Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

why does society celebrate christmas if there is no proven evidence of jesus's birth on the 24th or 25th?

something i've always questioned is if there is no evidence jesus was born on december 24th or 25th.why do we celebrate christmas on the 24th or 25th if it isn''t proven that jesus was even born on december 24th or 25th?
Top | New | Old
Semen · 18-21, M
JohnnySpot · 56-60, M
Punxi · F
Some believe He was conceived on March 25. Also believed to be the dat of His crucifixion.

March 26 + 9 months.

December 25.

Sol Invictus: The Roman festival of the "Unconquered Sun," is also associated with December 25.

Some historians believe the Christian Church selected December 25 to provide a Christian meaning to an already culturally significant winter date, making the transition from pagan traditions to Christianity easier.
swirlie · 31-35, F
Historians do not know when Jesus was born, but it is estimated that his birth was actually in 4 BC, not zero BC.

The reason it was 4 BC is because an error in calculation was made back in the day, which had originally made the calendar year 'zero' to coincide with the birth of Jesu.

The error that was made however, was one of mathematical calculation at the time, since there is no recorded evidence of an actual 'date' existing, since date calendars did not exist at the time of Jesus. This miscalculation of math actually puts the birth of Jesus coinciding with a date between 4 BC and 6 BC.

Further to that, it was determined that Jesus was conceived on what would be March 25th on the Roman calendar, to which they added 9 months of incubation to and arrived at December 25th being the birth date of Jesus, in whatever year that might have been in reality.
Why does it matter. It's the consensus to celebrate it on this day...
Murmurs · 36-40, F
Conspiracy theorists/anti-Christians (especially anti Catholics) like to say it's because just aligned with existing winter festival traditions (the Romans counted the 25th December as the Winter Solstice, also the birthday of 'sol invictus' and Christians just built a new festival on the same date).

No one actually knows when Jesus was born for certain, but the fact there were (as per the nativity story in Luke) shepherds in the fields, it probably wasn't December - more like spring time (so ironically, more around the date of Easter).

But it doesn't matter really. If Christians (and others culturally influenced by them, like the modern western world) are going to have any date to celebrate the coming of light into the world, it seems very poetically powerful to do it at the darkest time of year (in the northern hemisphere where the religion came from, anyway). Late December is symbolically ideal, and since we don't know the actual date, it's the most fitting one.

But if it troubles you, you can always have a big festival with feasting and a tree on 25th December - celebrating Isaac Newton or Humphrey Bogart's birthday instead. Or, indeed, mine ;)
MrVintage71 · 51-55, M
@Murmurs I need you at my parties,your views on the world,just leave me in awe!!! Awesome lady to know
GoFish ·
pagan catholic influence
helenoftroy2000 · 22-25, F
we dont really celebrate Christmas, and everything is a figment of your imagination
Convivial · 26-30, F
Because like many other Christian holidays it was hijacked from previous festivals and other religions and beliefs
Scroffington · 46-50, M
Because that's not how festivals or culture or religion works. Nobody knows Jesus' birthday. It's celebrated because it's the winter solstice and the people the Christians were converting already had celebrations at that time of year.
NinaTina · 31-35, F
I don't care as lost as I get a nice Xmas present🙏
jarrod73 · 51-55, M
It’s just a day that we set aside, to reflect on the birth of Christ. It doesn’t have to be the exact day or the exact month.

 
Post Comment