What's your favorite book to movie adaptation? Was it true to the original?

Lord of the Rings, for me. So well done. Seems like its very difficult to do well, though.

This Dark Tower adaptation looks like a stinker. What a shame it's a fantastic series.

This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »

Hanging2 · 51-55, M

Did't like the way they portrayed Gimli in the movies. Especially the Dwarf tossing side gag when they were at the gates of Helms Deep. They did capture the quintessential relationship between Sam and Frodo very well.

DanielChristensen · 46-50, M

@Hanging2 Those are excellent points.