the main three are if it’s true, factual, and beneficial, (and it’s the right time), you say it, but this isn’t of benefit to anyone, so remain silent. It has to be all three.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
Carissimi · 70-79, F
@Stereoguy The boy would also be hurt if the grandfather disowned him. Two people with broken hearts, and the boy’s life would be seriously altered. Sometimes even the truth should not be spoken.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
SledgeHammer · 46-50, M
This is some good movie pal..

What's the name of the movie?
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
toddr13 · 46-50, M
Let it go and allow the boy to be raised by the grandfather, to whom he may not be biologically related, but to whom he has an affinity and connection. Perhaps in time the benefactor grandfather could explain his origins, but in no way should custody be stripped from him, nor should be be insecure because of the actions of others who put him in that plight.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
carpediem · 61-69, M
I think I was fallen asleep before midway in the movie.
Jonjdw · 46-50, M
I would not say anything. Similar story I guess you could say. gone baby gone movie. But I’m gone baby gone the detective didn’t stay quiet. But it was a different story but similar.
Jonjdw · 46-50, M
@Stereoguy yes that’s it. He did promise to find the girl bring her back.
Jonjdw · 46-50, M
@Stereoguy but he was always helping the mom and the child.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
Let everyone Live one short life!
JustNik · 51-55, F
A bunch of imperfect people went out of their way to give this boy a good life. Their methods may be questionable, but sometimes I think you really have to let the thought count. Morality has its grays like everything else.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
TexChik · F
The boy just technically became the man's adopted grandson. The man is happy, and the boy is loved and now has a future. In this case the devil [i][b]is[/b][/i] in the details. Not today, Satan! Not today1
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
Sazzio · 31-35, M
I wanna watch the movie.

I watched Woman in a cage, Psycho and what really happened to Baby Jane? There was another one called Woman in a Window I believe, a really good twist plot in the end!
Jeephikelove · 46-50, F
Keep my mouth shut, that boy deserves to happy and loved not bounced from abusive foster home to abusive foster home.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
4meAndyou · F
No DNA baby daddy tests back in the 1950's. Sounds like all's well that ends well.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
sarabee1995 · 26-30, F
Great post! Noe I want to see the movie!

As for your question... None of my business. Let it be.
Jackaloftheazuresand · 26-30, M
It seems I'm the only honest one here. People deserve the truth especially from a professional like a lawyer
Jackaloftheazuresand · 26-30, M
@Stereoguy That doesn't mean he wouldn't be adopted in that time
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
Jackaloftheazuresand · 26-30, M
@Stereoguy There's no guarantee to anything not even the reason for lying. Honesty is the best policy no matter how hard it hurts because it respects you as a person. The lawyer just decides the grandfather should keep a kid who he might not otherwise. That's unfair to him. The kid going to an orphanage is what would happen just by virtue of existence.
GJOFJ3 · 61-69, M
The lawyer made the right decision
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
akindheart · 61-69, F
Whoa. What a plot
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
SweetMae · 70-79, F
I would not tell unless asked.
SW-User
This hits a bit close to home with a family member.....
That man "bought" the child. He used his money to influence the woman.... did he tell her how much better that child would be with someone who had more money?
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
SW-User
@Stereoguy I don't care about the man... was thinking about the child and how it all would be.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
This message was deleted by its author.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
This message was deleted by its author.

 
Post Comment